What an absolutely stupid comparison.
First off where do you get this dumb idea that only Law’s fruit is magic lmfao every fruit is magic you twat. And wrong, Law’s fruit only works with medical knowledge, it’s been stressed countless times, swap their fruits and Kidd couldn’t do half the shit Law can without going to medical school.
Second Law and his crew saved Luffy and escaped MF from an Admiral assault. If it weren’t for DOCTOR Law he would be literally dead and we have no TS One Piece.
Third, Law became a Warlord in his own right. The mastermind behind Rocky Port Incident involving former Rocks member and future Yonko and Marine Hero. All accomplishments before PH arc.
“Couldn’t defeat Vergo on his own” cuz he handicapped himself by giving up his heart in the first place? What braindead take or imaginary L is this?
Fourth, Law saved the SH’s asses by replacing the seastone cuffs, saved them from Yeti bros, and broke the gears of SMILE with his own power, didn’t need Luffy or any SH to do that. Without Law SH’s would be dead in PH.
Fifth, it was LAW who proposed the alliance cuz he had the grand plan to take SHs to Dressrosa and to Zou, where his crew is and has his Vivre card. Without Law, SHs don’t do either and don’t beat Doflamingo. If Law takes no accomplishments in the alliance, then neither does Luffy. Pot calling kettle black you genius.
Kidd lost to RHP, TWICE. First time he didn’t even get to see the boss and got taken out by underboss. He ended up allying with weakling Hawkins and spy Apoo, assuming it ever went through then that shit would stink based on what we saw in Wano. There’s absolutely nothing impressive about his battles, nor his ability to find good alliance partners. In fact, Kidd’s bounty was only slightly higher than Law’s at post-TS start, we know Kidd likes to cause destruction and Law had his frozen by then.
So no power-wise Kidd is not superior and in terms of shaking the New World, Law is the one who broke the Gears that threw everything into motion. Put Kidd in Law’s place and he gets destroyed by Fujitora’s meteor.
