I am very confused due to inconsistency in this forum

[Erkan12]

Garp the fist said this to me;

Erkan12,

Your actions in this message (How powerful is SSG ?) are not appropriate:


We cannot allow users to be abusive, overly aggressive, threatening, or to "troll". This does not follow our rules. Your message may have been removed or altered.

Your account's access may be limited based on these actions. Please keep this in mind when posting or using our site.


I deleted your message because calling Mihawk, in your first post in the thread, "pathetic", is troll behaviour. Saying it's stronger than Mihawk is fine, character bashing isn't. If you have any ideas for improving the forum take them up with the staff, but juvenile attempts at starting trolling matches by insulting characters is not improving it in any respect.

And I said this;

Are you following this forum? Zorofanboys do that all the time, especially when it comes to Shanks, Sanji, Blackbeard etc. They say worse things than ''pathetic''...

I would like to see what other moderators think about this, because this doesn't make sense, if all other moderators think like this I will leave this forum for being inconsistent towards the other fans who are not zorofanboys.

If this is the case, that saying ''pathetic'' to a fictional character such as mihawk is forbidden then I am done, because Zorofanboys do that all the time to other characters such as Shanks, Sanji, Blackbeard etc. and I can't accept this inconsistency towards the other fans who are not Zorofanboys or Admiralfans.

I would like to see what other people think, depending on their answer I will end my time in this forum.

@Bogard @TheAncientCenturion and the users like @True God Moe @comrade @Chaves @Yo Tan Wa

 

[comrade]

Shishio has done worse. I think bashing a character a bit is ok. It's a fictional character, not someone's mom. Lol.

 

[Erkan12]

Shishio has done worse. I think bashing a character a bit is ok. It's a fictional character, not someone's mom. Lol.

Yeah, that's my problem. Other people does that worse.

 

[Bogard]

Moderators can have different perceptions. I think it could have been better to ask it to @Garp the Fist directly. With that said, I usually let trolling go, except when it becomes repetive. In that case, I give a warning to the user. Shishio in question even almost already got banned in the previous version of the forum for repetitive attempt, but here we offer a greater chance for users to redeem themselves with the Udon system

 

[True God Moe]

Garp the fist said this to me;



And I said this;



If this is the case, that saying ''pathetic'' to a fictional character such as mihawk is forbidden then I am done, because Zorofanboys do that all the time to other characters such as Shanks, Sanji, Blackbeard etc. and I can't accept this inconsistency towards the other fans who are not Zorofanboys or Admiralfans.

I would like to see what other people think, depending on their answer I will end my time in this forum.

@Bogard @TheAncientCenturion and the users like @True God Moe @comrade @Chaves @Yo Tan Wa

Don't leave the website, Dude. Your still appreciated by many others.

I do agree we need fair treatment allowed instead of selective punishing one side, but not the other as it won't be balance website and the trolling won't stop from one side if favouritism is put on this. Got do same to the others or none at all to show fairness around if they do same actions as well.

 

[Garp the Fist]

I'll give my perspective, since I'm the one who's being questioned

I don't look on every thread, sorry, don't have the time for it. If a thread catches my attention I'll jump on, if a thread is reported I'll look at it.

In this case I looked at the thread out of interest, and the very first reply was along the lines of "stronger than pathetic Mihawk."

I don't think that's conductive to any good conversation. I think that's just an attempt at starting a flame baiting war. Now, maybe I could have done differently. Just edited out "pathetic" and left the post as stands, because there's absolutely nothing wrong with thinking SSG is stronger than Mihawk. That's something for me to consider in the future.

Now, if you have complaints about other occasions, report them. The staff will try and deal with them. I'll let you know, Erkan, that I've personally seen complaints about you that's I've just let go because I've felt everyone in the thread is having a bit of a trolling fest and nobody can be singled out. In this case, I thought I could cut off trolling early on and keep the thread on track.

 

[Gol D. Roger]

If you have any issues regarding the way things are handled in the community. Please feel free to approach the staff members via PM. I think @Garp the Fist has made his stance clear and his reasoning was sound. If you're still not satisfied with his answer. You may approach @TheAncientCenturion via PM to discuss this further!

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

The crux of the issue is that each moderator has their own perspective, as @Bogard mentioned, on what would make this forum the most enjoyable for its users. It’s a very new website and we’re still all blending our different styles as we move forward. We definitely don’t want anyone or a fandom here to think they’re being unfairly targeted, that’s not an attitude we carry.

I’ll apologize for probably causing the most confusion with rule enforcement, I’m likely the most lenient when it comes to material I delete or alter. I’m actually fairly certain I’ve allowed worse by everyone in this thread. I personally think the banter, like yours, is fine so long as it doesn’t get too toxic, derails a topic or leads to unneeded antagonism. But again that’s my particular style and we’re all coming together to blend our perspectives here.

I can't accept this inconsistency towards the other fans who are not Zorofanboys or Admiralfans.

You should go to the Zoro temple and ask exactly what they think of me as a moderator lol. They share the same opinion as you, but they say I’m unfair toward Sanji fans and biased against them.