Character Discussion Jinbei is by far the worst addition to the crew

[Roronoa-sama]

Lamebei... I like your style.

Essentially I agree 100%, not only is he boring, but doesn't fit the crew's youthful dynamic (we could say the same for Brook, but Brook acts like a child), since he's already a long time pirate, captain even.

if he's boring what is law?

 

[MonochromeYoru]

if he's boring what is law?

Lay off of Law. He's a much much much better and interesting character than the talking fish.

 

[Peroroncino]

Lamebei... I like your style.

Essentially I agree 100%, not only is he boring, but doesn't fit the crew's youthful dynamic (we could say the same for Brook, but Brook acts like a child), since he's already a long time pirate, captain even.

robin ruins that youthful dynamic way more than jinbe since he at least participates in the gags like he did this chapter

 

[RayanOO]

Fisher Tiger : top tier character

good gap

Arlong : good character

G
A
A
A
A
A
A
P

Jimbo Jumbo in the SH

 

[Roronoa-sama]

Lay off of Law. He's a much much much better and interesting character than the talking fish.

of course sasuke character without sasuke charisman

 

[Natalija]

robin ruins that youthful dynamic way more than jinbe since he at least participates in the gags like he did this chapter

Well Robin has been a bit boring post skip, but it's difficult to imagine the crew without her and she's extremely needed for reading history.

They do not need Jinbore at all

 

[RayanOO]

Well Robin has been a bit boring post skip, but it's difficult to imagine the crew without her and she's extremely needed for reading history.

They do not need Jinbore at all

Yeah to navigate they had Nami and Franky
To advise they had Robin Sanji Nami etc (even if Luffy always did what he wanted)
For putting Luffy in check we had Zoro and Nami

etc etc

Jimbe is stealing some good development for other SH and he is not needed at alllll

 

[MonochromeYoru]

robin ruins that youthful dynamic way more than jinbe since he at least participates in the gags like he did this chapter

Gag? That was straight up cringe my man. And it's only gonna get worse. The fish is gonna act like this EVERY DAMN TIME. Like, imagine how much panels he's gonna steal from the already panel malnourished Usopp, choppa, franky and Brook.

 

[Natalija]

Gag? That was straight up cringe my man. And it's only gonna get worse. The fish is gonna act like this EVERY DAMN TIME. Like, imagine how much panels he's gonna steal from the already panel malnourished Usopp, choppa, franky and Brook.

Not to mention how much will be wasted just by explaining things to him...

 

[RayanOO]

the worst thing is Oda will force him to do « funny » stuff or funny faces etc and it doesn’t suit him at all

 

[Seven7]

Depends felt like for me if he didn't join so late it wouldn't be a problem.
But I enjoy him
@Natalija @RayanOO Mods ganging up on Jinbei

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Not to mention how much will be wasted just by explaining things to him...

Exactly. He's also gonna butt in Robin's trait of explaining things to luffy, zoro's trait of being the main counsel and voice of reason in serious situation, the middle trio's trait of being the adults and knowledgeable ones in the crew etc and many more....

 

[BuggyDGod]

He adds literally nothing to the crew except strength, but even then he’s only barely on par with Franky, Brook, and Robin. I could excuse his addition if he at least had a personality but he doesn’t lol, he’s soooo booooorrring.

I’m gonna be honest, I think Carrot would’ve been a far better addition to the crew and I don’t even like her lol. At least she was shown to have some chemistry with the crew unlike Lamebei

He adds literally nothing to the crew except strength, but even then he’s only barely on par with Franky, Brook, and Robin. I could excuse his addition if he at least had a personality but he doesn’t lol, he’s soooo booooorrring.

I’m gonna be honest, I think Carrot would’ve been a far better addition to the crew and I don’t even like her lol. At least she was shown to have some chemistry with the crew unlike Lamebei

 

[Water1415]

He's a Zoro clone

 

[115673]

Deadpan comedy works. Jinbei will provide that. Oda will probably make it work. We are close to disbanding anyway. So, it doesn’t matter.

Or Oda has Jinbei killed for "tension" against BB pirates.

He's a Zoro clone

He is not. Zoro taunts Sanji all the time. Jinbei gives zero fucks. So, if we are talking dynamics, Jinbei is going to be different from Zoro.

 

[IIskandar1997]

I think Carrot would’ve been a far better addition to the crew

Well that sums it up

 

[Natalija]

Or Oda has Jinbei killed for "tension" against BB pirates.

I thought he was gonna kill him as a sacrifice in Whole Cake Island, but turns out Jinbore returned without one scratch on him

 

[115673]

I thought he was gonna kill him as a sacrifice in Whole Cake Island, but turns out Jinbore returned without one scratch on him

Okay, Oda will "fake" kill Jinbei at the beginning of the arc and bring him back at the very end like Paguya (at least I think that was his name). Still Tension for the whole arc.

 

[Date]

I'm okay with him, because at least he got devolpment since Impel Down, taking part in a lot of arcs like Marineford, post-Marineford, FI and WCI before joining.

Think Jinbei got more development then guys like Brook and Franky

 

[Orojackson Refugee]

anyone noticed how jinbe has joined the crew for quite a while now, but sanji fans only decide to discuss this now?