Role Madness Harry Potter: A World Of Wizardry Game Thread

[Luka]

What?

youre a mafia and you randomly hoped itt voting am

 

[Ultra]

His reasoning being bad is a legitimate point if you expect him to approach this situation differently as town, so that's a fair point. I just don't think the "get excited about Mugen coming in with a case and joining" is likely to be a scum thought process from your average WG'er. Sounds like he's just town and being open to suggestion.

 

[MUUGEN]

Wdym i'm confident hes town

& what makes you confident did you even see his reactions/claim?

 

[Charlie]

Particularly for point 3 - why do you see this as necessarily scummy? Presumably scum PG would have plenty of options in the plethora of stragglers that he could easily defer off Ekko after a cop claim. It's easier and safer if he's scum to just play kick the can, generally. I think him needing to vote Ekko out of necessity is a bad assumption. In fact I think if he's scum I'd probably assume he's more likely aligned with Ekko and doesn't understand why his positioning here looks bad lol

weren't you the one using math arguments earlier? like, even if we went in completely blind idk how many people are alive exactly, let's take 25

like, even if we went in completely blind

1/24 (-pot)
vs
6/22 (-pot, -ekko, -yoho)

4% chance of ekko being voldemort vs 27% chance of anyone else being scum

and this doesn't exclude people like me, flower, ratchet, etc.

this reasoning makes no sense - what's the point of investigators if you'd go and lynch innocent person anyway, because there's 4% chance they're immune to investigation

 

[MUUGEN]

Muugen, replacement of poe who haven't read shet fakes mech on someone - let's follow!

whoever said i had mech, thats a false convoluted lie from kek to make himself look "good", ultra pointed that right away chuck.

 

[MUUGEN]

He wasn't interested in reading Polar iirc

lol so they are mates then.

 

[Seraphoenix]

youre a mafia and you randomly hoped itt voting am

lol? I didn't randomly vote for him. I was on Ekko at first before he and others vouched for him.

You're talking like you come and provide anything

 

[MUUGEN]

Fake claims are provided by Fuji

so you agree kek gave a fake claim provided by the host?

 

[Flower]

whoever said i had mech, thats a false convoluted lie from kek to make himself look "good", ultra pointed that right away chuck.

Well, Charlie has mech that Ekko is good.
And I know Charlie is good.

 

[MUUGEN]

Gotta find whoever said "scum is probably inactive" and see if they blindly followed Muugen, who's subbed for inactive

no one followed me they followed ultra and then realized how horrid keks claim is

 

[Ultra]

weren't you the one using math arguments earlier? like, even if we went in completely blind idk how many people are alive exactly, let's take 25

like, even if we went in completely blind

1/24 (-pot)
vs
6/22 (-pot, -ekko, -yoho)

4% chance of ekko being voldemort vs 27% chance of anyone else being scum

and this doesn't exclude people like me, flower, ratchet, etc.

this reasoning makes no sense - what's the point of investigators if you'd go and lynch innocent person anyway, because there's 4% chance they're immune to investigation

I'm not arguing your point, I'm arguing against applying strict reasoning to a player's thought process here as a good way to catch scum. Possible you expect PG to be more rigorous here but town get carried away with high fantasy pretty often. Again, my model for what scum PG would do here is probably just the routine scum reaction - accept your claim and move on to a different push without trying to rock the boat. The exception to this is in case where he basically has to provide resistance to Ekko specifically or he loses, and I just don't think thats likely here.

Nonetheless I would chalk my confidence in Pot here as maybe 60%, not great but think it's not the way id prefer

 

[Charlie]

lol? I didn't randomly vote for him. I was on Ekko at first before he and others vouched for him.

You're talking like you come and provide anything

what he says is that you hopped on him when his wagon started gaining fraction, not "after people vouched for him"

 

[Ultra]

If AM is not scum I'd say cap Kekko immediatey by the way

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Why is blud liking that post.

You're really asking why the "chills 🥶" guy is liking incriminating posts against him?

 

[Flower]

Veto the Ekko lynch today.
Worst case he's Voldy and then we can't off him anyway.
Not a today issue.

 

[Charlie]

so you agree kek gave a fake claim provided by the host?

no, you have problem reading

if Ekko was town, his role pm would use word wolf

if Ekko was scum, his role pm would include fake claim which would use word wolf

meaning you're making argument out of what's literally nai

 

[Ultra]

@Charlie would also say a 4% chance of getting a misread is extremely generous when you account for Bus Drivers, Lawyers (I believe someone's flip basically confirmed this role)

Which is not to say your info should be tossed, just fact checking you

 

[Charlie]

@Charlie would also say a 4% chance of getting a misread is extremely generous when you account for Bus Drivers, Lawyers (I believe someone's flip basically confirmed this role)

Which is not to say your info should be tossed, just fact checking you

everyone who was in night chat, Pot included, knows my actions last night couldn't be redirected

 

[Pot Goblin]

and usually u love mech. ud be willing to let me confirm my kill once the vig dies but instead you want to yeet me with an innocent check on me. doesnt sound like town pot to me

When was the last time I cared about mech like this? If anything you tryin to use that scan despite thos bein a rm bastard game says a lot more. Usually you hate being scanned because you like to get solved through game play

 

[MUUGEN]

think muugen is insanely cowardish to come at me like this and stick with it as scum. would yeet him anyway cuz hes gonna be detriment asfk regardless of his alignment. if he wanna play like a prick hes gonna be treated like one

so you would yeet potenial vig, based off of your calcs i must be vig if not scum?