Speculations If you could change the Wano match-ups, what would you have done?

#1
I was thinking about how I would've rearranged the Wano fight match-ups if I had the choice, and I was wondering what other people would've liked to see.

Personally, I thoroughly enjoyed the teamwork aspect of the 5 SN vs Kaido and Big Mom. They kind of teased that they were going to split up into 1 group vs Big Mom and 1 group vs Kaido but instead we got Kaido taking on the gauntlet and then getting Luffy in a 1v1 whereas we did get a team battle with BM but poor Killer was not allowed in the club.

I thought it was pretty disrespectful of Oda to have Killer be presented like he was on the rooftop and fare as well as he did and then get fucking Hawkins as his fight who belongs in the same category of walking L that Jack does. Also, why the fuck did Sanji fight Queen? Terrible match up and Sanji got his PU so early in the fight that he took a fat shit on Queen for the most part after that.

I also would have removed the scabbards vs. Kaido and only have the rooftop 5 having fought him so he wouldn't be as worn down by the time it gets to the final match-ups.

So this is how I probably would have wanted it:

Luffy, Zoro and Yamato vs. Kaido - All out ACoC battle where all three of them having reasons to want to take down Kaido (take a step closer towards PK, free wano, avenge Yasuie & ebisu town people). I also think this would've eased some of the tension about Luffy ascending to Yonko level too quickly and would've left more room for growth later. I.E. going from taking out a Yonko in a 3v1 vs in a 1v1...if Oda really wants to give Luffy all the shine he could mostly just have Yamato and Zoro reach their limits while Luffy delivers the final few blows

Kid, Law & Killer vs Big Mom - I think adding Killer to this fight really would have pushed Big Mom to properly go all out and risk a huge portion of her life span with some crazy shit. Also Killer got disrespected and fuck that

Sanji vs King - Sanji hasn't had a proper 1v1 in so long so I didn't want to put him in the team battles because even if it would've been hype to fight a Yonko he wouldn't really get credit all for himself. Plus the 6 people above already fought either Kaido, Big Mom or both so I wanted to stick to those people. Anyway King is a much better match for Sanji and would've pushed him waaaay farther than Queen did (if that fight is over). The choreography would've been better, Sanji would've been able to grow even more, we could've found out even more about Lunarians, etc.

Jinbe vs. Queen - Jinbe was straight up just not a match for Who's-Who. I considered putting him against Jack but I hate Jack and I love Jinbe so no. Plus this fight probably would've forced Jinbe to improve and get a PU, getting some shine as the newest crew member

Inuarashi vs Jack - no change here

Nekomamushi vs Perospero - again no change

Drake vs Who's Who - Just makes sense to me for some reason

Franky vs Sasaki - No change

Robin vs Black Maria - No change

Nami and Usopp vs Ulti - I hated that BM had to be involved in this

Brook vs Page One - I know he's the weakest tobiroppo but there's more of a storyline w/ Nami and Usopp vs Ulti

Chopper and Bepo vs Hawkins - Wanted to give bepo a chance to get back at hawkins for what he did to law's crew and then I also wanted to give chopper a fight

Apoo can go fuck himself and fall off onigashima and drown
 
#2
To make the yonko defeats more believable the fights should have been like this

5SN vs 2 yonko

Luffy + Yamato vs Kaido
Kid + Law vs Linlin
Zoro vs King
Killer vs Queen
Sanji vs Perospero
Inu and Neko vs Jack
Heat and Usopp vs Page One
Bepo and Nami vs Ulti
Franky vs Sasaki
Jinbe vs Who's Who
Robin vs Maria
Brook and Wire vs Hawkins
Drake vs Apoo


And then:

Luffy + Yamato + Zoro vs kaido (more believable end for Kaido since he cant lose 1 v 1)
Kid + Law + Killer vs Linlin ( 3 of the 5 strongest vs 1 yonko more believable end for Linlin)
Sanji + Drake + Jinbe + Franky + Heat vs Cp-0

Would have been far better if Oda made it clear that the 3 supernova alliance was what won the war not just the SHP winning thanks to plot armour, also with this it would properly highlight that SHP > Kid Pirates >> Heart Pirates
 
#8
Not a change of match-up, but I'd completely rewrite Nami/Usopp vs Ulti/Page One so Meme is out of it. A freaking emperor doing 95% of the work didn't and stil doesn't sit well to me. I'd have Zeus gets back to Nami before, and may have a Law of Kid crewmates involved as an assist to make it more balanced.(and so they finally get some use outside Killer) If mid trio members were able to solo Tobi roppo, I don't think it would be too unbelievable for the weaklings to win in 2 vs 1.
 
