General & Others Where Does One Piece Rank compared to other Shonen In terms of overall story?

[pg13]

 

[Djordje]

I didnt read/watch much manga / anime but from those I did :

Naruto ( at least part 1 ) is much better and Yugioh (before GX) is way better than One piece.

Oda is simply shit at building tension and high stakes which is for my personal taste a huge disadvantage.

 

[SkySanji]

Rank in terms of what? Popularity? Enjoyability? Writing? Fights? World building? etc...

 

[Rumble]

In what terms?

 

[pg13]

In what terms?

Overall story

 

[Unlimited Rulebook]

Overall story

Overall story? That isn’t Oda’s strong suit at all. Oda is top notch for environments and also, on rare occasions, for characters. Story-wise, he is like a middle-school kid writer, lacking flow and consistency, much less writing a cohesive story. Oda depends on visuals. He could never write a decent novel.

 

[Mathias]

Overall story

One Piece isn't worth a thing in terms of quality in history of literature.

Destiny child that will save the earth from a millenium of lies and whatnot.

Sounds like I'm reading some kind of biblical story.