Role Madness One Piece Mash 2.0

[Michelle]

@Polar Bear has replaced @Marr​

Welcome Polar, share any thoughts you have pls

 

[Yoho]

🤔🤔

 

[Michelle]

Spoiler

Marr: Waluigi
bittersweet: Lord Melkor > EkkoLoJinx > Pot Goblin > Orca > Michelle > Udell > Udell
The Orca: Udell > Michelle > Udell
Waluigi: EkkoLoJinx (havent moved my vote yet from Melkor)
Hayumi: EkkoLoJinx > The Orca > Pot Goblin > Udell
Charlie: The Orca > Pot Goblin
EkkoLoJinx: Red Night > Pot Goblin
Naomi: Marr > Charlie > unvote > Marr > EkkoLoJinx > Waluigi
Luka: Pot Goblin
Udell: Pot Goblin
Michelle: Pot Goblin > UNVOTE
Red Night: Reloaded
Mr Reloaded: Orca


​

Pot Goblin- 4 - Charlie, Ekko, Luka, Udell
Udell- 3 - Bittersweet, Orca, Hayumi,
Waluigi- 2 - Marr, Naomi
Ekko- 1 - Waluigi
Reloaded- 1 - Red Night
Orca- 1 - Reloaded
No vote- Michelle,
and everyone else hasnt placed a vote yet.

Vote: Udell

REASON

Because this one can actually flip wolf, and the shopkeeper won't, and I won't, and Orca won't, and I won't vanity vote Ekko just because Melkor did, without questioning them first.

ALTERNATIVE SUSPECTS

Would also consider voting for Michelle, and Naomi even if they flip town, because they're just killing townies this game and ending their ability to do so would be very pro town.

Would be willing to vote for Ekko, if there was a case and a wagon.

Would be willing to look at Charlie as per @Duckt.

Luka is also a fine vote, as it proves their indestructible claim or hits a non town and makes them dead.
And then the town PRs can do their thing overnight. Just think thats lower odds of hitting wolf.

Don't have a reason to vote for, or not vote for

Marr
Mr Reloaded
Charlie
All the people not currently voting or participating, but I recommend making one of them the counterwagon to Udell instead of Pot Goblin who is obviously a suboptimal vote at best.

Will not vote for-

Orca,
bittersweet,
Pot Goblin,
Waluigi,
Red Knight the yellow named,
Hayumi,
Duckt,
Ratchet,
The entire category of "almost anyone Naomi votes for especially for the reasons Naomi gives."

Lord Melkor: Duckt > Alexis*
Flower: Lord Melkor > Lord Melkor > Mr. Reloaded > MangoSenpai > Alexis2282AE > EkkoLoJinx > Alexis2282AE > Lord Melkor
EkkoLoJinx: Lord Melkor
Naomi: Polar Bear
bittersweat: Lord Melkor
Alexis2282AE: Duckt > Hayumi
Red Night: Alexis2282AE > Mr. Reloaded > Ratchet > unvote > Alexis*
Michelle: Mr. Reloaded > MangoSenpai > Alexis2282AE > EkkoLoJinx > Alexis2282AE > EkkoLoJinx*
Hayumi: MangoSenpai > unvote > Duckt > MangoSenpai > Alexis2282AE
MangoSenpai: Red Night > unvote > Lord Melkor > The Orca
Duckt: Mr. Reloaded > Unvote*
Paragorn: Yoho
Ratchet: Alexis2282AE
York: Alexis2282AE
Marr: Lord Melkor
The Orca: Polar Bear > Lord Melkor
Mr. Reloaded: Lord Melkor > The Orca
Charlie: The Orca


Lord Melkor - 5
Alexis2282AE - 5
The Orca - 3
Duckt - 1
Mr. Reloaded - 1
Polar Bear - 1
Yoho - 1
Hayumi - 1


So it looks like possibly a 50/50

But this post really really reeks..


Vote Lynch LM

Still though, while yes LM was put in a position that if he wished to live he would have to vote Alexis here regardless.

But it's just the way that he does it, claiming that he can be scum and that in his PMs he knows that he is scum..

