Character Discussion Lady Chiyo vs Shimotsuki Yasuie which character had the bigger impact?

[lee33]

Compare the following characters and tell me which had the better impact?

EDIT: It's funny how people are comparing Lady Chiyo to that of Whitebeard or Ace. WB and Ace are central main characters of One Piece while Lady Chiyo is a very minor secondary character. The fact that you guys have to compare them to Lady Chiyo speaks volumes to the level of quality of writing in One Piece.

 

[Franosuke]

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Lady Chiyo kept Sakura alive throughout the fight, helped to defeat Sasori and gave her life for Gaara. As an Edo Tensei, she also told Kankuro how to cure Hanzo's toxins.

But Yasuie inspired people I guess.

 

[Ace]

Theyd be even if Yasuie greatly contributed in defeating a warlord and resurrected Law

 

[Finalbeta]

She reminds me more of Weevil's mother

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Chiyo has more impact than 70% of OP characters Lmao.

 

[York]

Need to compare Chiyo to someone more on her level, like, uh, marineford whitebeard lmaooooooo

 

[PuckTheGreat]

If death actually meant sumin in OP then Yasuie’s death would’ve been very touching. Mofo is prolly still alive somewhere on Wano.
Death very rarely has weight in OP so it’s hard to take it seriously. Whereas, death has always had weight in Naruto even with the existence of Edo Tensei.

Plus, Chiyo died to bring Gaara back & had developed a deep connection with Sakura. She had a strong connection to characters most people care about hence why her death had such a significant impact on the readers whereas Yasuie died to inspire minor characters like the scabbards etc. to work together to fight Orochi & Kaido. Yh his death also lit a fire in Zoro to make him angry & wanna kill Orochi but whatever happened to that plot line 😂. That’s basically ONE PIECE & death in a nutshell it’s just fake tension/fluff & rarely has any weight to it. Chiyo’s death is more comparable to sumin like Ace dying for Luffy.