Character Discussion MVP of every arc w/o Luffy

[mrtsrdr]

As you know,

Every arc, one straw hat star is shining. And I want to learn your thoughts. My list :

Arlong Park : Zoro and Sanji
Alabasta : Mr Prince Sanji
Skypia : Sanji
Enies Loby : Sanji
Thriller Bark : Zoro
Dressrosa : Zoro
WCI : Brook

I made list based on role of the arc. Like Brook stole copy.

 

[Vicks Nosferatu]

Dressrosa Usopp everything Else I gree

 

[Sadistic Senpai]

As you know,

Every arc, one straw hat star is shining. And I want to learn your thoughts. My list :

Arlong Park : Zoro and Sanji
Alabasta : Mr Prince Sanji
Skypia : Sanji
Enies Loby : Sanji
Thriller Bark : Zoro
Dressrosa : Zoro
WCI : Brook

I made list based on role of the arc. Like Brook stole copy.

No way, Dressrosa's arc would be Law without a doubt

 

[RayanOO]

Dressrosa : Zoro

Zoro indeed had a good role, beating Pica, and being one of the leader to push the birdcage

But Ussop was a real game changer : god ussop took down the small demon and freed the toys, he also rallied the gladiators to help, and also one of the main reason the tontattas helped

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Brook was the clear cut MVP for WCI, everything he did was badass and insanely beneficial for his captain/crew. I’d say Franky is doing the same in Wano, he’s getting love and panel time like few of his nakama are in this raid

 

[Fuckthis3]

Arlong park: idk
Alabasta: Crocodle
Skypia: idk
Enies lobby: idk
Thriller bark: perona
Dressrosa: Cavendish
Wci: germa/Caesar

 

[mrtsrdr]

Zoro indeed had a good role, beating Pica, and being one of the leader to push the birdcage

But Ussop was a real game changer : god ussop took down the small demon and freed the toys, he also rallied the gladiators to help, and also one of the main reason the tontattas helped

Dressrosa Usopp everything Else I gree

I forgot the Usopp. You right . Usopp must be MVP of Dressrosa .

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Brook was the clear cut MVP for WCI, everything he did was badass and insanely beneficial for his captain/crew. I’d say Franky is doing the same in Wano, he’s getting love and panel time like few of his nakama are in this raid

Imo Jimbei takes this in WCI. He set Luffy and Nami free from the prison book, took care of Nami and saved Brook from Big Mom after Luffy left, had the idea of the alliance with Bege, told Big Mom to fuck off with her homies and quit the Big Mom pirates during the tea party, maneuver the Sunny like a G and stayed behind to let the rest of the crew escape.
He also motivated them after Pedro died.

Brook is a close 2nd though.

 

[RobotNinja]

As you know,

Every arc, one straw hat star is shining. And I want to learn your thoughts. My list :

Arlong Park : Zoro and Sanji
Alabasta : Mr Prince Sanji
Skypia : Sanji
Enies Loby : Sanji
Thriller Bark : Zoro
Dressrosa : Zoro
WCI : Brook

I made list based on role of the arc. Like Brook stole copy.

Arlong Park: Nojiko and Pinwheel Ossan
Alabasta: Karou ,Ducks/Eyelashes and Mr. Prince and Miss All Sunday
SkyPiea: Wiper
Enies Lobby: Kokoro and Chimney and Going Merry
Thriller Bark: Zoro
Dressrosa: Usopp
WCI: Judge Top 5

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Imo Jimbei takes this in WCI. He set Luffy and Nami free from the prison book, took care of Nami and saved Brook from Big Mom after Luffy left, had the idea of the alliance with Bege, told Big Mom to fuck off with her homies and quit the Big Mom pirates during the tea party, maneuver the Sunny like a G and stay being to let the rest of the crew escape.
He also motivated them after Pedro died.

Brook is a close 2nd though.

No argument here, Jinbe’s the only one who showed out at least as hard as Brook

 

[Veku]

Pre- ts:

Romance Dawn: Zoro
Orange Town: Zoro
Syrup Village: Usopp
Baratie: Sanji
Arlong Park: Every Strawhat equally? Or Nojiko
Logue Town: Dragon
Reverse Mountain: -
Whiskey Peak: Zoro
Little Garden: Dorry and Brogy
Drum Island: Chopper/Dr. Kureha
Alabasta: Pell
Jaya: Teach
Sky Island: Wyper/Sanji
Long Ring Long Land: Aokiji
Water 7: Zoro
Enies Lobby: Sanji/Going Merry
Thriller Bark: Zoro
Sabaody Archipel: Kuma
Amazon Lilly: -
Impel Down: Ivankov
Marineford: Whitebeard, or maybe Shanks

Post ts:
Sabaody Archipel: Sanji and Zoro or Kuma for defending the Thousand Sunny
Fishmen Island: Jinbei
Punk Hazard: Law
Dressrosa: Usopp and/or Law
Zou: Minks overall, or Inu and Neko if it comes down to a single character
Whole Cake: Either Brook or Jinbei, maybe even Sanji if I'm being generous
Reverie: -
Wano: So far: Big Mom lmfao

 

[Sir Yasheen]

As you know,

Every arc, one straw hat star is shining. And I want to learn your thoughts. My list :

Arlong Park : Zoro and Sanji
Alabasta : Mr Prince Sanji
Skypia : Sanji
Enies Loby : Sanji
Thriller Bark : Zoro
Dressrosa : Zoro
WCI : Brook

I made list based on role of the arc. Like Brook stole copy.

