News One Piece Live Action Series!!

[Rootbeer]

Omitting attack names should be a general rule to stick to.
It doesn't translate well into live action at all.

They can implicitly hint towards their attack names as a nod to manga/anime fans by commenting on them like e.g. "my fist hits as hard as a rifle (gomu gome rifle)"

Ofc my example is off the cuff, a writers team could hopefully come up with something more natural

I think it's not that it doesn't translate well, it's that they just didn't do it well.. It's very static and his words doesn't match the action..

 

[HA001]

If tou going to do attack names stick to finishers

 

[Don Diego]

The live action is clearly intended for western children who haven’t read One Piece. That is why we have MCU dialogue because western kids still love those films.

Same for western adults. They are still love those movies

 

[Hanners220]

Same for western adults. They are still love those movies

They sure do and I don’t know why?

 

[NikaInParis]

I think it's not that it doesn't translate well, it's that they just didn't do it well.. It's very static and his words doesn't match the action..

To each their own but I still think attack names = too cartoony

 

[Rootbeer]

To each their own but I still think attack names = too cartoony

You would need to explain that to me, cause i think it's cool.. It's like a kid point of view, naming your attack makes it more powerful, especially if you have Rubber powers..

Galaxy Impact would not have hit the same without the name?..

 

[NikaInParis]

You would need to explain that to me, cause i think it's cool.. It's like a kid point of view, naming your attack makes it more powerful, especially if you have Rubber powers..

Galaxy Impact would not have hit the same without the name?..

If it's just a Luffy specific thing, then it isn't that big of a deal. But hearing Zoro or Sanji call out their attacks in LA would be cringey af.

I don't get the Galax Impact point at all. Are you comparing manga to live action now?

 

[Toby D. Dog]

My father in law came across the trailer and even though he’s known about one piece for years, he’s just now shown interest in it. I guess there is always a silver lining to these things. I’ll remain optimistically cautious from now on.

 

[Luffydom56]

Some fans are so far up opla dick that they are ready to insult Manga Luffy over that trash. Can’t wait till gear 5 anime hype overshadows this shit.

 

[Toby D. Dog]

Some fans are so far up opla dick that they are ready to insult Manga Luffy over that trash. Can’t wait till gear 5 anime hype overshadows this shit.

July right?

 

[Luffydom56]

Unironically correct

 

[Rootbeer]

If it's just a Luffy specific thing, then it isn't that big of a deal. But hearing Zoro or Sanji call out their attacks in LA would be cringey af.

I don't get the Galax Impact point at all. Are you comparing manga to live action now?

Yeah ok, it would be tricky with Zoro and Sanji.. But i sure i hope i get to hear Party Table Kick when he destroy Fullbody..

Edit: That was Anime only, but they Seem to go the Anime route somewhat already with Nami..

Actually, they don't need to show them saying it, the audience can hear them saying it dubbed as the attack is executed..
That would be dope i think, that's how they did it in the Anime for Sanji's first technique.. They probably won't think of that though..

Whether, it's live action or the manga, the point is the delivery wouldn't be the same..

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Doesn't mean much comming from a moron..

Luffy is also not an American from the USA yet he can act in english.. Why your arguments are so stupid..

Bougya

 

[LubeDaddy]

the trailer looks like absolute hot garbage. As expected. Live action adaptations of manga don't work

 

[pg13]

Unironically correct

Honestly I think they should just drop the Named Attacks and they’ll be ok ✅

 

[Toby D. Dog]

Honestly I think they should just drop the Named Attacks and they’ll be ok ✅

They should just use it for the big ones.

 

[ShadyOjiro]

They should just use it for the big ones.

I say just once.

 

[Toby D. Dog]

I say just once.

Elaborate.

 

[pg13]

They should just use it for the big ones.

No don't say it at all........ Its not suppose to be 1 for 1 its suppose to be its own thing.

 

[CodeBreaker]

where is Sanji's cigarette?