[FNZ] Role Madness One Piece Whole Cake Island

[CakeWalker]

If I null read someone bc I’m getting paranoid of them, then I track them to what I can only assume is the scum kill with the info I’m given

My first thought isn’t “oh I must have been redirected”

It’s “this dude is scum” lol

you're also the same player that was demanding a thunderdome battle with Nat. You're not the voice of reason

 

[Destroya]

Neither had Dest btw.

You said I had no reaction to your truth tell? I literally talked about it first post of the day.

 

[Flower]

Yep I clocked that too. Just undecided if I want to go there yet. I don't have a hard logical case to sell on X.

We have time. And I can finally play this game now, too.

 

[Natalija]

Yep I clocked that too. Just undecided if I want to go there yet. I don't have a hard logical case to sell on X.

He didn’t do anything helpful whatsoever, and his reads are hogwash logic.

We absolutely need a claim there

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Muugen was replaced by Lanji.

What!?!?!!?

 

[Ratchet]

Also I think some of what Cakewalker was arguing yesterday was blatantly scummy.

I think I want to lynch there, but I also am feeling X as scum entirely independent of her.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Let the dead lay in piece!

What is your POE now?

Becoming very suspicious of CakeWaker

Still think Tac can be scum but taking Lanji/Nat’s read into account.

Dest I’m becoming wary of for real. And I’m legitimately wary of Ratchet/Pot with the whole heal thing.

Rej, Mono also in POE

 

[Ratchet]

Dest I’m becoming wary of for real. And I’m legitimately wary of Ratchet/Pot with the whole heal thing.

Uh, what?

 

[Destroya]

So I'm all caught up now.

I definitely thought Saka was going to flip wolf. There was nothing townie about that slot and the way he played at EOD was to just give up. Feeling slightly lost after that flip.

I think it's very unlikely Flower is wolf here. However, I want to make it very clear right now I think her using her truth tell is cheating. She's been told by numerous players, numerous times, how shitty that is. I do not want to play with Flower when she does that and losing Muugen because of that makes my game less enjoyable. It is a completely selfish noce because she cannot control her emotions. This needs to be dealt with after the game.

Looking at the Muugen stiff and his claim, is it possible that one of the amp or refill led to him being unable to use his ability last night? If he wasn't role crushed, and he couldn't be blocked, with only one death, where did his kill go?

Considering Cal and Saka were town, I think Tac needs to be discussed more. He survived D2 only to lay low in D3. To be honest, I need to iso his slot and see what's there.

Still don't care for Nat's game. She hasn't been able to provide and reasons for her reads and she seemingly switches them on the fly. That vanilla claim is still pingy.

Tpein, Rej, and Reloaded are all slots that I think have a decent chance of having wolf among them. Tpein I think is just going to flip wolf here. Has given nothing to this game and feels like Pokemon Tpein. Rej had some posts that showed life of solving, but I still feel iffy about his slot. Reloaded would be a bold wolf here, but he's seen enough wolf performances that I wouldn't put it past him to try something like this.

Next tier would be Melkor, Ratchet, Conq, Mono, and Cake. These are slots that I could see going either way, but have as a town lean. Considering I've already been wrong twice this game, I imagine there is going to be a wolf among these names.

Flower, Pot, Muugen, and Prof are my town reads. Flower because of the truth tell. Pot because he healed Ratchet. Muugen because of read and play. Prof because of play.

Mitch and Kagu are confirmed.

Literally second paragraph. If you're going to be over reactive and emotional enough to use your truth tell and want to be read as town, least you could do is read the game.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

you're also the same player that was demanding a thunderdome battle with Nat. You're not the voice of reason

I feel like the above process is what any reasonable person would think with that result

 

[Flower]

You said I had no reaction to your truth tell? I literally talked about it first post of the day.

You were happy about it in Gram's game, at least didn't try slicing my throat over it while you were flaming me here.

What changed? Perhaps your alignment?

 

[Destroya]

Yep I clocked that too. Just undecided if I want to go there yet. I don't have a hard logical case to sell on X.

I went from wolf reading Flower to town reading her because of the truth tell.

 

[Flower]

Also I'm giving Ratchet a mindmeld Town lean. Fight me.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Uh, what?

Idk. I’m scared one or both of you is scum lol. I feel like you Town read Pot stronger than is justified.

And I’m paranoid you’re healed and won’t resolve now lol.

 

[CakeWalker]

we have role blockers, role crushers and redirectors left right and center. mafia is about logic and not just outing results straight away. its also not about trying to cheat/gamebreak to win. So - I guess I need to change my morals

 

[Destroya]

You were happy about it in Gram's game, at least didn't try slicing my throat over it while you were flaming me here.

What changed? Perhaps your alignment?

I was certainly not happy about it in Gram's game. Literally called it cheating there.

 

[Lord Melkor]

logic was - must have been redirected.
outing info - would potentially lead to a Muugen mislynch. Which as someone I hard town read - would make no sense

Why did you choose Muugen as target of your track ability?

 

[MonochromeYoru]

you're also the same player that was demanding a thunderdome battle with Nat. You're not the voice of reason

That doesn't change the fact that what he says makes sense...

 

[Destroya]

I was certainly not happy about it in Gram's game. Literally called it cheating there.

And what have I done here? Yeah I'm pissed you do it because I consider it cheating and you being emotional like this is unbecoming. But then I shifted to trying and working with you, trying to interact about Tac, and you chose to ignore me.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

we have role blockers, role crushers and redirectors left right and center. mafia is about logic and not just outing results straight away. its also not about trying to cheat/gamebreak to win. So - I guess I need to change my morals

No one has claimed redirector as far as I’m aware. And the role blockers and role crushers are completely irrelevant to your result so Idk why bring them up.

And again, jumping to immediately being redirected doesn’t seem intuitive at all. Why did you decide it didn’t make sense exactly for Muugen not to be scum who killed Pero?