Just did a quick search and this came up:
وفيه أن الذي أخبر سلمان بصفة النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم وبشره به هو عيسى ابن مريم عليه السلام .
ولكن هذا الحديث منكر ، وإسناده ضعيف لجهالة راويه عن عمر بن عبد العزيز ، وجهالة من رواه عنه عمر .


This gave me pause, since most Muslims don't use that with Salman.

Also, Ibn Ishaq was more of collector of oral tradition regardless of what is true or not, not everything he wrote down is taken as authentic.
Yeah Ibn Ishaq was more of a compiler of narratives. A good rule.of thumb is if Bukhari and/or Muslim don't have a narration to take it with a big grain of salt.

Tgere's also Sunan from ibn ebi Davud, but Bukhari and Muslim are the primary sources.
 

Apollo

The Sol King
They don't know what they believe in since unlike us, they aren't centralised and didn't have someone like Al Amir al Said(GBHS) whose interpretations is mostly agreed on
What do you think of the 40 years rule to learn of the religion?

@Midnight Delight @Apollo chances Tehran falls this month?
Without Israeli/American intervention? 1%.
With intervention, idk. Maybe Iran pulls out a dirty bomb with all the uranium or maybe they fall before that.
 
We truly live in interesting times.
Iran about to get regime changed, Murica vs NATO war, each and any Central and South American country on the chopping block.

There's not enough GMO maize for all the popcorn needed to soak up all the blood that will be spilled.
 
What do you think of the 40 years rule to learn of the religion?


Without Israeli/American intervention? 1%.
With intervention, idk. Maybe Iran pulls out a dirty bomb with all the uranium or maybe they fall before that.
Apparently the ayatollah is already planning to flee like bashar
 
Top