General & Others Rank these One Piece villains from most evil to least evil

Which of these villains is the most evil?

  • Enel

    Votes: 4 6.1%
  • Doflamingo

    Votes: 31 47.0%
  • Crocodile

    Votes: 3 4.5%
  • Kaido

    Votes: 6 9.1%
  • Big Mom

    Votes: 3 4.5%
  • Orochi

    Votes: 14 21.2%
  • Rob Lucci

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Arlong

    Votes: 2 3.0%
  • Wapol

    Votes: 1 1.5%

  • Total voters
    66
#21
I'm not sure what you're getting at the start, because you even say the difference between Big Mom/Kaido in other posts is scale. That's the only difference between Enel and Lucci, and it's far more likely Lucci has murdered more people given his role in the government and his love of murder.
That's an assumption tho, no way of knowing who overall has the higher body count, especially when one murders cuz he feels like it and the other murders when they're on the job. Depends on how many assignments Lucci has received and we simply don't know. Like I said in my previous posts, lucci only murders when he sees he has a reason to. Enel offed his entire home island and other Sky islands cuz "lol suck it nerdz, I'm God".
I think Big Mom valuing cookies over the lives of others, over their belongings, their nations and future pretty much puts her on the same spectrum as people like Crocodile or Enel but neither go out of their way to actively hurt people. For Crocodile it's just business, for Enel it's an ego / power trip. For Big Mom it's about her absolute greed over human lives.
I personally disagree but your point is fair and understandable.
And yeah yeah, no, I said Kaido's statement is a hyperbole but that doesn't matter. In a war he wants to wage, it'll lead to millions suffering. He does not care about them or the ramifications of his goals. It's not like Goku at all.
Goku let Cell heal, spared Majin Buu the first time he fought him, and was willing to put the universe at risk to fight in a tournament of power. I will admit however, perhaps my Goku analogy wasn't completely accurate when compared to a pure destruction loving tyrant like Kaido. My overall point is that Kaido's disregard for the life that is lost in his war is no different than any average pirate. If the average scumbag pirate had Kaido's crew, power, and boredom they would do exactly what he was doing and they wouldn't be any more evil than they already were.
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
#23
Like ZenZu said, it’s objectively Crocodile. No one else really comes close. Most of Doflamingo’s “evil” actions, can be traced back to people wronging or betraying him in the first place. And Doflamingo truly cares for his family and tolerated their failings.

Not Croc. He killed those loyal to him without a second thought, and most of his evil actions he commits against people who never did any wrong to him, and he truly enjoyed seeing them suffer, unlike Doflamingo who at least was extremely remorseful about killing his father and brother.

Croc, 10/10 times.
 

Finalbeta

Ging Freecss stan
#24
1. Doflamingo
2. Enel
3. Crocodile
4. Orochi
5. Linlin
6. Kaido
7. Arlong
8. Wapol
9. Lucci

I'm not picking Lucci any highter because despite his justice is flawed he behaves with a precise pattern and he doesn't kill innocents unlike Akainu and so on.
 
#25
Kaido. He's the kingpin behind all the evil stuff Caeser, Doflamingo and Orochi have got up to. And one of his men tried to commit genocide on the Minks.
I'm not picking Lucci any highter because despite his justice is flawed he behaves with a precise pattern and he doesn't kill innocents unlike Akainu and so on.
He murdered five hundred soldiers who were held hostage as a punishment for being weak

As a teenager

Lucci is a madman
 
#26
its Doflamingo

the way Doflamingo manipulate people around him is terrifying, I disagree with people saying he care about his crew, he has a twisted relationship with them where he only loves them as long as they are his puppets who worship him and willing to sacrifice themselves for him, what law said about him is true, Crocodile in comparison is just a classic mafia boss who only care about success and doesn't care about the conseqiences

DD hurt people both physically and mentally, and was the cause for countless deaths throughout the years by causing many wars in the NW, his end goal is destroying the world which is the most evil goal a human can think of
 

Finalbeta

Ging Freecss stan
#27
Kaido. He's the kingpin behind all the evil stuff Caeser, Doflamingo and Orochi have got up to. And one of his men tried to commit genocide on the Minks.


He murdered five hundred soldiers who were held hostage as a punishment for being weak

As a teenager

Lucci is a madman
Hmm you are probably right. His reason for it was that they had failed, which felt more like Akainu way of thinking.

Not sure if he grew chillier though, but probably not.
 

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
#28
I think Orochi is the worst : takes pleasure to kill and hurt and torture. Plan to destroy his island. Doesn't really care about anybody, even allies. No other goal than destroy. And length : he has hurt Wano for 25 years.

Croco : what he did in alabasta was insane : he was ready to kill everybody for his goals and kinda torture them during years : no rain, conflict between Koza and the king etc. And croco didnt care about anyone. He doesn't really torture for fun etc when you bother him he kills you.

The third is likely Dofla.
 

