Questions & Mysteries Is Carrot on the Sunny

[kentasaiba]

Fanbase:

Oda:

 

[NAMELESS]

If she is,i will lose my shit.I'm done with carrot,wanda,yamato,momo and kinemon.Fuck them.Its time for straw hat interactions.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

It's a fun idea for sure, but Carrot's shitty treatment in Wano is what really makes me doubt the chances of her actually stowing away.

Her acceptance and goodbye were probably both offscreeen'd

 

[AL sama]

It's a fun idea for sure, but Carrot's shitty treatment in Wano is what really makes me doubt the chances of her actually stowing away.

Her acceptance and goodbye were probably both offscreeen'd

don't you dare doubt that after what oda just did

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

don't you dare doubt that after what oda just did

You have a point

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

The thing is: there are 5 haki users in the crew. Some people believe they won’t realize her presence?

Robin thing happened simply because back then haki wasn’t a thing. Just my 2 cents tho

 

[centurion]

 

[AL sama]

The thing is: there are 5 haki users in the crew. Some people believe they won’t realize her presence?

Robin thing happened simply because back then haki wasn’t a thing. Just my 2 cents tho

not a convincing answer man

she sneaked in after zou too

 

[JoSeungHun7335]

not a convincing answer man

she sneaked in after zou too

Can be argued that Luffy was the only one on board. But if it happens when all 5 haki users present and she can still sneak in, let’s conclude it’s one of Oda’s shitty writings, that logic can’t be applied in One Piece world.

Why the need to sneak instead of just ask? Not like they’re enemies after all. She already tagged along once too

 

[AL sama]

Why the need to sneak instead of just ask? Not like they’re enemies after all. She already tagged along once too

cause she is a freaking dumb rabbit

 

[Carrota Guco]

I hope she is, but...
- She has been out of focus for a while
- Oda dropped a lot of plots lately
- She hasn't shown desire to join the crew specifically
- She hasn't been seen in chapter 1057
- She didn't seem to reject queenship out right
- She has been paired with minks a lot not the crew lately
-

However...
- She has a clear goal to bring the dawn
- She seems to have roles on the crew
- She is paralleling the previous rulers/roger's crew
- We have almost never had a dock loading scene in one piece
- She hasn't been seen in chapter 1057
- Oda said 2 years ago we would get another member in 2 year approximately
- Minks seem hard to detect even with observation haki (Luffy Whale forest)
- Pedro conversation with her imply she should help the strawhats and she has his will
-

We'll see. From my point of view it seem the lessons she learned from Pedro may influence her to lead toward the dawn in her own way which is to become a pirate for now.

 

[zzShinichi]

At this point literally anything can happen
Shit Oda can even make Yamato change her mind and we see her climbing on Sunny's anchor in the next chapter

 

[Nikuzi]

You know what, yes, she's on the sunny. Fuck it.

All in

 

[Xlaw]

People should know when to give up

 

[Kurozumi D. Trussop]

This is true Peak Fiction

 

[Sakura no Hiluluk]

The only honest answer is : we don't know.

As simple and as uninteresting as it may sound, that's the truth.