Idk where this narrative was born tbh.

We have literally seen WB post GV without a scar and, after the battle with Roger, with a new wound:

WB before:


WB after Roger:


Retcon aside, there is no way Garling did it.
When was it ever stated where the scar is though?

And if it was Roger why call him just " Him " we already knew Shanks was in Roger crew.
Post automatically merged:

Mihawk
:steef::steef:
 
Top