Yeah
That's why BM was clean after the war while the rest were bandaged
That's why no rocks was in critical state bar Xebec and Kaido
Post the panel of WB, BM, shiki running away?
WB and BM never suffered defeat there
Oda first shows us: Captain John, Wang Shi, Silver Axe, Shiki, BM, Kaido, WB, and such are all part of Xebec's crew. He shows them in a line up.
Oda then shows a panel of the actual matchup that took place against Xebec. And guess what it was? 4 vs 2. And who came out the winner? Garp and Roger.
I don't care about your headcanon of how that fight went. The reality is based on what we know, it was a 4 vs 2 match up of WB/Kaido/BM/Xebec vs Roger/Garp, with Shiki/Raylaigh/Gaban/other marines/etc fighting their own fights.