This makes no sense to me

Vote Lynch Waluigi

no i havent made a "list" yet. havent been closely following the game myself and hoped for the young ones to have a chance at the spotlight, though admittedly leaving them on their own in a cult game might be rough..

anyway solid entrance. thanks for taking over and stuff. i'll handle the rest if you wanna follow along


from day 1 and what i read of today i feel mostly ok with these players as town

• duckt
• cata (bittersweet)
• reloady
• ratchet
• yoho
• naomi - she makes a good cult target and had a weak start of day 2. recent posts r fine
• jag - trending down today, can be busy/culted. his day 1 was much more transparent
• michelle - trending down today as well. can be busy irl but regardless her presence is noticeably weaker. i kinda feel like if she got culted (or if anyone did) they would atleast make an effort to make their play match. great disparity in play is often not a great determination of cult, unless the culted player is very polarized. i'd look more for forced contributions to mimic old playstyle with less polarized players
• melkor - melkor felt closer to his town self before subbing out and i also feel like nibel talked down the melkor wagon in a slimy way

these ones are a bit skitzo but can be town

• orca
• udell - i dont really remember how he plays as scum but he's making enemies with everyone in a counter intuitive way for that alignment. blud saw my post on naomi (which i made with 0 reference to his) and decided im out to pocket him

these can be wolf

• hayumi - this ones specifically an odd case because the usage on ratchet was meh and hayumi isnt usually a skitzo player as either alignment. indie doesn't make sense either because confirming a lie detect puts a target on his back. what hayumi is is a filthy wifom enjoyer and he sucks at claims/fakes. i would make a case for tossing him if he doesnt self resolve after that claim. i dont agree with all of his pushes today either which is another point against him because his reads have been mostly decent lately as town.
• mango - did he even post day 2? hayumi had mango in wolf reads / poe in day 1 but he hadn't really made any visible effort pushing it. mango on his day 1 play can be anything
• nibel - nibel is skating through the thread and comes in every time to talk down the main wagons but when it comes to his own scum hunting he postpones it in a future tense "i will do this" "i will do that" then dips again. he's effectively avoiding the thread by playing "the good guy". he needs to be pressured to sit here and push an actual wagon with accountability for the price of shooting down the other ones

we can start with nibel

vote lynch nibel

heading off to sleep now, gn

Vote: Paragorn

Goodbye, wolf.

And good night everyone else! Hope you enjoyed watching me do my town thing.

It ain't much, but it's honest work.

oh yeah

Vote Lynch Ratchet


forgot my ritua

l

I will make a VC in the next post

 

[bittersweet]

I'm sorry if it felt like an insult to you, that was not my intention
However it is silly to not have an explanation beyond "I'm not familiar with a mechanic" for wolf reading someone
Like if you don't know a mechanic, perhaps try to familiarise yourself with it if you want to doubt it or else your argument seems in bad faith

Well, considering this is the first game I've played in with the mechanic, I am educating myself.

 

[bittersweet]

Also, good morning, I'll give an updated reads list here soon.

 

[Michelle]

Marr: Waluigi
bittersweet: Lord Melkor > EkkoLoJinx > Pot Goblin > Orca > Michelle > Udell > Udell
The Orca: Udell > Michelle > Udell
Waluigi: EkkoLoJinx (havent moved my vote yet from Melkor)>Udell>Paragorn
Hayumi: EkkoLoJinx > The Orca > Pot Goblin > Udell
Charlie: The Orca > Pot Goblin
EkkoLoJinx: Red Night > Pot Goblin>Red Night
Naomi: Marr > Charlie > unvote > Marr > EkkoLoJinx > Waluigi>Ratchet
Luka: Pot Goblin
Udell: Pot Goblin
Michelle: Pot Goblin > UNVOTE
Red Night: Reloaded
Mr Reloaded: Orca
Mango: Waluigi

​

Pot Goblin- 3 - Charlie, Luka, Udell
Udell- 3 - Bittersweet, Orca, Hayumi,
Waluigi-2 - Marr, Mango
Ekko- 1 - Waluigi
Reloaded- 1 - Red Night
Orca- 1 - Reloaded
Paragorn- 1 - Waluigi
Red Night-1 - Ekko
Rarchet -1 - Naomi
No vote- Michelle,
and everyone else hasnt placed a vote yet.

Hope it's correct

 

[Michelle]

Also @Polar Bear your slot is voting Waluigi, do you intend to keep the vote?