KiriNigiri

The Road To Harmony
#29
Enel stuck me more as deluded and arrogant rather than evil, though he wasn't a particularly good guy. Doffy's always had this rotten, power hungry nature, but he does hold some respect for his subordinates, Bellamy notwithstanding.

Crocoboy is cold, but this coverpage-



As well as some of his actions during Marineford such as saving Ace and Luffy, hint at a softer side, imo.

Orochi has displayed virtually 0 redeeming qualities. In fact, he has committed all 7 deadly sins for his time in the story.

Envy - Jealousy and insecurity over Oden and even creating a propaganda that he's a Nitoryu practitioner like Oden
Lust - His insatiable one for women
Wrath - Anger and hate towards the people of Wano
Sloth - Skimps out on his duties as Shogun and only parties
Gluttony - Focused all resources and prosperity around the Flower Capital where he lives
Pride - Believes his own hype of Shogun and shoots down any who may speak against it
Greed - Demands more from CP0 without question

Is he the most evil? Unsure as there are still some characters, like IM, who've yet to be fleshed out or properly introduced, but he's definitely been one of the most despicable characters in the whole series.
 
#30
Big Mom leaves nations in ruins and steals all their food and valuables… Just like what any other average pirate would do (except on a smaller scale because average pirates are weaker than Big Mom). She hasn't actually aimed at specifically only eradicating all life on an island like Enel or Doffy, she just commits the average pirate raids and pillaging on a larger scale.
I think Big Mom valuing cookies over the lives of others, over their belongings, their nations and future pretty much puts her on the same spectrum as people like Crocodile or Enel but neither go out of their way to actively hurt people. For Crocodile it's just business, for Enel it's an ego / power trip. For Big Mom it's about her absolute greed over human lives.
I agree mostly with both of you and don't want to add oil to fire, but... Doesn't she take lifespans as tax? As it shortens the life of people, it's easily almost the same as genocide. It's like... Slow genocide.
 
#34
^You won't catch me saying this a lot, but the guy above me is completely correct. Enel is top 3 most evil pricks in the manga easily.
I agree mostly with both of you and don't want to add oil to fire, but... Doesn't she take lifespans as tax? As it shortens the life of people, it's easily almost the same as genocide. It's like... Slow genocide.
You're completely correct, but tbf she did give them a choice to leave. I'm not denying she's insane, after all I have her above sociopaths like Lucci and Kaido. Slow genocide is exactly what Orochi is doing, starving most of his people and whatnot, but I have Big Mom slightly under him because in Big Mom's case you have the choice to leave totland. In Wano you're staying, whether you're dying or nah.
It seems Doffy won over everyone's hearts, absolute leader :pepedoffy:
And yet Caesar Clown is still the number 1 evil prick, even more so than Doffy :goyea:
 
#35
You're completely correct, but tbf she did give them a choice to leave. I'm not denying she's insane, after all I have her above sociopaths like Lucci and Kaido. Slow genocide is exactly what Orochi is doing, starving most of his people and whatnot, but I have Big Mom slightly under him because in Big Mom's case you have the choice to leave totland. In Wano you're staying, whether you're dying or nah.
Aha, then we are on the same page. Because you said she just commits the average pirate raids and pillaging on a larger scale, and I was like... What is average about this ahahaha

And yet Caesar Clown is still the number 1 evil prick, even more so than Doffy :goyea:
Fuffuffuffuffu
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#36
Reminder



Even Zoro couldn't handle how twisted Croc was.

I might place Crocodile above Doflamingo for the simple fact that he would toss any underling like used goods without a second thought. Doflamingo truly cared for his family. Even going as far as letting the strawhats escape because Law held a scrub like Giolla (who is no use to Mingo) hostage. Crocodile doesn't value any life and doesn't seem especially close to anyone really (he showed interest in working with Daz Bonez though that's about it).
Isn't Enel pretty much the same?
 
#37
Crocodile was a ruthless savage. Whenever they seemed to solve an issue he was like but there is more kuhahaha. But i dont think he was necessarily the far end of evil, just that he does everything possible to achieve his goal. Lucci for example used justice as an excuse to kill whenever he feels like it, i think hes more dark inside. Then there is Doffy who id say is pretty high on the list. But id also include Hody
 
#39
You're completely correct, but tbf she did give them a choice to leave. I'm not denying she's insane, after all I have her above sociopaths like Lucci and Kaido. Slow genocide is exactly what Orochi is doing, starving most of his people and whatnot, but I have Big Mom slightly under him because in Big Mom's case you have the choice to leave totland. In Wano you're staying, whether you're dying or nah.
You can't leave Totto Land, Big Mom makes the false promise of allowing you to leave so if you do try to leave you will get executed.
 
#40
Not Croc. He killed those loyal to him without a second thought, and most of his evil actions he commits against people who never did any wrong to him, and he truly enjoyed seeing them suffer, unlike Doflamingo who at least was extremely remorseful about killing his father and brother.

Croc, 10/10 times.
he also had the best evil laugh in the anime

 
Top