[FNZ] Role Madness Final Fantasy XVI Mafia - Game Thread
- Thread starter Ratchet
- Start date
- Status
Well, I'm accustomed to faction kills being explicitly stated to be faction kills. That's why I'm second guessing what implications this would have.
Because if this was in fact not a mafia kill then it might imply that both red and Luka is tracker.
The thing that kind of makes me wonder is if Red would lie about having tracked LM, when Luka claims to have seen him visit LM to kind of back up his claim.
I think if there's a vig they should claim the shot on LM
Because if this was in fact not a mafia kill then it might imply that both red and Luka is tracker.
The thing that kind of makes me wonder is if Red would lie about having tracked LM, when Luka claims to have seen him visit LM to kind of back up his claim.
I think if there's a vig they should claim the shot on LM
You have to accept that we either receive a hint or nothing by the WU.
If we receive, then we can consided Melkor a protective role, and if not, it's not important at all.
I don't expect that the WU should tell us that mafia had a kill.
If any townie killed Melkor, they should claim, otherwise I consider that an effect of the mafia factional, either direct on him (first option) or on a player Melkor defended (if I trust the WU as a hint).
If we receive, then we can consided Melkor a protective role, and if not, it's not important at all.
I don't expect that the WU should tell us that mafia had a kill.
If any townie killed Melkor, they should claim, otherwise I consider that an effect of the mafia factional, either direct on him (first option) or on a player Melkor defended (if I trust the WU as a hint).
It was a early vibe read. That's why he was slight townie categorized. You said yourself that you're a vibe player in early game. Your view on me is biased by the fact that Yoho turned to be scum and that I claimed tracking Melkor last night. I don't think I'm experienced enough to understand what went wrong with the situation. You're exactly saying what Emil said yesterday I know that I'm not in a good position. Well, I'll try to make abstraction of my own situation to leave a legacy.
Another question worth asking, is why would scum target Melkor’s slot? I don’t recall him hinting at a particular PR. And he wasn’t super town leaning either. Which makes me think two possibilities that are more likely.
A. Scum are relatively cowardly. And wanted to pick someone unlikely to have the attention of a protection role. But why play conservative after you’ve just lost a day 1 lynch? You’re already behind the 8 ball. You need to be bold as scum when you’re falling behind. Otherwise the town will out confirm town leans faster than you can deal with it. And you’ll be exposed as the odd man out of a town block.
B. Melkor was a protection role that required some degree of risk to use. Like a bodyguard. The scum did go for a more juicy target last night, and Melkor got killed instead. This seems the stronger play from scum. Just unlucky for them Melkor did his job.
A. Scum are relatively cowardly. And wanted to pick someone unlikely to have the attention of a protection role. But why play conservative after you’ve just lost a day 1 lynch? You’re already behind the 8 ball. You need to be bold as scum when you’re falling behind. Otherwise the town will out confirm town leans faster than you can deal with it. And you’ll be exposed as the odd man out of a town block.
B. Melkor was a protection role that required some degree of risk to use. Like a bodyguard. The scum did go for a more juicy target last night, and Melkor got killed instead. This seems the stronger play from scum. Just unlucky for them Melkor did his job.
- Status