Role Madness Harry Potter: A World Of Wizardry Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Charlie

Charlie

‎
#2,705
#2,705
Ratchet said:
A Tracker isn't a claim that can just be dismissed out of hand. Generally, lynching investigative roles before they've had any investigations is suboptimal play, because if you're wrong, you lose information, and if you're right, you're not losing much by giving them a night, and their choice of targets could be informative.

And while it's true that a scum mate certainly could be doing that, I point to the fact that this claim came so late in the day that it was running the risk of not mastering, and indeed, did not matter in the end. If I'm going to look for a way to pivot off my mate, then I'm going to ask him to claim soon enough so I can do so. And if he doesn't, then I have no reason to move off of him. Eventually, it becomes untenable. Now you might not agree that I would always play it that way, but you have played enough games with me to know that I'm not a bad scum player- my actions as scum are going to be geared towards engineering an advantageous position for my team. So unless you can argue a plausible angle in which my actions were as such yesterday, then I think at the very least, any read on me should be "more likely town than scum".
Click to expand...
I see you. You're "more likely town than scum" for me personally btw, just not Town locked
 
Pot Goblin

Pot Goblin

Heisenbunny
‎
#2,710
#2,710
Ratchet said:
A Tracker isn't a claim that can just be dismissed out of hand. Generally, lynching investigative roles before they've had any investigations is suboptimal play, because if you're wrong, you lose information, and if you're right, you're not losing much by giving them a night, and their choice of targets could be informative.

And while it's true that a scum mate certainly could be doing that, I point to the fact that this claim came so late in the day that it was running the risk of not mastering, and indeed, did not matter in the end. If I'm going to look for a way to pivot off my mate, then I'm going to ask him to claim soon enough so I can do so. And if he doesn't, then I have no reason to move off of him. Eventually, it becomes untenable. Now you might not agree that I would always play it that way, but you have played enough games with me to know that I'm not a bad scum player- my actions as scum are going to be geared towards engineering an advantageous position for my team. So unless you can argue a plausible angle in which my actions were as such yesterday, then I think at the very least, any read on me should be "more likely town than scum".
Click to expand...
That's a good point, if you're on a team and one of your fellas is pretty much done for scum ratchet would have no problem going with the flow on that unless it was worth the risk. That choose your own character game not too long ago comes to mind.
 
Charlie

Charlie

‎
#2,718
#2,718
@Pot Goblin

you haven't killed York to get into event thing, right? :O it was like this at eod

1. Alexis2282AE (3)
2. Crowned Witch (3)

3. Pot Goblin (2)
3. York (2)

Yoho/Mr. Reloaded/Flower/Sir Yasheen/Seraphoenix/Ultra (1)

Mr. Reloaded: Sir Yasheen > Alexis2282AE > Ultra
York: York
Alexis2282AE: Alexis2282AE
The Orca: Alexis2282AE
Alwaysmind: Yoho
Yoho: Alexis2282AE > York
Pot Goblin: Pot Goblin
Jaguark101: Mr. Reloaded
Charlie: Crowned Witch
Crowned Witch: Crowned Witch
Michelle: Crowned Witch
Destroya: Pot Goblin
Flower: Flower
Sir Yasheen: Sir Yasheen
Seraphoenix: Seraphoenix
Crying bc no Cryo: Alexis2282AE
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top