Character Discussion MVP of every arc w/o Luffy

#82
As you know,

Every arc, one straw hat star is shining. And I want to learn your thoughts. My list :

Arlong Park : Zoro and Sanji
Alabasta : Mr Prince Sanji
Skypia : Sanji
Enies Loby : Sanji
Thriller Bark : Zoro
Dressrosa : Zoro
WCI : Brook

I made list based on role of the arc. Like Brook stole copy.
Enies Lobby & Dressrosa: Usopp but everything else I agree with
Post automatically merged:


Zoro indeed had a good role, beating Pica, and being one of the leader to push the birdcage

But Ussop was a real game changer : god ussop took down the small demon and freed the toys, he also rallied the gladiators to help, and also one of the main reason the tontattas helped


Let's not forget Usopp is the reason we have a fleet now.
 
#85
Actually many arcs we can easily give mvp to others even considering Luffy.
one of the aim ın this thread is to show how Oda write SH.
When ı check the posts , ı can see everybody dont have to be strong. Everyone has special ability and charactrization. and oda try to write each character equally. If we think about about just in terms of the who is strong , we cannot enjoy enough from OP.
Because OP is story based universe due to that , Oda does not care so much consistency about power scalling.
 
#88
Arlong Park : No one(I don't see it to be SHs actually, it was nothing to dire too, actually should be given to Nojiko)
Alabasta : I would go with Vivi. She did a lot. And actually have to give credit to Smoker/tashigi too for their involvement, smoker used rain dance powder too which along with vivi helped to calm the main problem.
Skypia : No one.
Enies Lobby : No one(Soge King/Franky/Sanji?.. actually everyone felt good to me.. Ussop Franky actually had great moments(talks) with Robin which was the best thing I guess, and the last defense with franky and sogeking was great)
Thriller Bark: Zoro(No doubt)
Dressrosa : Meh. Don't really see any MVP. Though could be Ussop given he single-handedly pissed of doffy the most.
WCI : Oda :specialmeh:
Post automatically merged:

Enies Lobby: Kokoro and Chimney and Going Merry
Actually, forgot about real MVPs :cheers:
 
Last edited:
#89
Arlong Park: Usopp
Alabasta: Sanji
Skypia: Usopp
Enies Lobby: Nami
Thriller Bark: Zoro
Dressrosa: Franky
WCI: Nami
What did Nami do Enies and WCI .d
Post automatically merged:

Arlong Park : No one(I don't see it to be SHs actually, it was nothing to dire too, actually should be given to Nojiko)
Alabasta : I would go with Vivi. She did a lot. And actually have to give credit to Smoker/tashigi too for their involvement, smoker used rain dance powder too which along with vivi helped to calm the main problem.
Skypia : No one.
Enies Lobby : No one(Soge King/Franky/Sanji?.. actually everyone felt good to me.. Ussop Franky actually had great moments(talks) with Robin which was the best thing I guess, and the last defense with franky and sogeking was great)
Thriller Bark: Zoro(No doubt)
Dressrosa : Meh. Don't really see any MVP. Though could be Ussop given he single-handedly pissed of doffy the most.
WCI : Oda :specialmeh:
Post automatically merged:


Actually, forgot about real MVPs :cheers:
Oda has been good slection for wcı .D.D
 
#90
What did Nami do Enies and WCI .d
EL: She interceded for Sanji, defeated Kalifa, used the key to free Zoro and Sogeking from their Seastone handcuffs. Thanks to her they were able to escape, because she calculated the route between the whirlpools.
WCI: Defeated Brulée, helped Luffy defeat Creker, fought the Chess Army, rescue Brook from sleeping BM. She was part of the Vinsmoke rescue and delivered them their raid suits, which led to them getting saved almost immediately. Stole Zeus, inspired King Baum, who helped them escape from Big Mom, destroyed Big Mom's army with Zeus's help and landing heavy hit on a Yonko. Helped Jinbe escape from Smoothie, smashed the mirrors on Luffy's orders. As a result, she received a huge power up in the form of Zeus.
 
Last edited:
H

Herrera95

#91
one of the aim ın this thread is to show how Oda write SH.
When ı check the posts , ı can see everybody dont have to be strong. Everyone has special ability and charactrization. and oda try to write each character equally. If we think about about just in terms of the who is strong , we cannot enjoy enough from OP.
Because OP is story based universe due to that , Oda does not care so much consistency about power scalling.
He doesn't care at all about consistency. But this has absolute nothing to do in giving weak people important roles. Oda's fake deaths, Usopp/Nami saying that they won't handle another headbutt from Ulti then receiving it and still handling even better than before is just poor writting.
 
H

Herrera95

#97
:josad:

The legendary times of Garp visiting Luffy.
Actually just once?
Post automatically merged:

We missed old days. We dont care who is stronger. Just we would wait what is next adventure of our crew ? How will they contribute story.

Right know , there is one discussion , who is strong who is best. very bored.
Because the next adventure is already set. After Wano most likely a light arc at Elbaf then final poneglyph, Laugh Tale, Final War and Ending.
 
Top