General & Others Marineford vs Enies Lobby: Which is the best arc of OP?

Better arc


  • Total voters
    56
#62
First off

fuck if it’s a better written story wise or power wise, it’s all about how you feel/felt watching/reading it

people bringing up the fact that MF would probably be slandered if it was weekly

but just imagine how much we’d be invested if the strongest of men go together again , wouldn’t even matter if it’s PIS induced or not

And actually MF is the PEAK of ONE PIECE

We all get super invested when a single top tier is involved , now imagine all the worlds strongest getting together again and showcasing their abilities
~ brings more agendas
~ more feats
~ more character depth
~ world structure
~ power structure

and most important of all, hype and entertainment, Garp/Kuzan , Shanks/Greenbull , Luffy/Kizaru

we all were super invested in these Sub Arcs/Egghead because of the presence of top tiers; while Egghead was kinda goofy it made wonders and generated hundreds of pages of worth discussions wether it be story or power level related.

Nothing tops marineford the set up was too exciting, not a single boring chapter from it every bit was interesting , every character was interesting

honestly it might be the only arc where I didn’t skip anything and read it all the way through
 
#66
The W7-EL saga is peak One Piece. Best fights, great flashbacks (Franky, Robin), even an otherwise unsufferable character like Usopp has his moments. And it is also really funny, centaur Franky, Sanji's wanted poster and Sanji's message to Nami are amazing

Impel Down-MF has no strawhats so it is subpar by definition
 
#67
The W7-EL saga is peak One Piece. Best fights, great flashbacks (Franky, Robin), even an otherwise unsufferable character like Usopp has his moments. And it is also really funny, centaur Franky, Sanji's wanted poster and Sanji's message to Nami are amazing

Impel Down-MF has no strawhats so it is subpar by definition
Enies Lobby was mid water 7 carried.
marineford>>>>>>>>>
 

Shisui

3 Palestine
#71
MF for me. Luffy without the SHs is peak Luffy. Probably why OP sales was at its peak. Man was all hands and heart:ronalugh:
Never heard anyone read/watch MF and say man, if only Chopper was here:Egg_Peak:
Post automatically merged:

Some people prefer Enies Lobby because all of the SH's were featured, whereas in MF, there was only Luffy.

Marine Ford was the best arc Oda has ever written imo, I didn't even miss the other SH's tbh. It was the only arc in which the pacing wasn't abysmal, and the fights, emotional drama, and characters were all top tier.
ykb:holdw:
 
Top