General & Others Objectively Who is Luffys most Skilled Crewmember?

T H E M O S T S K I L L E D ?


  • Total voters
    82
#44
If that's the case, then it's obviously Sanji. Bro gets points everywhere. There isn't a stat you can talk about where Sanji at least doesn't get above-average marks while you can't say the same about the rest of the crew.
Well, he was raised by judge to be a all around person, a total soldier and then had really good mentor in Zeff and a shitty place to grow up ( the resturant lol ) where if you grow up, you just learn every skill lol
Its kinda like growing in crowded families
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#45
Well, he was raised by judge to be a all around person, a total soldier and then had really good mentor in Zeff and a shitty place to grow up ( the resturant lol ) where if you grow up, you just learn every skill lol
Its kinda like growing in crowded families
It isn't just about where you grow up. Luffy and Zoro were raised among wise men too, they aren't the sharpest tools when it comes to brains.

While the other SHs, ignoring their specialties, lack in more than one ways compared to Sanji.
 
#47
Franky/Brook top tier

Chopper comes in a close 3rd

The rest are pretty similar aside from Luffy who just makes shit up as he goes along most of the time. Sanji could rank in 4th, but his craft is easily replicated like when nami cooked that fish and cooking in general is an easy thing to learn.
 
#51
Luffy literally said her food isnt as good as Sanji's...
Its like saying anyone with haki is as good as Shanks
When did he say that? I don't think Luffy even ate the fish since he started eating before she cooked and poisoned himself.

Either way it wouldn't matter too much, that was her first time cooking it and no one even mentioned sanji's name they all looked it, clearly sanji's skills are easily replicated. Nami couldn't just read Brook's guide to piano and start playing Chopin. She wouldn't even be able to play chopsticks, but she made great food easily by just reading once


Sanji is skilled, but his talents simply do not require the person to be that talented to be good at it. It's like comparing the skillset of checkers to chess.
 
#52
Chopper > Nami > Franky > the rest

1. No one can do what Chopper can in the whole crew and if not for him some of them would be dead
2. Nami is excellent navigator but others could do it just not as good as her
3.Franky amazing shipwright but like with Nami others can do it just not as good as him

For the rest;
- Robin can hard to scale
- Sanji is an excellent cook but many others in the crew can do it
-Usopp jack of la trades
- Zoro second to none when it comes to combat but everyone else can hold their own
- Jinbe, others can steer the ship
- Brook since he is somewhat useful
- completely useless
 
#55
Franky/Brook top tier

Chopper comes in a close 3rd

The rest are pretty similar aside from Luffy who just makes shit up as he goes along most of the time. Sanji could rank in 4th, but his craft is easily replicated like when nami cooked that fish and cooking in general is an easy thing to learn.
Reminder it takes a decade to master making sushi alone. Cooking is not an easy thing to learn
 
#56
Reminder it takes a decade to master making sushi alone. Cooking is not an easy thing to learn
That's only because they have starter chefs doing dumb shit like washing rice for 5 years. These days you can learn michelin starred cooking by watching youtube tutorials for a few weeks, why? Because it's not that difficult.

It cannot be compared to medicine, shipwright or even a musician, especially one like brook who seems to have mastered every instrument.
 
#57
That's only because they have starter chefs doing dumb shit like washing rice for 5 years. These days you can learn michelin starred cooking by watching youtube tutorials for a few weeks, why? Because it's not that difficult.

It cannot be compared to medicine, shipwright or even a musician, especially one like brook who seems to have mastered every instrument.
Thinking you can become a Michelin star chef via YouTube is wild.
 
Top