General & Others Is the alliance against the Beast pirates necessary?

[Albino 👑]

If the strawhats decided to call off the alliance last minute and instead call the grand fleet to fight against the beast pirates themselves could they have been just as successful?
No alliance no big mom interference ect. Just the strawhats and beast pirates going head to head

• Having around 5,600 members

• 1 captain
• 3 all stars
• 6 tobi roppo
• 10 numbers
• 500 gifter
• 1 apoo
• Having around 20,000 overall members

Whats the point of the alliance especially if the strawhats can solo the top beast pirates?
If luffy can beat kaido, JZS the all star, the other 6 the tobi ropp, ect the alliance should even exist tbh

http://imgur.com/a/s6na3cZ

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

None of the Straw Hat Grandfleet members can take on and beat the Tobi Roppo and questionably the Numbers. Maybe the top 3 of the Grandfleet for the latter, but definitely not casually. It basically means the Straw Hats will be bogged down by fodder and mid tiers that'll gang up on the Top 4 as they try to fight Kaido + the executives.

 

[Dettles]

If they were able to call the Grand Fleet, combined with the Allies on Wano, The "Alliance" wouldn't be needed.
But, with how fast things move in One Piece and how hard it is to get to Wano, the Grand Fleet wouldn't make it in time.

 

[rerere]

This is why I think that SH should take like 2 calamities and like 3 tobiroppo, otherwise the alliance would seem useless

 

[bhacha2000]

It was necessary. Oda want to make Lufy a Hero for all OP world. Many countries need to have owned debt or obligation after Luffy save or free them

 

[Bullet]

Yes it is because Kaido can solo the Sh and grandfleet

 

[Luffy is the mc]

The thing is the straw hats are already alone against the beast pirates tbh. The scabbards went straight after Kaido and they basically will do nothing aside losing.
The 5000 samurais are useless af. You could say that there will be maybe only Law and Kidd that will defeat a few beast pirates but that's it.
The main players will be defeated by Luffy and his crew. Throw the alliance in that and they would win too.

 

[Finalbeta]

It was necessary. Oda want to make Lufy a Hero for all OP world. Many countries need to have owned debt or obligation after Luffy save or free them

Just like Mihawk once stated after all. Luffy is keeping at it.

He will never stop help people around the world and form solid alliances. One day all these guys will repay the favour and help him. Perhaps in the Final War, who knows I guess.

 

[Krusher1357]

Imagine if Luffy's vivre card has slowing been burning while he has been at wano and the GF appear at Onigashima in sync to help luffy dunk on BM n Kaido 😂 would be sad tho, luffy needs to prove he can take a yonko now, at least a stalemate

 

[Buusatan94]

Imagine if Luffy's vivre card has slowing been burning while he has been at wano and the GF appear at Onigashima in sync to help luffy dunk on BM n Kaido 😂 would be sad tho, luffy needs to prove he can take a yonko now, at least a stalemate

No reason for that, Luffy had ignored Ace's Vivre Card burning for so long, it took him finally learning that Ace was to be executed for him to think about trying to rescue him at long last, lol.

 

[Krusher1357]

No reason for that, Luffy had ignored Ace's Vivre Card burning for so long, it took him finally learning that Ace was to be executed for him to think about trying to rescue him at long last, lol.

I don't think all the alliance would ignore it, plus they are all seasoned pirates by now and know exactly what the fuck is going on with vivre cards unlike luffy at the time. I don't think it will happen, I just think it'd be a laugh

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

I mean you have Kaido and Big Mom crews here so you definitely need as much allies as possible.