Garp is fun to play I haven't tried Roger or Raleigh yet but Roger just seems like a reskinned Shanks
They did something interesting imo => Shanks moveset turns out to be a little bit of Roger and little bit of Rayleigh. Which is most likely lore accurate.
They clearly wanted to put Roger’s haki above anyone else. He is constantly exuding this pink aura that he is the only one to have.
The other choice they made who seems lore accurate to me is that Roger is a “powerful” swordman that have every of his attacks imbued with AdvCoC while Rayleigh is a “speed” swordman with some of his attacks imbued in AdvCoC.
Now just give me Young WB, King and KoH Zoro and I’m good.