#10
Luffy, Yamato, Zoro and XDrake vs Kaido
Kid, Killer, Law and Hawkins vs Big Mom
Marco vs King
Sanji vs Queen vs Who’s who (traitor)
Jinbe vs Smoothie
Inu & Neko vs Jack & Peros
Franky vs Sasaki
Robin vs Black Maria
Nami and Usopp vs Ulti
Brook vs Page One
Chopper vs the strongest Number
Injured Kawamatsu vs Daifuku
Injured Shutenmaru vs Snack

Changes after some fighting
Jinbe + Marco vs CP0 (protecting Robin)
King goes to the roof -> King vs Zoro
Yamato, XDrake and Luffy vs Kaido round 2

XDrake and Hawkins would be support characters
 
#11
The monster trio I wouldn't change they are fighting their level.

Luffy vs Kaido
Zoro vs King
Sanji vs Queen.

Brook vs Apoo
Franky vs Sasaki
Robin vs Black Maria
Chopper and Ussop vs Page 1
Nami vs Ulti
Jimbei vs Jack
 

Garp the Fist

Bwahahahaha
#12
1. Let Usopp actually beat Page One. Big Mom can weaken him, that’s fine.
2. Let Nami actually beat Ulti. Again, Big Mom can weaken her, I don‘t mind that, but not the extent of what we got. Also then give the two of them a real fight after it, even if only for a chapter
3. Jinbei vs Sasaki gets another chapter
4. Robin vs Black Maria is fine
5. Give Brook Who’s Who. Don’t think his Fishman racism is all that important tbh. The Nika exposition can be dropped another way, the Gomu Gomu stuff can still come from him
6. Give Chopper Perospero. Team him up with Carrot or something, or just point out he’s weakened still from his previous fights.

7. Give Jinbei Jack and make it a proper two chapter fight. Don’t care about the Minks.
8. Make Queen a big powerhouse using more moves like Brachiobomber combined with tech. Make him fuck up Sanji using the Germa tech instead of Brachiosnake. Make the two actually fight for two chapters.
9. Zoro fights King before he gets to Kaido.

10. Rooftop fight still happens, except after everyone else has went down. Have Killer vs Hawkins, Kid vs Apoo, Law vs Drake or CP0 or something beforehand to keep them occupied. Swap around when Yamato fights Kaido, have Luffy try a one vs one earlier and get tossed off the island, let Marco distract the Yonko or something.

Would need a lot of rewriting to fit everything in some areas but I think it would have been better
 
#15
Im actually fine with most of the matchups we got, its the execution, choreography, and finale's of the fights that have been a little wanting.

Brook vs Appo
Usopp vs Page One
Marco vs Kaido (more conversation then a fight, Like does Kaido even know Marco's here? What would his reaction be?)
Both CP0 Agents vs Drake (Push the 1% Man narrative)
Luffy vs Jack (Still holding out hope for a Luffy one shotting of Jack because he said he'd kick jacks ass lol)
Chopper vs a Number or 2
 
H

Herrera95

#18
I would change how some things happen.

Kaido vs Mink Army + Scabbards - Would be much better to show how tough Kaido is facing hundred of enemies at once.

Luffy + Zoro vs King + Queen in order to reach Rooftop by the fastest way without Luffy being a pussy and taking the longer way to avoid fighting.

Sanji + Nami + Usopp vs Ulti + Page One - Sanji got outpowered by Page One hybrid form(which took BM's ACoC to be defeated in his animal form) and somehow he thought Usopp and Nami were strong enough to defeat them? Makes no fucking sense. They needed a Yonko help to beat them.

Jinbei vs Jack - Jinbei was clearly overkill to Who's Who(pathetic bait from Oda trying to make him as "great" as Queen). Jack would be a much better fight.

Perospero vs Pedro - He is alive for sure. He should have appeared in his Sulong Form and saved Wanda and Carrot from Perospero.

Chopper + X-Drake vs Apoo + Numbers - Numbers would be a good matchup for Chopper. Not so strong as Queen that Chopper can't even hurt him but not weak as Gifters that Chopper one-shot them.

Franky's and Robin's matchup no change.

Since Who's Who was chilling in his room no one need to fight him.
 
Top