Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Game End - Indie Victory]

[KWEH]

I mean, me, ultra and kweh could end up like tripple protected so looking at active people it's a choice between you, flower, orca and polar. 4 people

Hegel oughta be a scum character methinks? Isn't that thing a boss or something?

 

[KWEH]

I said i could vouch for Yoho

Fucking hell lmao ye I remember now 😂

 

[Flower]

No you're talking about a whole lot of shit that has no significance.

Strictly, from a logical standpoint, there is absolutely nothing proving that the green faction isn't mafia, nor that they couldn't kill him. You're speculating on what you think is likely, but you're needlessly confusing yourself and others.

Dude.

It is stated a single flavour ONLY knows the wincon.

There won't be a faction with a bunch of people when only a single player even knows what they have to do.

Which means that flavour is a Cult/Cultafia leader. And gradually converts the scum members.

 

[Flower]

Or the scum members convert themselves with their abilities.

Still that's something you have to factor into your theory.

 

[Flower]

So...

That player decided to kill Polar instead of a YoRHa claim when that seems to be the main threat to them because...?

 

[Ultra]

Dude.

It is stated a single flavour ONLY knows the wincon.

There won't be a faction with a bunch of people when only a single player even knows what they have to do.

Which means that flavour is a Cult/Cultafia leader. And gradually converts the scum members.

Ok Flower time to go baby mode.

Objective -

The true objective of your faction is currently unknown except to The Red Girls (N2), however, you are instructed to obey and ensue chaos...

See this, right here? This doesn't mean "The Red Girls" know the identity of every single player who is detached from them. They do not issue commands to players who are not yet part of their alignment. You insisting they wouldn't kill Polar because (headcanon) is not logical

 

[Charlie]

Hegel oughta be a scum character methinks? Isn't that thing a boss or something?

what's the use of this tho?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

ok this isn't productive.

Who kills PB and is it a coincidence that some of his top scumreads happened to not claim android or machine yet? Also Ultra was there too

 

[Ultra]

QED - There's no contradiction in the available information to start spitballing he was killed by xyz

 

[Yoho]

Fucking hell lmao ye I remember now 😂

🤣🤣

 

[The Orca]

Not sure why you all are entertaining Ultra and his ramblings at this point

Things we can deduce or have been revealed in Polar's flip

Adam and Eve (Green) were created

Polar was killed, he was town purple machine and then he was Adam, Green faction

Polar was in a neighbor on D1 via his purple town role

Red Girls is part of the Green Faction with Eve

Doesn't matter how Polar or the other(s) changed (probably just a game mechanic)

Stick to hunting mafia, don't get side tracked on D2

 

[Flower]

Ok Flower time to go baby mode.



See this, right here? This doesn't mean "The Red Girls" know the identity of every single player who is detached from them. They do not issue commands to players who are not yet part of their alignment. You insisting they wouldn't kill Polar because (headcanon) is not logical

So the game started with a single hostile role and could have been over by EoD1, then?

 

[Flower]

Anyway @Gadonkadonk claim.

 

[Luka]

I dont get it is Polar Bear town or mafia why is there a fake claim lol.

Probably mafia

 

[Luka]

Also shame on you guys for lynching Butter.

Tend to agree and it was a wolfy kill by Ultra
I wasnt able to be in thread to defend them but the obtuseness felt villagery

 

[Luka]

Vote Random Asshole.

My vote is glued to him today for reasons.

Is this being cheeky or mech

 

[Ultra]

Tend to agree and it was a wolfy kill by Ultra
I wasnt able to be in thread to defend them but the obtuseness felt villagery

It's not a kill it's a lynch

 

[Ultra]

Butter had it coming...not my fault!

 

[Random Asshole]

Is this being cheeky or mech

Vote duel

 

[Luka]

How did Adam die is what Im wondering lol.

Wha
Factional or vig no? Why like, even wonder this tbh