Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Night 5]

[Ultra]

Enough with the elitism we can play mafia here as well.

Ill give you that Red Girls sounds like one role youre right.

No you don't get my point. This is a situation where there's no reason you should expect brushing everything aside and playing "normal" mafia is gonna do anything for you. It's just silly

 

[Fujishiro]

@Ultra There is another scum role called Grun and its the one that protected Gad.

 

[Ultra]

@Ultra wanna lynch Yoho and call it a day lol.

Nah just shoot him or something

 

[Fujishiro]

No you don't get my point. This is a situation where there's no reason you should expect brushing everything aside and playing "normal" mafia is gonna do anything for you. It's just silly

Oh I got your point but I maintain that we dont know the setup so Im just going to play normally and assume there is atleast 2 people in a scum chat lol.

 

[Ultra]

@Ultra There is another scum role called Grun and its the one that protected Gad.

I am aware. I didn't say there was only a singular scum role, but there is only one role that knows the win condition.

 

[Fujishiro]

I dont think Polar Bear was vigged because he was defending Butter as town so I dont see the vig shooting him lol.

 

[Ultra]

And if there's a bunch of lone scum then scum hunting the traditional way is basically a shot in the dark

 

[Fujishiro]

i mean, Gad is kinda outed scum and Polar was town atm, so...

good job, Polar i guess?

We dont know if Gad is a red herring or no lol. Ill assume hes scum though lol.

 

[Fujishiro]

And if there's a bunch of lone scum then scum hunting the traditional way is basically a shot in the dark

They should know they are scum though so they would be playing in a certain way that doesnt feel genuine lol.

 

[Ultra]

They should know they are scum though so they would be playing in a certain way that doesnt feel genuine lol.

Nope.

Lone scum with lack of TMI don't actually operate that differently. If I was one I'd basically do the same thing Luka is doing and pretending this was a normal game and tossing some reads into LHF knowing I might even get some credit if one is scum

 

[Charlie]

We dont know if Gad is a red herring or no lol. Ill assume hes scum though lol.

people always talk in similar situations that this could be mafia trying to frame someone but i really don't remember a game where mafia used ability made to protect them, hoping to frame some inactive .-. like, imagine if gad was some town role that could easily confirm itself

just naaah

 

[Yoho]

@Ultra wanna lynch Yoho and call it a day lol.

🤧 you wanna lynch me just cause I voted you?

Shame

 

[Charlie]

actually i went back at Luka's claim and it's not like he just claimed neighbour, he was figured out and then he confirmed it

couldn't someone like, tell me this when i asked like 3 times? .-. he could be scum i guess, claimed abilities but not being polar's neighbour despite people asking about it since d2 started

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

@Pot Goblin hey dumb question but how did u confuse your role PM with being a machine if you're an android? One role clearly says living machine and one clearly says yorha, plus the yorha roles seem to mention that you either kill machines (BS' flip) or they don't mention machines at all (Polar's fake Yorha flip)

 

[Emil]

Day 2 - Vote Count 3
​

Votes:
Flower -> RA
Ultra -> Pot > Luka
Indigo -> RA > Unvote > YTW
Orca -> AM > YTW
Luka -> RA
Kweh -> Luka
Fuji -> YTW > Lemon > Luka
YTW -> Ultra
Gad -> Ultra > Lemon > Luka > Lemon
Charlie -> YTW
York -> YTW > Lemon
T-pein -> Luka > Gad
Crying -> RA
AM -> YTW
Alexis -> Lemon
Hime -> Luka
Yoho -> Fuji


Count:
Luka = 4 (Ultra, Kweh, Hime, Fuji)
YTW = 3 (Orca, Charlie, Indigo, AM)
Lemon = 3 (York, Alexis, Gad)
RA = 3 (Flower, Luka, Crying)
Ultra = 1 (YTW)
Fuji = 1 (Yoho)


Not Voting = 4 (RN, RA, Pot, Lemon)

Please let me know if I made any mistakes.

With 21 alive, it's 11 votes required to achieve majority.
Day 2 ends in a little more than 12 hours.

Countdown
​

Spoiler: Player List

Living Players [21/23]

1. @Yoho
2. @Alexis2282AE
3. @Fujishiro
4. @Yo Tan Wa
5. @Alwaysmind
6. @York
7. @The Orca
8. @KWEH
9. @Flower
10. @Red Night
11. @Random Asshole
12. @Charlie
13. @Pot Goblin
14. @Ultra
15. @Luka
16. @Indigo
17. @lemon.de
18. @T-Pein™
19. @Crying bc no Cryo
20. @Gadonkadonk
21. @hime

Dead Players [2/23]

1. @Butterscotch Sundae - YoRHA No. 9 Type S (9S) - YoRHa aligned - Lynched Day 1
2. @Polar Bear - Adam - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 1

Subs

1. @Lord Melkor
2. @Rej
3. @tepig19283
4. @Worst
5. @Ratchet
6. @Orwellian

 

[Ultra]

people always talk in similar situations that this could be mafia trying to frame someone but i really don't remember a game where mafia used ability made to protect them, hoping to frame some inactive .-. like, imagine if gad was some town role that could easily confirm itself

just naaah

The complication here is that if scum are separated the person in question might genuinely not know unless it's gad himself

 

[Ultra]

But otherwise would agree that any framing utility that ability has is probably offset by wasting it as such. Nothing redeemable about Gad anyway

 

[Alwaysmind]

took a nap and gad a premonition about this game.
but in my dream one of the player isn even on this forum let alone the game.

it was something about Eve having a yellow coloured role.

 

[Alwaysmind]

And the player not here. Cardboard tube knight….

 

[Pot Goblin]

@Pot Goblin hey dumb question but how did u confuse your role PM with being a machine if you're an android? One role clearly says living machine and one clearly says yorha, plus the yorha roles seem to mention that you either kill machines (BS' flip) or they don't mention machines at all (Polar's fake Yorha flip)

Cause I literally never touched this flavor before lmao