Speculations How the flying duck did Tama get to Onigashima?

[dirtyLarry]

I'll quote myself from the actual chapter thread:

"Nobody can come up with a convincing explanation how an 8-year old girl and her gigantic dog can somehow suddenly appear on the battlefield in Onigashima.

She couldn't have "sneaked" on a ship, since she would've had to hide that massive dog from hundreds of other people on actually rather small ships. Let's be honest, that's ridiculous.

She couldn't have tamed a bird to fly her over, since - once again - that bird would've had to carry her dog, too. That means that bird would've been dragon-sized and easily spotted by Kaido & Co. on the rooftop.

Some wildcard character helping her is also a bit far-fetched. She just got back to the Tengu, who was adamant on keeping her out of trouble. Which "friendly" character would actually support an 8-year old girl to take part in a brutal slaughterfest? Not even Luffy & Co. would be that bold/supportive here."

So I'm asking you guys, what do you think? How will Oda explain her suddenly appearing out of nowhere?

 

[HA001]

Blueno

 

[DarkWitch]

I'm guessing that she probably had Babanuki or some other SMILE user take her to Onigashima.

 

[Fuckthis3]

Oda

 

[Seth]

Plot inconsistency sama

 

[stealthblack]

Nomatter how You spin IT, tama makes no sense whatsoever. Oda forcing another sugar, but this time on luffys side

 

[MarineHQ]

Trash piece writing

 

[Luffy bin Dragon]

as @KiriNigiri stated the Komainu is a Shinto shrine it could have the ability turn into stone and could go unnoticed like a normal statue

 

[Veljko]

Dog swims?

 

[Midnight Delight]

Plot Plot No Mi

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

One word

 

[Finalbeta]

Isn't she always portrayed to adventure a lot? She always steps into the danger IIRC.

So this time was no different, but luck wants she managed to act like a little saviour here.

That was completely and undeniably unexpected to me.

 

[BakiDou]

There are several options:
1. The dog has a flying devil fruit.
2. The dog knows sky walk.
3.The dog can use instant transmission(dbz ripoff).
JK, it is just trashpiece.

 

[Chrono]

The dog probably swam there. Dogs can swim....and this is a giant one.

 

[CbShadow]

The dog probably swam there. Dogs can swim....and this is a giant one.

For once we are in an agreement.

 

[Seth]

The dog probably swam there. Dogs can swim....and this is a giant one.

Imagine if King kicked off the BMP ship and it landed straight on Tama's head.

 

[Chrono]

Imagine if King kicked off the BMP ship and it landed straight on Tama's head.

Good riddance then. Get rid 2 Memes

 

[Luffy bin Dragon]

The dog swam to Onigashima and because The Komainu is a Shinto statue it could be able to turn into stone. The BP were drunk I doubt they would notice.

 

[KiriNigiri]

I'll add what I said in the chapter discussion thread.

We will get a full explanation on how she and her Komainu snuck in. Besides which, I can suspend my disbelief on stuff like people not noticing a giant Komainu. It's One Piece. It isn't above stretching things for the sake of plot and comedy. But if we need an explanation, a Komainu is a shinto shrine statue.

It wouldn't surprise me if her Komainu has the ability to turn into stone, or just pretend to be one. From the perspective of anyone on an Alliance ship, there are more important things to worry about than who put a statue on their ship.

And Tama is training to be a Ninja. Is it insane to say she might have developed some techniques on her own to help hide herself or her dog?

Because of all these different paths Oda can take, I'm gonna wait for his explanation on the matter.

I'd also like to include Carribou to the discussion. There's no reason Tama can't learn about his ability to transport people inside him. She was there at Udon when he was being congratulated by Raizo. The real question would be how she convinced him to help if that's the case.

 

[Rej]

dunno why people blame the plot or the writing, that is stupid

I expected Tama to appear and it was teased because it was mentioned that she is useful in this war. I will trust Oda to explain this well, I will give Oda one chance, if neccessary 10 chances to explain.