Controversial If One piece has a great ending, will it be the best shonen ever?

[Gaimon The Pirate]

To be the best Shonen all it needs to do is not having a horrible ending.
All the others already shit the bed and Miura died.

I mean, Slam DUnk already exists and cannot be topped..

 

[MonsterKaido]

Some will say yes, I'd be one of the ones to say no. I personally think Bleach is better. Though I'd be surprised if OP got a good ending considering how long it's been going on for.

Bleach top 1

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Bleach top 1

The Style of Bleach is quite peculiar, and I think among the big 3 was the more stylish and COOL.
But the lack of plot and the absolute shit arcs really weight it down.
I will say that I read with more pleasure Bleach than Naruto.

 

[BattalGazi]

Yes but i have never seen a shounen with a decent ending.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Yes but i have never seen a shounen with a decent ending.

Dragonball, slum dunk, FMA?

 

[BattalGazi]

Dragonball, slum dunk, FMA?

Slam dunk was just depressing even today i want a collage version of it where hanamichi comes back, rukawa got the all the glory. Give me a basketball team which is based on Sendoh and Hanamichi. Dragonball is just meh not good at all FMA is bitter sweet i guess.

 

[Least Pirates]

Fuck no, top 5 maybe but Slam Dunk and Naruto I can say are definitely better. I slandered Naruto HARD during its run but Wano made the 4th shinobi war look like a masterpiece

 

[vikas]

Probably not.
I would say it would just be a relief that it did not wen to super shit(we know its already on shit track now).

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Slam dunk was just depressing even today i want a collage version of it where hanamichi comes back, rukawa got the all the glory. Give me a basketball team which is based on Sendoh and Hanamichi. Dragonball is just meh not good at all FMA is bitter sweet i guess.

Slam Dunk ending is great.
Hanamichi understands what he likes in life, Rukawa understands what really is to be a leader, Akagi wins his battle..
They win an impossible battle in an impossible tournament, it's the opposite of depressing. It's happy, it shows that winning is not all, and that there is the next time to look for, that's what sport is.
But going back to topic, the claim was "no shonen" ever had a decent ending, and these 3 had.

Post automatically merged: Jun 30, 2023

Fuck no, top 5 maybe but Slam Dunk and Naruto I can say are definitely better. I slandered Naruto HARD during its run but Wano made the 4th shinobi war look like a masterpiece

One Piece is still miles ahead of Naruto and Sasuke fighting without a reason in the end, or kaguya.