[FNZ] Role Madness One Piece: Water 7/Enies Lobby

[Lord Melkor]

Well, I'm Chopper

Are you able to heal?

 

[Lord Melkor]

You don't actually believe this. You would have seen that she was positing I could be fake claiming, I feel like you're asking this question to get an answer you want. You can go back to lean scum.

I was not yet caught fully, but it seems you are the main Flower expert here.

 

[Ratchet]

Like you pushed me day 1 as your main push as scum last game?

1 - Ongoing game, can't discuss it.
2 - What makes that "weak".
3 - Why would you equate that game to this one? Where are the similarities?

Scum.

 

[Ratchet]

I was not yet caught fully, but it seems you are the main Flower expert here.

You don't need to be an expert to see this - she's tied me arbitrarily with every scum candidate she has had.

Ekko - Claimed I attempted to save his as his buddy. Said he and I were tied together, never established how.
Yoho - Claimed I had Yoho duel me to clear me.

Mango, Cal etc were more of the same. So given this, why would you be expecting an honest answer?

 

[Lord Melkor]

1 - Ongoing game, can't discuss it.
2 - What makes that "weak".
3 - Why would you equate that game to this one? Where are the similarities?

Scum.

If I cannot discuss the ongoing games how I am supposed to answer 3? Hypocrtical much?!

You main pushes day 1 were me (town) and Udell (lean town on him). Yes, pretty weak.

I cannot exclude you are lying about your role at this point.

 

[Worst]

If you think Yoho is town, i believe that Rachet's flip gives us info and is less risky in current gamestate. I do not want to have 3 kills going around.

Doesn't Ratchet's flip basically put you into troubles if he's SK and not maf ?

 

[Flower]

Let me just say this, scum having an extra kill on top of a 3x Bleeder is very unlikely. Meaning if it‘s not Ratchet‘s kill, it must have been Worst‘s.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Doesn't Ratchet's flip basically put you into troubles if he's SK and not maf ?

Maybe, but if I need to be resolved to solve the game so be it. We should also get some further info tonight hopefully.

 

[Ratchet]

If I cannot discuss the ongoing games how I am supposed to answer 3? Hypocrtical much?!

You main pushes day 1 were me (town) and Udell (lean town on him). Yes, pretty weak.

I cannot exclude you are lying about your role at this point.

That's not hypocrisy. How about this game - is your argument that the target of said pushes is the sole determinator as to whether a push is weak or not? That seems silly - you would essentially disqualify me from ever scum reading more easily-lynchable slots early on the basis that they don't reach some arbitrary criteria of performance that *you* define. If you want to argue that they're wrong, then sure, but unless you also want to argue that I am never wrong as town, then it doesn't explain your argument that I couldn't be town on that basis.

 

[Red Night]

Are you able to heal?

Yes 3x

 

[Flower]

I‘m tempted to give Ratchet one more night tbh.

 

[Flower]

Vote Ratchet to win.

Somebody else just get off him please so we have a tie.

 

[Worst]

I‘m tempted to give Ratchet one more night tbh.

He's a valuable asset and i'm sure he'll never betray me

 

[Flower]

He's a valuable asset and i'm sure he'll never betray me

Well, he‘s forced to shoot PoE now. We‘re putting his kill on a leash. Also means scum will have to worry and throw blocks/redirects at him which means Town will be more free to use their night actions undisturbed.

 

[Flower]

And it‘s not like he can run away with the game now either. We know he isn’t Town.

 

[Flower]

Yes 3x

Either that‘s Gambit‘s role or this guy‘s just Town.

Chances that they janitored the exact role that‘s confirmed to be Town and in the game are very low tho, so lynching there today is a low probability play.

 

[Flower]

@Worst let‘s lynch the Goblin.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Either that‘s Gambit‘s role or this guy‘s just Town.

Chances that they janitored the exact role that‘s confirmed to be Town and in the game are very low tho, so lynching there today is a low probability play.

Agreed.

Are you sure Ratchet is not fake claiming as scum here?

I would put some pressure on Pot, Zemmi and Jag and force their claims. I do not think Pot and Zemmi gave full claims?

 

[Red Night]

Vote Lynch Pot Goblin

I'll help you pushing this guy

 

[Flower]

Agreed.

Are you sure Ratchet is not fake claiming as scum here?

I would put some pressure on Pot, Zemmi and Jag and force their claims. I do not think Pot and Zemmi gave full claims?

He could be, but they won‘t have another extra kill and he claims to have a Strongman, so he has no excuse why he wouldn‘t be shooting. If his kill doesn’t show we lynch him next day. We can even give him a single target as a Strongman can‘t be stopped anyway.

Tldr if he doesn’t comply we lynch him next day.