Versus Battle Nagumo vs Shishiba

[Chrono]

I feel the only way to liven this section is with vs battles...

So....Nagumo vs Shishiba, who wins.

Location:- Town
Restrictions:-
-Shishiba has all fingers

My opinion: I see Nagumo taking this high diff....possibly extreme diff depending on how actually strong Shishiba is. In general Shishiba and Nagumo both have varying types of hype. Both I feel Nagumo has better.

 

[NikaInParis]

Nagumo should take this after a high diff fight
He has the portrayal over Shishiba and still has yet to show his current capabilities
Not to say Shishiba went balls to the wall against old Yotsumura, but he did put in great effort against a guy out of his prime

 

[Chrono]

Nagumo should take this after a high diff fight
He has the portrayal over Shishiba and still has yet to show his current capabilities
Not to say Shishiba went balls to the wall against old Yotsumura, but he did put in great effort against a guy out of his prime

Exactly....plus I kinda got the vibe Yotsumaru was afraid of Nagumo. Could be him just threatening Amane, but still I feel like Nagumo just has all the potrayal over him. Though Shishiba does have the hype of apparently being able to progess above normal Order standing.

Can you tag everyone ? Tags dont work for me.

 

[NikaInParis]

It's Chrono's fault
Tags:
@Nidai_Kitetsu @Xlaw @Chrono @Alpha @Tobra @djiayebee @Jailer @NikaInParis @Light D Lamperouge @Dark Admiral @Worst
@wordy @Vonal @Apollo
@Renzokuken @Marimo_420 @Kromage911 @BleakAsh @Don DaSlayer @Meeyori @Cream filled donut7 @Seatonnes
@CoC: Color of Clowns
@Devilbat @Yato @Woozles

 

[Apollo]

It's Chrono's fault
Tags:
@Nidai_Kitetsu @Xlaw @Chrono @Alpha @Tobra @djiayebee @Jailer @NikaInParis @Light D Lamperouge @Dark Admiral @Worst
@wordy @Vonal @Apollo
@Renzokuken @Marimo_420 @Kromage911 @BleakAsh @Don DaSlayer @Meeyori @Cream filled donut7 @Seatonnes
@CoC: Color of Clowns
@Devilbat @Yato @Woozles

There is a very real chance that Nagumo can even beat Prime Sakamoto, he clears anyone from the order other than Takamura.

 

[Nidai_Kitetsu]

Yeah, Nagumo has a better portrayal

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Nagumo easily. More prominent. Much better portrayal imo.

We've had a direct comparison with bounties which Deffo illustrates a point.​

Nagumo is the only S rank order target that we are aware of when the bounties are issued. It's been brought up numerous times only for him.

Spoiler

And he took out the second strongest assassin on the list with ease

Spoiler

Apart>Minimalist>Dump>Saw


When Kashima shows the bounties we can see that the order is
Nagumo
Sakamoto
Shishiba
Osaragi

Spoiler

This is important because we get to see and establish the order. And it's been repeated. So from there we can see that ostensibly Shishiba has been afforded an A rank

Spoiler

​

 

[Chrono]

Nagumo easily. More prominent. Much better portrayal imo.

We've had a direct comparison with bounties which Deffo illustrates a point.​

Nagumo is the only S rank order target that we are aware of when the bounties are issued. It's been brought up numerous times only for him.

Spoiler

And he took out the second strongest assassin on the list with ease

Spoiler

Apart>Minimalist>Dump>Saw


When Kashima shows the bounties we can see that the order is
Nagumo
Sakamoto
Shishiba
Osaragi

Spoiler

This is important because we get to see and establish the order. And it's been repeated. So from there we can see that ostensibly Shishiba has been afforded an A rank

Spoiler

​

But it's ridiculous how low Shishiba and Osaragi were rated. Apart should be a fodder to them...yet he was ranked higher. And Im pretty sure it's Uzuki who's been scaling them in the bounties.

