Then you wonder why some users from the other web think WG has slumped in quality because of posts like these.
Besides instant locking and dishing out warnings, I think a new rule should be placed for any vs. threads.
That rule should be that the topic creator NEEDS to give his or her detailed opinion (opening post) on the match up and it should AT LEAST be three sentences long.
If a mod sees that the opening post does not meet this criteria then they are warned and locked instantly until he or she has edited their post.