Arlong Park:
Straw Hats: Zoro and Sanji
Non Straw Hats: Genzo and Nojiko

Loguetown:
Straw Hat: Nami
Non Straw Hat: Dragon

Whiskey Peak:
Straw Hat: Zoro
Non Straw Hat: Igaram

Little Garden:
Straw Hat: Sanji
Non Straw Hat: Dorry and Broggy

Drum:
Straw Hat: Chopper
Non Straw Hat: Kureha

Alabasta:
Straw Hat: Sanji
Non Straw Hat: Ace (annihilated the incoming Baroque Works fleet)

Jaya:
Straw Hat: Robin
Non Straw Hat: Monkey Alliance

Skypeia:
Straw Hat: Sanji
Non Straw Hat: Ganfor

Long ring long land
Straw Hat: Zoro and Sanji
Non straw hat: none

Water 7:
None

Enies Lobby:
Straw Hat: Sanji and Merry
Non Straw Hat: Paulie or Kokoro

Thriller Bark:
Straw Hat: Zoro
Non straw hat: Lola

Sabaody:
Straw Hat: Sanji
Non Straw Hat: Kuma and Rayleigh

Fishman Island:
Straw Hat: Nami
Non Straw Hat: Seakings and royal family

Punk Hazard:
Straw Hat; Usopp
Non Straw Hat: Law

Dressrosa:
Straw Hat: Usopp
Non straw hat: Sabo

Zou:
Straw Hat: Chopper
Non Straw Hat: Momo

WCI:
Straw Hat: Brook
Non Straw Hat: Pedro

 

[mrtsrdr]

Arlong Park:
Straw Hats: Zoro and Sanji
Non Straw Hats: Genzo and Nojiko

Loguetown:
Straw Hat: Nami
Non Straw Hat: Dragon

Whiskey Peak:
Straw Hat: Zoro
Non Straw Hat: Igaram

Little Garden:
Straw Hat: Sanji
Non Straw Hat: Dorry and Broggy

Drum:
Straw Hat: Chopper
Non Straw Hat: Kureha

Alabasta:
Straw Hat: Sanji
Non Straw Hat: Ace (annihilated the incoming Baroque Works fleet)

Jaya:
Straw Hat: Robin
Non Straw Hat: Monkey Alliance

Skypeia:
Straw Hat: Sanji
Non Straw Hat: Ganfor

Long ring long land
Straw Hat: Zoro and Sanji
Non straw hat: none

Water 7:
None

Enies Lobby:
Straw Hat: Sanji and Merry
Non Straw Hat: Paulie or Kokoro

Thriller Bark:
Straw Hat: Zoro
Non straw hat: Lola

Sabaody:
Straw Hat: Sanji
Non Straw Hat: Kuma and Rayleigh

Fishman Island:
Straw Hat: Nami
Non Straw Hat: Seakings and royal family

Punk Hazard:
Straw Hat; Usopp
Non Straw Hat: Law

Dressrosa:
Straw Hat: Usopp
Non straw hat: Sabo

Zou:
Straw Hat: Chopper
Non Straw Hat: Momo

WCI:
Straw Hat: Brook
Non Straw Hat: Pedro

All of them seems good except fishman island. Your choice seems interesting for fishman island.

 

[RobotNinja]

I don't really remember what Sanji did at Sky Island so can someone tell me why many of you are crediting Sanji for it?

 

[mrtsrdr]

I don't really remember what Sanji did at Sky Island so can someone tell me why many of you are crediting Sanji for it?

Just sanji saved Nami and Usopp life. And we haven't seen so much action from SHs in there.

 

[RobotNinja]

Just sanji saved Nami and Usopp life. And we haven't seen so much action from SHs in there.

I see, Well I think that when picking the MVP it needs to have that impact that This character Stole the show type thing. So I wouldn't give Sky Island to Sanji just for that.

Wiper or arguably Ganfall easily outshine anyone else that arc.

Just like how Usopp and Zoro Stole the Show in Dressrosa and Thriller Bark. I think it needs that level of impact.
Or Going Merry at Enies Lobby.

 

[RayanOO]

I don't really remember what Sanji did at Sky Island so can someone tell me why many of you are crediting Sanji for it?

End the flying priest career with the best concasse ever, saved Ussop/Nami life like a badass, and break the arch Maxime to stop the big clouds and thunder

 

[Sir Yasheen]

All of them seems good except fishman island. Your choice seems interesting for fishman island.

I mean, Nami stealing the keys in fishman island to free the royal family and putting her own biases aside to hear Jinbe out knowing about Jinbe and arlongs “relationship” beforehand i think give it to her. Not many people did anything major this arc

Post automatically merged: Jun 15, 2021

I don't really remember what Sanji did at Sky Island so can someone tell me why many of you are crediting Sanji for it?

He broke Enels ship to slow it down enough for Luffy to get back up there to ring the bell and win in time.

He saved Usopp and Namis life.

He was the one who organized Usopp and Luffy then finished of Satori or whatever his name was.

Sanjis I need a light is one of the most iconic scenes from skypeia and I challenge you to find another as impactful as it outside of luffy

 

[RobotNinja]

End the flying priest career with the best concasse ever, saved Ussop/Nami life like a badass, and break the arch Maxime to stop the big clouds and thunder

I guess if we are counting only strawhats then Sanji was the MVP of the Strawhats during Sky Island for the reasons you've mentioned but a good case can be made for Robin.

But overall I think Wiper should get MVP.

Post automatically merged: Jun 15, 2021

Sanjis I need a light is one of the most iconic scenes from skypeia and I challenge you to find another as impactful as it outside of luffy

Wiper "Ring it Strawhat"

or Robin speech to Wiper "Isn't it Romantic"

 

[Rekien]

Alabasta : Mr Prince Sanji
Skypia : Sanji

The guy who didnt even manage to get a single 1v1 in skypea was the MVP? LMAO. And dont even get me started in Allabasta, he got bon clay as an opponent.

Sanji's biggest mister prince moment was on little garden.