General & Others How to know if a theory is wrong.

[Gear5PhoenixMan]

If the theory makes sense, has evidence to support it, and would make the story better then that theory is wrong.

If a theory has very vague evidence or none at all, and derails the plot of the story then it is much more likely to be true.

Oda doesn't like people guessing his theories. How do you make the plot unpredictable? By making stupid decisions and poor writing choices.

In video games pros sometimes can't predict bad players because they make bad unpredictable decisions.

 

[milluki]

If you think OP is unpredictable then stay away from HxH

 

[Gear5PhoenixMan]

If you think OP is unpredictable then stay away from HxH

stfu im talking about theories dumb fuck.

No one thought Luffy was going to have a new devilfruit name before Oda hinted at it.

No one thought Luffy was going to have Toon Power.

 

[Kiri D Bachi]

stfu im talking about theories dumb fuck.

No one thought Luffy was going to have a new devilfruit name before Oda hinted at it.

No one thought Luffy was going to have Toon Power.

And how many people thought Luffy will have G2 or G3 before the very chapter it happened? How many hints, evidence, theories were there about it?

And there you are, wanking HxH, a Manga with twists that are so random that there is even no point in theorizing, but somehow your OP theory being wrong makes Oda shit writer, and OP being unpredictable makes it a bad story.

 

[Gear5PhoenixMan]

And how many people thought Luffy will have G2 or G3 before the very chapter it happened? How many hints, evidence, theories were there about it?

And there you are, wanking HxH, a Manga with twists that are so random that there is even no point in theorizing, but somehow your OP theory being wrong makes Oda shit writer, and OP being unpredictable makes it a bad story.

No theories being wrong don't make a bad story. Bad writing makes a bad story. Stop reading one piece if you're that dumb.

 

[Kiri D Bachi]

No theories being wrong don't make a bad story. Bad writing makes a bad story. Stop reading one piece if you're that dumb.

I'm not the one constantly ranting about how OP is bad and how Oda is a shit writer, why should I be the one to stop reading it? You are the one who clearly doesn't like it, you should stop reading it. You will probably be happier and less frustrated because you won't have any more theories that will end up wrong.

 

[Finalbeta]

Sometimes we can sadly only postulate things that look more logical