I think the best possible reasoning for all of this is that Uzuki knows how strong Nagumo and Sakamoto are. He probably thinks Sakamoto is way past his prime...thus he's B rank. But since he never joined The Order, he doesnt know about Shishiba and deffo not the new recruit Osaragi.

Meaning that in general, the bounties dont really mean much. Of course thats assuming thats what the author intended, which is kinda of a pull to see him thinking like this. Then again it is his manga.

So yh Nagumo and Osaragi are deffo deserving of S-Rank. There should be a new rankings of S Ranks tho.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Imo, I think Order members are on the same level (with the exception of Takamura and Prime Sakamoto), so the fight between members would be extreme diff.

I'mma give it to Nagumo due to better feats and portrayal so far.

 

[Chrono]

Hopefully Nagumo shows his stuff against Koba and shows some really impressive feats

 

[Yato]

Imo, I think Order members are on the same level (with the exception of Takamura and Prime Sakamoto), so the fight between members would be extreme diff.

I'mma give it to Nagumo due to better feats and portrayal so far.

Imo current Nagumo potrayal is closer to the prime sakamto than average order member.
So ima give it to Nagumo high diff.

 

[CoC: Color of Clowns]

I'd say Nagumo, since he's been paired with Sakamoto a lot, and hasn't seemed to be pushed at all so far in the present. Just a smiling monster.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Imo current Nagumo potrayal is closer to the prime sakamto than average order member.
So ima give it to Nagumo high diff.

Maybe.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

But it's ridiculous how low Shishiba and Osaragi were rated. Apart should be a fodder to them...yet he was ranked higher. And Im pretty sure it's Uzuki who's been scaling them in the bounties.

I think the best possible reasoning for all of this is that Uzuki knows how strong Nagumo and Sakamoto are. He probably thinks Sakamoto is way past his prime...thus he's B rank. But since he never joined The Order, he doesnt know about Shishiba and deffo not the new recruit Osaragi.

Meaning that in general, the bounties dont really mean much. Of course thats assuming thats what the author intended, which is kinda of a pull to see him thinking like this. Then again it is his manga.

So yh Nagumo and Osaragi are deffo deserving of S-Rank. There should be a new rankings of S Ranks tho.

I think we're supposed to look at the intent here unless something major comes for us to disregard it. Nagumo has the best portrayal even without this therefore we can assume it is correct. The bounties can also work differently based on the group. Like no one from the mercs was good enough for an S rank, while from the assassins only Nagumo was good enough. They need not be interrelated. I think that's just the icing on the cake for Nagumo tbh, and don't really think the author was 'tricking' us there.

 

[Tobra]

too easy bruh

nagumo mid-high diff

 

[Chrono]

I think we're supposed to look at the intent here unless something major comes for us to disregard it. Nagumo has the best portrayal even without this therefore we can assume it is correct. The bounties can also work differently based on the group. Like no one from the mercs was good enough for an S rank, while from the assassins only Nagumo was good enough. They need not be interrelated. I think that's just the icing on the cake for Nagumo tbh, and don't really think the author was 'tricking' us there.

I like the idea of it working for it group-wise...

An A from the JAA 》》》 An A from the Serial Killers that would make sense.

I think the Serial Killers themselves werent on the list originally, until they found themselves on another section. So yh their rankings could be seperate imo.

So yh honestly at that point, Sakamoto was a B rank in my opinion. As I feel Shishiba and Osaragi would whoop Fat Sakamoto.

- So a B rank from The Order low diffed an A++ from the Serial Killers.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

I like the idea of it working for it group-wise...

An A from the JAA 》》》 An A from the Serial Killers that would make sense.

I think the Serial Killers themselves werent on the list originally, until they found themselves on another section. So yh their rankings could be seperate imo.

So yh honestly at that point, Sakamoto was a B rank in my opinion. As I feel Shishiba and Osaragi would whoop Fat Sakamoto.

- So a B rank from The Order low diffed an A++ from the Serial Killers.

Yeah that works the best imo.


It's separate and they are not interrelated therefore an A from the JAA>>> an A from the serial killers, and etc.

 

[Seatonnes]

As much as i love shishiba
Nagumo obviously takes the W