Controversial Oda can't draw sword fights

[Stacks]

Its honestly trash all the sword fights in this manga is absolutely trash compared to other sword fights in another manga

Why draw and make a lot of characters who wield swords if you can't draw them

 

[Midnight Delight]

100% true
Even Zoro fans here only like his One Liners and Poses, not his actual techniques

Even Sasuke had more interesting Swordmanship than Shanks for example

 

[Patryipe]

Correct. His best fight are those were you have brawlers with "emitting" powers.

 

[nik87]

He can, its just that there are only two fights in the entire show that are between two "pure" swordsmen.
Zoro vs WSS of the past, the first Kokuto user.
And Zoro vs WSS of the present, 2nd Kokuto user.
All other fights are having a different flavor, whether through DFs or racial abilities or something else.

 

[Stacks]

100% true
Even Zoro fans here only like his One Liners and Poses, not his actual techniques

Even Sasuke had more interesting Swordmanship than Shanks for example

Roger and Shanks did a basic sword swing

fans: GOOODAAAAA

 

[Momonosuke]

I mean dudes not that great of an artist, however he does write a pretty entertaining adventure manga. I just wish he wouldn't get so carried away, or maybe if he had a better filing system for the different ideas he has and subplots he introduces.

 

[Stacks]

He can, its just that there are only two fights in the entire show that are between two "pure" swordsmen.
Zoro vs WSS of the past, the first Kokuto user.
And Zoro vs WSS of the present, 2nd Kokuto user.
All other fights are having a different flavor, whether through DFs or racial abilities or something else.

it can have a different flavor but it still taste sour

 

[gz89]

Its not only about the drawing, but the lack of blood.

Bleach might have big pace issues but its swordfights were bloody and gore and it was something that made those fights look amazing.

 

[Peroroncino]

Its not only about the drawing, but the lack of blood.

Bleach might have big pace issues but its swordfights were bloody and gore and it was something that made those fights look amazing.

what's amazing about bleach sword fights where almost all wounds were bloody slashes across the shoulder?

 

[RYNO]

I mean dudes not that great of an artist,

 

[gz89]

what's amazing about bleach sword fights where almost all wounds were bloody slashes across the shoulder?

Thats true for some fights indeed, but there were cases that characters lost their limbs, Byakuya's fights were all bloody not some shoulder cuts etc etc. In the OP verse after mr1 & Kaku most of the fights especially post ts are haki energy slashes, especially the anime ruined everything with the fucking auras..

 

[Momonosuke]

I mean he's nowhere near as terrible as whoever does jojos bizarre adventures, but there are plenty of op characters who's designs are just as cringeworthy. Ivankov, big mom, bon clay, doflamingo, queen, perosperro, etc.
[automerge]1681384593[/automerge]

Thats true for some fights indeed, but there were cases that characters lost their limbs, Byakuya's fights were all bloody not some shoulder cuts etc etc. In the OP verse after mr1 & Kaku most of the fights especially post ts are haki energy slashes, especially the anime ruined everything with the fucking auras..

I get what you're saying, but how does someone count byakuyas little flowers as a sword fight?

 

[WaidoWSC]

Cross out the word „Sword“ and you got it correct..

 

[gz89]

I mean he's nowhere near as terrible as whoever does jojos bizarre adventures, but there are plenty of op characters who's designs are just as cringeworthy. Ivankov, big mom, bon clay, doflamingo, queen, perosperro, etc.
[automerge]1681384593[/automerge]

I get what you're saying, but how does someone count byakuyas little flowers as a sword fight?

Byakuya was just an example. Zaraki's fights were also fantastic and full bloody. Aizen stomping the captains aswell.

pre ts swordfights of Zoro were not bad imo the real problem was after the ts that haki was the main thing.

 

[kumae]

Maybe loda but it also happens with punchs and kicks till you don't see animate

 

[Loki D. Terror]

Byakuya was just an example. Zaraki's fights were also fantastic and full bloody. Aizen stomping the captains aswell.

pre ts swordfights of Zoro were not bad imo the real problem was after the ts that haki was the main thing.

Bleach flights >> OP fights

 

[Herrera95]

in this manga is absolutely trash compared to other sword fights in another manga

We work with panels dude.

 

[Stacks]

We work with panels dude.

Not a problem look at other manga with swordplay

 

[Herrera95]

Not a problem look at other manga with swordplay

Not me. You have to proof your point.

 

[The White Crane]

Its honestly trash all the sword fights in this manga is absolutely trash compared to other sword fights in another manga

Why draw and make a lot of characters who wield swords if you can't draw them

What else is new?
[automerge]1681392751[/automerge]

He can, its just that there are only two fights in the entire show that are between two "pure" swordsmen.
Zoro vs WSS of the past, the first Kokuto user.
And Zoro vs WSS of the present, 2nd Kokuto user.
All other fights are having a different flavor, whether through DFs or racial abilities or something else.

Zoro vs Ryuma has the best swordfight choreo pre-TS, tbh.