 

[Michelle]

Oops, i made some mistakes, smh

 

[Michelle]

Vote lynch Polar Bear

 

[York]

@York what do you think of waluigi sus you?

Well, he doesn't seem to have provided any reason whatsoever, so I can't say I think much of him at all

 

[Hayumi]

I'm just a bit iffy on his jump from LM to Alexis, completely misreading alexis after claiming to be able to read him correctly.
later

Alexis played nothing like his usual town self and Flower, etc saw the exact same thing so he’s very much to blame. Absolute trash performance from him, and all he leaves as a legacy is an OMGUS smh

 

[Michelle]

Alexis played nothing like his usual town self and Flower, etc saw the exact same thing so he’s very much to blame. Absolute trash performance from him, and all he leaves as a legacy is an OMGUS smh

I understood the reason and I couldn't fight against it because of the way he played (better said didn't play) but I am dissapointed no one considered my take close to Eod.

Why do you scum read Udell?

 

[Hayumi]

I understood the reason and I couldn't fight against it because of the way he played (better said didn't play) but I am dissapointed no one considered my take close to Eod.

Why do you scum read Udell?

He doesn’t have a single post not having to with mechanical talk (census/cultings) for starters.

And then his reaction to 3 pressure votes is a crash out saying how this is a coordinated effort to lynch him and how that’s his last post…? Like what, you can just get lynched then lol.

 

[Michelle]

He doesn’t have a single post not having to with mechanical talk (census/cultings) for starters.

And then his reaction to 3 pressure votes is a crash out saying how this is a coordinated effort to lynch him and how that’s his last post…? Like what, you can just get lynched then lol.

Do you have meta for Udell? I forgot how he plays, meaning we played a while ago

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

🤔🤔

Whatchu cooking? Do you have reads?

 

[Waluigi]

Still though, while yes LM was put in a position that if he wished to live he would have to vote Alexis here regardless.

But it's just the way that he does it, claiming that he can be scum and that in his PMs he knows that he is scum..

This makes no sense to me

Vote Lynch Waluigi

Im laying in bed rereading, and yes, that is indeed baffling and gross of melkor to do

its also a big fat lie, and a realllllly silly one to tell.

Sorry, he told that lie while he was town. Shame.

@MangoSenpai

Please do not extinguish me for that lie he told.

If you do, I will never, ever, ever blame you though.

 

[Pot Goblin]

Marr: Waluigi
bittersweet: Lord Melkor > EkkoLoJinx > Pot Goblin > Orca > Michelle > Udell > Udell
The Orca: Udell > Michelle > Udell
Waluigi: EkkoLoJinx (havent moved my vote yet from Melkor)>Udell>Paragorn
Hayumi: EkkoLoJinx > The Orca > Pot Goblin > Udell
Charlie: The Orca > Pot Goblin
EkkoLoJinx: Red Night > Pot Goblin>Red Night
Naomi: Marr > Charlie > unvote > Marr > EkkoLoJinx > Waluigi>Ratchet
Luka: Pot Goblin
Udell: Pot Goblin
Michelle: Pot Goblin > UNVOTE
Red Night: Reloaded
Mr Reloaded: Orca
Mango: Waluigi

​

Pot Goblin- 3 - Charlie, Luka, Udell
Udell- 3 - Bittersweet, Orca, Hayumi,
Waluigi-2 - Marr, Mango
Ekko- 1 - Waluigi
Reloaded- 1 - Red Night
Orca- 1 - Reloaded
Paragorn- 1 - Waluigi
Red Night-1 - Ekko
Rarchet -1 - Naomi
No vote- Michelle,
and everyone else hasnt placed a vote yet.

Hope it's correct

 

[bittersweet]

Im laying in bed rereading, and yes, that is indeed baffling and gross of melkor to do

its also a big fat lie, and a realllllly silly one to tell.

Sorry, he told that lie while he was town. Shame.

@MangoSenpai

Please do not extinguish me for that lie he told.

If you do, I will never, ever, ever blame you though.

I think you're okay. Right now, Udell seems the better push for today's lynch.

 

[Hayumi]

Do you have meta for Udell? I forgot how he plays, meaning we played a while ago

I don’t think I’ve played with them before.

 

[Random Asshole]

Oh damn fell asleep super early yesterday DX