Character Discussion Jack should have been Kaido's YC1

[L55]

King for me looks more Badass in Design.

But the Hype Jack receives in Zou, was something close to what Marco and Katakuri receives in their respective introductions.
[automerge]1688569931[/automerge]

Yep, in Zou.

Mistranslation
The official says he s one of kaido s trusted subordinate

 

[Juanpiz]

Stop making dupes, Neutralwatcher

I thought Cracker is jacks equal

 

[Shiroyru]

Bobbins was still one of the strongest non Vets of Big Mom's army, and this was in WCI Where headliner level guys were still somewhat relevant

Jack felt like filler in Wano

People thought Bobbins was BM’s Marco. He ended up being BM’s Holdem

 

[Urouge D. Rouge]

I agree with this post

 

[Fujishiro]

Comparing Jack to King is like comparing Mr. 3 to Mr. 1 or Jabura to Lucci or Cracker to Katakuri and so on.

King is significantly stronger than Jack. No joke, you can put dozens of characters between King and Jack, that's how big the difference is. In fact, King >= Marco >= Katakuri > Doffy > Queen >= Denjiro > Sulong Dukes > Jack > Inu~Nekomamushi~Ashura Doji~Perospero

Nobody was talking about strength.

 

[zorovsanji]

I agree with ndule tho. Jack should be yc1 as he's closer to kata while king should be a partner like Rayleigh. Someone who can one shot big mom shouldn't be treated as yc.

 

[JoNdule]

Comparing Jack to King is like comparing Mr. 3 to Mr. 1 or Jabura to Lucci or Cracker to Katakuri and so on.

King is significantly stronger than Jack. No joke, you can put dozens of characters between King and Jack, that's how big the difference is. In fact, King >= Marco >= Katakuri > Doffy > Queen >= Denjiro > Sulong Dukes > Jack > Inu~Nekomamushi~Ashura Doji~Perospero

Mr 1 fits to be Crocodile strongest commander

King feels like a background backup commander while Jack embodies what Oda wanted to do with beast pirates

 

[Kiiro]

I agree with ndule tho. Jack should be yc1 as he's closer to kata while king should be a partner like Rayleigh. Someone who can one shot big mom shouldn't be treated as yc.

King can 1 shot Big Mom?
[automerge]1688948887[/automerge]
1.- Introduced against Minks which he failed to defeat in 5 or 10 days.
2.- Had to use poison weapons to get the upperhand against Veteran fighters.
3.- Failed to get the ninja guy.
4.- Was crushed in the sea battle. Crushed by Zunesha
5.- Lost against Minks at wano.
6.- Lost against Zou Kings once again.


Does he even have a single win? Nah, King is the right hand.

 

[Glahuh]

troll

 

[silverfire]

No, that would just be a mini-Kaido. It’s like saying Compote should be Linlin’s right hand man, it brings nothing new to the crew.

Overall agreed with this. The yonko’s right hand men tend to be foils to them, help keep them in check. Jack has a temperament similar to Kaido’s own. His eagerness to throw down also lends itself to someone trying to prove themselves worthy.

But overall he ended up a let down. I don’t even remember how he got defeated.

 

[Albino 👑]

Jack was also on the rooftop like zoro and killer

 

[JoNdule]

Overall agreed with this. The yonko’s right hand men tend to be foils to them, help keep them in check. Jack has a temperament similar to Kaido’s own. His eagerness to throw down also lends itself to someone trying to prove themselves worthy.

But overall he ended up a let down. I don’t even remember how he got defeated.

Jack could have been smarter while being wild

Zodo is dumber than Luffy btw yet his strongest commander.
[automerge]1688975963[/automerge]

Jack was also on the rooftop like zoro and killer

Yeah
He had privilge to fight at rooftop
Protect Kaido more than King and Queen

King and Queeb let retainers reach Kaido easily
Frauds