Status
Not open for further replies.
By adding additional scene in the rushed part.
I don't watch the anime weekly but I have heard the anime already added scenes in Shutara vs Sternritter and Uryu vs Renji that were shorter in the manga.

It's called having an opinion dumbfuck. Fuck outta here.
Chill, we can make what happened in One Piece discussions, stay in OP discussions. Let's discuss Bleach in civil manner like normal human being.
 
Four chapters ago the story details were so poorly thought out and artistically rendered, readers thought it was all part of an in-story conspiracy either stemming from a hallucination or from a dream.
Tbf none of it was story breaking stuff, just really weird minor inconsistencies
The drop off in storyline intricacy has been noticable for a while now, but the franchise is still doing great numbers
 
My thoughts about One Piece is that it's pretty flawed but it still the only shonen I have been seriously following weekly for a decade while I tend to get bored pretty easily of other series, so Oda is doing something right at least.

I still have to catch up to HxH chapters for example
HxH is a hard read for me. I haven't been able to get past the beginning of the current arc.
 
Tbf none of it was story breaking stuff, just really weird minor inconsistencies
The drop off in storyline intricacy has been noticable for a while now, but the franchise is still doing great numbers
We also have to understand that the story has so many moving parts that weren't there before the timeskip. Bro is juggling so many characters and plot threads which must be extremely overwhelming.

The scope of the story is just insane, that's why I forgive Oda for inconsistencies with Haki and details here and there since it's pretty clear that he's trying his best. I still think he's doing a very good job compared to his peers.
 
My thoughts about One Piece is that it's pretty flawed but it still the only shonen I have been seriously following weekly for a decade while I tend to get bored pretty easily of other series, so Oda is doing something right at least.

I still have to catch up to HxH chapters for example
I don't know if you are following Kingdom like the majority of Admiral fans. But yeah, following OP weekly no matter how bad it is lately > following Kingdom weekly.
Kingdom is really hard to read on weekly basis, I stopped following the series seriously after Kanki's death.

Back then we had Bleach and Fairy Tail. Miss those days
 
It's just not fun anymore, call me an idiot but I'm not looking to read a fucking novel when I get into a shonen
I try not to judge it so hard since it generates a lot of passion among its fans (kinda like One Piece)

Togashi is clearly doing something right, but not everybody is going to see it the same way. What I've heard is that since he takes so long with outlining his plot and character arcs, the writing is leagues above anything else in shonen.
 
It's just not fun anymore, call me an idiot but I'm not looking to read a fucking novel when I get into a shonen
I think that's the story's forte, though.
HxH implements more novelistic aspects, just like Bleach and, more recently, Sakamoto implement more cinematographic ones.
With comics being a marriage between visual and textual, to become more unique a work has to either skew in one direction rather than the other, or to perfectly balance the two.
 
I try not to judge it so hard since it generates a lot of passion among its fans (kinda like One Piece)

Togashi is clearly doing something right, but not everybody is going to see it the same way. What I've heard is that since he takes so long with outlining his plot and character arcs, the writing is leagues above anything else in shonen.
HxH's writing is great, clearly above One Piece. It'

I think that's the story's forte, though.
HxH implements more novelistic aspects, just like Bleach and, more recently, Sakamoto implement more cinematographic ones.
With comics being a marriage between visual and textual, to become more unique a work has to either skew in one direction rather than the other, or to perfectly balance the two.
Many people are into it so Togashi struck gold, but I disagree with the idea HxH is inherently better because it is more text focused. For all its flaws, I wouldn't want One Piece to become like HxH
 
HxH's writing is great, clearly above One Piece. It'


Many people are into it so Togashi struck gold, but I disagree with the idea HxH is inherently better because it is more text focused. For all its flaws, I wouldn't want One Piece to become like HxH
My point wasn't that HxH is better than OP (nor am I claiming the opposite).

What I said was, the wordiness is what makes HxH HxH. Such an extensive focus on dialogue and narration wouldn't fit another series, let alone one that's 1000+ chapters in, like OP.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top