General & Others Is Oda okay?

Akagame

Akagame

‎
#25
#25
Den_Den_Mushi said:
No, Oda is quite clearly not ok. Man needs a serious break, even a hiatus, but I doubt his editors will allow it. But to be fair, most of his woes are entirely self-inflicted.

Oda has said in interviews that he regrets introducing seven warlords as this was too many. He even folded Mihawk, who was not actually introduced as a warlord into the group to fill out numbers, but he has still yet to flesh out these characters properly. Clearly however he did not learn jack shit as he proceeded to introduce ten supernovas, six Tobi Roppo, nine Red Scrubbards and an untold number of minor antagonists and commanders. If Oda is breaking under the weight of all this unnecessary trash, he only has himself to blame really.
Click to expand...
THIS. If it's getting too much then stop introducing so many side characters that no one gives a shit about. We barely know who the Straw Hats are anymore because he'd rather dedicate unreal amounts of panel time to Scabbards and fodder. He needs to focus and stop giving himself all of this mental strain.
 
JerAx

JerAx

‎
#28
#28
Yasheen said:
The story’s literally the same since Pre timeskip we just as readers are more mature and can see the issues.

Like straight up it’s almost the exact same. It’s still fun and it’s still entertaining I’m not saying Odas perfect but he has to entertain the largest fanbase in shonen. His choices aren’t going to work for everyone, but the majority of his readers go with it
Click to expand...
Tell you what is the typical fans nowdays lol
 
djnhsly

djnhsly

‎
#31
#31
I wouldn't say it's completely trash, but I think his age and poor health might have affected his writing, so I think Oda might need to take a hiatus after Wano. Plus, he needs to stop writing too many characters. Looking at how underwhelming Wano has been, I'm more worried about how the Final War will go. I just hope Oda won't mess it up like the way Kubo did Bleach's Final Arc.
 
ZenZu

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
‎
#33
#33
S.W317 said:
Do you think Oda is the one who’s writing one piece still? Or someone else is doing it for him, cause it feels like the one writing one piece nowadays is an incompetent noob unworthy of Shonen jump and Shuesha, both Demon Slayer and JJK and Tokyo revengers have destroyed one piece in sales this year and this should show you something.

is Oda perhaps suffering from some kind of mental disease or dementia?
Click to expand...
First it was Kidd fans, now Luffy fans in the mud lmfao. Did y'all really think Luffy would be made to look superior to Kaidou with G4, when he couldn't even get that vs Katakuri? Your fault not Oda's lmao.
 
mrtsrdr

mrtsrdr

‎
#35
#35
When oda start to write one piece , manga power in conmercial sector is not strong as much as today . Of course , he was the one who want to announce his manga . After commercialization of series , one piece is getting famous and famous day by day . Just for that , editors entered unnecessary things to series by convincing oda to gain more money . Like supernova and warlord system . If you introduced something , you have to use these characters . I dont think so oda is happy to extend one piece series. While one piece is seen as a weekly series that will put their minds at ease for readers , it is seen as something that makes money by those who trade this business .
second reson is absolutely animation . Demon slayer jujutsu kaisen or etc have good story line ? Nah ? Just animation quality collecting more people attention for these series . I did not see any art side of toei works . If they had done same process like tue other animes ( 24 chapter or 20 chapter high quality and non repeating things in the anime ) , one piece would have collected more people from new generation . Just check out demon slayer season 2 animation art
One of the sale decreasing reason is that new generstion manga readers dont interest any story line thing . All of them want to see good and clear fight and no extension and repeating thing . Demon slayer manga almost last 75 80 chap composed of fight and one happy end chapter . But check one piece , to able to make fan service , edotors make oda create rooftop scene . And we know that , this is unnecessary move totaally . Or luffy run ten chapter to reach rooftop to start roof top one piece chapter 1000 . Rule is simple . You can be genius but Your talent is revealed as much as the quality of the people around you.

- bad animation company
- idiot editors
- long years Of fatigue
- changing era and changing new generation perspective
 
S.W317

S.W317

‎
#37
#37
WesMidnight said:
There are respectful ways to critique the author of a series you are reading for free online.
This isn't it.
:kuzanshut:
Click to expand...
I’m mad because he yet again made Luffy lose once more, how many more rounds is there for Luffy vs Kaido? I mean the moment when they were about to exchange final blows should’ve been the perfect moment to end the fight with a big W for Luffy
[automerge]1646565613[/automerge]
Manos. AsuraZoro said:
Guys stop hating the guy, seriously.
Many of us are entertained from his work without giving a single penny.
I barely entertain my 3 year old son lol, it's not easy to have everyone satisfied.
I suggest if you guys hate one piece that much just drop it and find something that is more fitting to your standards.
Those kinds of comments could actually be harmful if somehow reach Oda.
Click to expand...
I hope it reaches him so that he would stop making Luffy keep losing to Kaido in retarded ways, why did Oda make Kaido into this unbeatable person?
[automerge]1646565732[/automerge]
Finalbeta said:
Sometimes his decisions are particularly bad but his talent is still remaining immeasurable.
Click to expand...
Is ZKK immeasurable talent? It’s nothing but madness, making Zoro defeat the main villain instead of the MC is retarded, and I’m sure this is the sole reason why he made Luffy lose, so that Zoro would be the one to kill Kaido. Then why not make Zoro the main character?
[automerge]1646565779[/automerge]
Yasheen said:
The story’s literally the same since Pre timeskip we just as readers are more mature and can see the issues.

Like straight up it’s almost the exact same. It’s still fun and it’s still entertaining I’m not saying Odas perfect but he has to entertain the largest fanbase in shonen. His choices aren’t going to work for everyone, but the majority of his readers go with it
Click to expand...
Has Zoro ever defeated a major villain? This is new to me
[automerge]1646579291[/automerge]
Finalbeta said:
Health wise you mean buddy? :josad:
Click to expand...
Health of course, who in their right mind would think that ZKK is a good idea?
 
Last edited:
Finalbeta

Finalbeta

Hero of Albion
‎
#38
#38
S.W317 said:
I’m mad because he yet again made Luffy lose once more, how many more rounds is there for Luffy vs Kaido? I mean the moment when they were about to exchange final blows should’ve been the perfect moment to end the fight with a big W for Luffy
[automerge]1646565613[/automerge]

I hope it reaches him so that he would stop making Luffy keep losing to Kaido in retarded ways, why did Oda make Kaido into this unbeatable person?
[automerge]1646565732[/automerge]

Is ZKK immeasurable talent? It’s nothing but madness, making Zoro defeat the main villain instead of the MC is retarded, and I’m sure this is the sole reason why he made Luffy lose, so that Zoro would be the one to kill Kaido. Then why not make Zoro the main character?
[automerge]1646565779[/automerge]

Has Zoro ever defeated a major villain? This is new to me
[automerge]1646579291[/automerge]

Health of course, who in their right mind would think that ZKK is a good idea?
Click to expand...
What I meant is that in general Oda is still a pretty talented mangaka. It's not easy to come up with something like One Piece in its totality, his health striked him a lot recently however :josad: So he is looking less qualitative
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top