Speculations Perfect Example of Real Swordsmen VS Swordsmen..
- Thread starter Rootbeer
- Start date
So you appeal to ignorance before projecting your own ignorance onto others? Hmm, rather humorous.
You were the one to originally bring up historical samurai to begin with in order to somehow reinforce whatever point you were supposedly making about fantasy shonen samurai in this thread and then doubled down on it by bringing up the Shinsengumi. I hardly see how this is supposedly my fault for going off topic.
Thus we circle right back to this post.
Considering how you are now going in circles and flip flopping between stating that historical samurai primary weapons are irrelevant to One Piece while also simultaneously still defending all of the dumb claims about historical samurai that are supposed to be irrelevant anyway (including truly egregious appeals to popular culture) then I am going to be calling quits on this convo. This shit is truly going nowhere. 
You were the one to originally bring up historical samurai to begin with in order to somehow reinforce whatever point you were supposedly making about fantasy shonen samurai in this thread and then doubled down on it by bringing up the Shinsengumi. I hardly see how this is supposedly my fault for going off topic.
Thus we circle right back to this post.
I could but when Maynard showed you an article about Samurai specifically being a noble military rank rather than being anything to do with being swordsmen, you ignored him. So why should I bother?
Besides, why don't you show proof of historical samurai using swords as their primary battlefield weapon to shut all us critics up?
Besides, why don't you show proof of historical samurai using swords as their primary battlefield weapon to shut all us critics up?
Last edited:
So you appeal to ignorance before projecting your own ignorance onto others? Hmm, rather humorous.
You were the own to originally bring up historical samurai to begin with in order to somehow reinforce whatever point you were supposedly making about fantasy shonen samurai in this thread and then doubled down on it by bringing up the Shinsengumi. I hardly see how this is supposedly my fault for going off topic.
Thus we circle right back to this post.
Considering how you are now going in circles and flip flopping between stating that historical samurai primary weapons are irrelevant to One Piece while also simultaneously still defending all of the dumb claims about historical samurai that are supposed to be irrelevant anyway (including truly egregious appeals to popular culture) then I am going to be calling quits on this convo. This shit is truly going nowhere.
You were the own to originally bring up historical samurai to begin with in order to somehow reinforce whatever point you were supposedly making about fantasy shonen samurai in this thread and then doubled down on it by bringing up the Shinsengumi. I hardly see how this is supposedly my fault for going off topic.
Thus we circle right back to this post.
Considering how you are now going in circles and flip flopping between stating that historical samurai primary weapons are irrelevant to One Piece while also simultaneously still defending all of the dumb claims about historical samurai that are supposed to be irrelevant anyway (including truly egregious appeals to popular culture) then I am going to be calling quits on this convo. This shit is truly going nowhere.
So you appeal to ignorance before projecting your own ignorance onto others? Hmm, rather humorous.
You were the one to originally bring up historical samurai to begin with in order to somehow reinforce whatever point you were supposedly making about fantasy shonen samurai in this thread and then doubled down on it by bringing up the Shinsengumi. I hardly see how this is supposedly my fault for going off topic.
Thus we circle right back to this post.
Considering how you are now going in circles and flip flopping between stating that historical samurai primary weapons are irrelevant to One Piece while also simultaneously still defending all of the dumb claims about historical samurai that are supposed to be irrelevant anyway (including truly egregious appeals to popular culture) then I am going to be calling quits on this convo. This shit is truly going nowhere.
You were the one to originally bring up historical samurai to begin with in order to somehow reinforce whatever point you were supposedly making about fantasy shonen samurai in this thread and then doubled down on it by bringing up the Shinsengumi. I hardly see how this is supposedly my fault for going off topic.
Thus we circle right back to this post.
Considering how you are now going in circles and flip flopping between stating that historical samurai primary weapons are irrelevant to One Piece while also simultaneously still defending all of the dumb claims about historical samurai that are supposed to be irrelevant anyway (including truly egregious appeals to popular culture) then I am going to be calling quits on this convo. This shit is truly going nowhere.
What about your ignorance on the fact that i never brought history in the first place to speak about Samurai typically wielding a
Sword?.. It was always in context to One Piece.. It actually came from this guy?..
So will you own up to your own ignorance, because i can recognize mine and that's called taking responsibility for your actions..
I was ignorant of the fact that Samurai in History were not using the Sword primarily at the Battefields..
Why would i bring Historical fact about Samurai when i can make my point through One Piece in the first Place.. That doesn't make sense..
I'm not going in circle, you're simply not addressing my new point.. Which is simple..
Were the Samurai of High Status wielding the Sword primarily or not?..
The only way you want to call quits on this argument is because you want to save face and not own up to anything.. Next time be more prepare when you want to challenge me.. I owned up to my mistakes can you?..
Sword?.. It was always in context to One Piece.. It actually came from this guy?..
So will you own up to your own ignorance, because i can recognize mine and that's called taking responsibility for your actions..
I was ignorant of the fact that Samurai in History were not using the Sword primarily at the Battefields..
Why would i bring Historical fact about Samurai when i can make my point through One Piece in the first Place.. That doesn't make sense..
I'm not going in circle, you're simply not addressing my new point.. Which is simple..
Were the Samurai of High Status wielding the Sword primarily or not?..
The only way you want to call quits on this argument is because you want to save face and not own up to anything.. Next time be more prepare when you want to challenge me.. I owned up to my mistakes can you?..
If you kept this going instead of calling him out about going in circles. He would be the one calling you a deflector
https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/for...s-not-allowed-to-use-acoc.40230/#post-4147527
Saying False does not make this True..
How am i moving the goalpost when i " Acknowledged " my ignorance about most Samurai not wielding a Sword Already?..
My arguments were always with One Piece at the basis..
Oh yeah because you made a comment that had completely nothing to do with the discussion at all.. How ignorant is that tell me..
How am i moving the goalpost when i " Acknowledged " my ignorance about most Samurai not wielding a Sword Already?..
My arguments were always with One Piece at the basis..
Oh yeah because you made a comment that had completely nothing to do with the discussion at all.. How ignorant is that tell me..
But yall don't want to take L's so you run.. I can take L's
Even if the Sword was not the primary means of battle in Edo or whatever period, it does not change that the Sword was core to
the Samurai lifestyle.. Why are Katanas wordly reknowned now and are the most deadly Blades ever created ever?..
I'm trying to make a point but i won't get an answer..
Even if the Sword was not the primary means of battle in Edo or whatever period, it does not change that the Sword was core to
the Samurai lifestyle.. Why are Katanas wordly reknowned now and are the most deadly Blades ever created ever?..
I'm trying to make a point but i won't get an answer..
What about making use of that endless source of knowledge you are holding in your hands and doing your own research instead of begging strangers to waste their time teaching you basic knowledge?
@Rootbeer did Zoro abandon the WSS path here?
