Speculations No Ginny is not Bonney and she is not alive

[DarkWitch]

I've seen some people think that Ginny is still alive and that she is Bonney herself, imo I highly doubt that's the case and Ginny herself is most likely dead.

I've mentioned this in the 1097 spoiler thread and I'll mention it again here, in almost all character flashbacks there is always someone important in that flashback that always ends up being killed.

For the Law flashback it was Rosinante.

For Big Mom it was Mother Carmel and the Orphanage Kids.

For Oden it was Oden himself.

For Robin it was the people of Ohara and Robin's Mom

For Brook it was his original Pirate Crew.

And so on.

So when it comes to the Kuma flashback, the character Ginny has been shown to be a very important character. I think it's obvious that at some point in the flashback, Ginny ends up being killed.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

The question is always with Ginny dead, where does Bonney come from

 

[Woozles]

The question is always with Ginny dead, where does Bonney come from

Did you forget which island this arc takes place on?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Did you forget which island this arc takes place on?

Cloning a dead girl is just creepy I’m sorry

 

[Woozles]

Cloning a dead girl is just creepy I’m sorry

As opposed to cloning living breathing people...

 

[Sir Yasheen]

As opposed to cloning living breathing people...

Yeah cause what is kuma taking Ginny’s dead body and saying please clone my dead partner? Hell nah

 

[Woozles]

Yeah cause what is kuma taking Ginny’s dead body and saying please clone my dead partner? Hell nah

But raising your actual partner as your own child isn't creepy

 

[Sir Yasheen]

But raising your actual partner as your own child isn't creepy

Yeah significantly different from raising someone who willingly reverted to a child and losing their members and paying them back for raising you from taking their dead body to a scientist to do illegal shit to bring them back to life as a child…

 

[Woozles]

Yeah significantly different from raising someone who willingly reverted to a child and losing their members and paying them back for raising you from taking their dead body to a scientist to do illegal shit to bring them back to life as a child…

So we're supposed to believe that Ginny willingly chose to revert to being a infant and wiped all of her memories?

In the clone arc...

 

[Sir Yasheen]

So we're supposed to believe that Ginny willingly chose to revert to being a infant and wiped all of her memories?

In the clone arc...

Seeing how Vegapunk and Kuma haven’t even met yet and suddenly Kuma giving her corpse to a man he’s never met makes no sense….

Yeah

 

[Woozles]

Seeing how Vegapunk and Kuma haven’t even met yet and suddenly Kuma giving her corpse to a man he’s never met makes no sense….

Yeah

my guy, you're putting her corpse in his hands well before we know when she may have died.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

my guy, you're putting her corpse in his hands well before we know when she may have died.

Yeah cause if she’s not dead before kuma gets there she’s not going to die since kumas powers would take all her pain into himself.

 

[Woozles]

Yeah cause if she’s not dead before kuma gets there she’s not going to die since kumas powers would take all her pain into himself.

Mans, we don't know who took her or the proximity of her to Vegapunk.

It's entirely possible she met vegapunk and died before Kuma could rescue her.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Ginny doesn't HAVE to die, after all nobody died in Luffy's backstory/flashback, or King and Kaidou's (though those were ridiculously short and straightforward tbf), but yeah she's likely to or is probably captured or in hiding.
Maybe we get a Saul thing where she's in a predicament where she's believed to have died, but actually survived and is laying low until she can strike back somehow.

 

[ConquistadoR]

I cannot believe people read 1000+ chapters of this manga and still dont get Oda's formula of story telling... Ginny is 100% gonna die in the flashback.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

I cannot believe people read 1000+ chapters of this manga and still dont get Oda's formula of story telling... Ginny is 100% gonna die in the flashback.

I'd say it's either that or she, as I said above, gets a Saul type fakeout, but Oda always kills off the women in the flashbacks for some reason.
Except for Bellmere, she's still in the dungeon.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

The clone thing is the most possibile,altough yeah i agree that there is not a valid reason why she should have had been cloned. Unless it was just Vegapunk experimenting with Ginny,then created Stussy,then Weevil? But why Whitebeard didnt end up to be cloned well if he is a clone too?

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

Bonney is clone of Ginny , we know stussy has her own clone why not Bonney.

So why they cloned Ginny would be interested it has to do with Saturn he was definitely experimenting people or blackmail Kuma to work with world govt shit can be endless.
[automerge]1698899686[/automerge]

Ginny doesn't HAVE to die, after all nobody died in Luffy's backstory/flashback, or King and Kaidou's (though those were ridiculously short and straightforward tbf), but yeah she's likely to or is probably captured or in hiding.
Maybe we get a Saul thing where she's in a predicament where she's believed to have died, but actually survived and is laying low until she can strike back somehow.

She is definately dying it’s going to be related to Bonney .