General & Others Oda didn't said that ...

#1
I see many times people use the argument : Oda told us in the box that X and Y
and I told them : no legit writer is crazy enough to break the 4th wall and talk to them ... boxes are NOT Oda's world ... they are IN-WORLD data

it don't means they are WRONG
but it don't means they are always right .... just like this piece of shit



this is not Oda telling us : I name this version of WB the WSM
this is in world data about a man's title



any way .... here is Oda in SBS 67 explaining his own method



D: Pleased to meet you, Oda-chi! Heso!! I'll try to make this quick, but... I noticed a certain one of Oda-chi's policies? Or is it poliswees?!! Oda-chi... you don't seem to write lines in your own handwriting on the side as supplements to character's speech bubbles!? Other manga-ka do it a lot, but... please explain this for me!! Penname- Myaari

O: Ohh. Yes. Lines written in speech bubbles vs. lines written outside them- good job noticing. I did the latter back when I was a newbie and even during the early days of serialization. But I made the conscious decision to stop doing that relatively early on, so you could call it a policy. Of course I don't mind it if other authors do it, but I thought that if I did that, the reader might see my handwritten characters while reading and suddenly become aware that there is an "author", so I stopped. While reading my manga, I want you to forget about my existence.


@Seraphoenix @RayanOO @Bullet @Natalija @ODIAK D.TSEGNORTS @Erkan12 @GeneralP123 @Salah WG @Irregular @XGoldrogeRX @Steven @Shiroyru@Sentinel @Tejas @5000 ng/dl or death @Trafalgar_D_Law @TrafalgarD.Law @Rosella.Fiamingo @Rmstorm @playa4321 @Olimaat @Nidai_Kitetsu@MonsterKaido @Lifeismeh @Jo_Ndule @Enryu @HA001 @ShishioIsBack @Fleet Admiral Lee Hung @Buusatan94 @Lukegranders @Luffy is the mc @SDfear @uyuu @Hades @Enryu @Dark Admiral @Akai @Tekashi69420 @Kenshiro11 @GeneralP123 @Fujishiro @zaman @Desolate Smaug @Just a member @Celestial D. Dragon @Big D. Kaios @Bounty @Camie @Jew D. Boy @Ichiro Miyata @KINGKONGGUN15 @Pan D. A. Man @Shanks Joestar @MarineHQ62 @Chaves @Kejon @PurpleSwordsman @Gol D. Roger @AdmiralKinyagi @kurwa @Monkey D Luffy @Xlaw @Inflamed Haki @K!NG HARA$H!MA @stealthblack @Luffy the Yonko Slayer @TheAncientCenturion @Arrow @Guan Yu @Guiding_Thunder @T.D.A @Blackbeard @Light D Lamperouge @Bogard
 
Last edited:
H

Herrera95

#14
This is just excuse for people say shit about OP and not Oda and he writes terrible like he has been doing lately.

But overall you are right. Like "on 1v1 bet on Kaido" this is how World portrayal him, not how he is in fact. World doesn't know about Oden that made 2 scars on him and almost killed him. World doesn't know what happen at his encounter with Shanks. World doesn't know what happened at God Valley.

And I would say the same about everything any character says, including explanations about haki. This is 1500, haki is like science that people are studying. Is not fully discovered yet, and it can have wrong affirmations that people are spreading as true.

For example, haki blooms at extreme situations. But can you trick your own mind to do that? Katakuri need extreme situation to unlock his future sight, but he is told to be invincible and said he never fought someone so strong until Luffy. So how he went on exterme situation to unlock his haki? Maybe BM trained him and she is capable of doing that for sure. What would make me think, why Rayleigh didn't the same with Luffy but left him 6 months alone...
 
#16
Mens going next level to push their agenda doubting info boxes that Oda gives
yes ... pointing out what Oda said is next level agenda ... sure
Post automatically merged:

It seems Mihawk's title is wrong ; he got called the strongest by sanji thanks to u guys
:hihihi:
Mihawk is safe ... characters called him that too
Post automatically merged:

@Fenaker Mihawk title box is fake?
Post automatically merged:


Whitebeard was the strongest pirate, confirmed by Oda in his volume cover at MF :suresure:
Oda never confirmed shit
and WSP is a political title as novel explained it
 
#17
Obvious all titles are inverse and all of them are not 100% accurate.........this is what the general public and characters of one piece world feels about them and are hailed as such.........this is not oda's opinion but general civilian's opinions/viewpoint...........there are lots of factors becasue of which titles can get rendered in effective such as sickness in case of Sickbeard
 
#18
If you think like this you can basically consider that anything a character said is not true because it is just his opinion and not the author.

For example: Garp said that the Yonko are the most powerful pirates but it is his opinion, so this might be false.

At the beginning of MF war the narrator introduce the admirals as the strongest force of the GM so I guess it can be false too.

Do you see the rabbit hole?
 
Top