General & Others Rate One Piece arcs
- Thread starter Nekochako
- Start date
Won't bother rating every east blue arc individually-
East blue saga- 7.5
Twin capes/whiskey peak-7
Drum Island- 8.5
Alabasta-8
Jaya-9.5
Skypiea-9
Long ring long road-5 (saving grace was Kuzan's entrance)
Water 7- 9.5
Enies Lobby- 9
Thriller Bark- 7.5
Sabaody-10
Amazon Lily- 6.5
Impel Down-8.5
Marineford-10
Post war-8.5
Fishman Island-6
Punk Hazard-7
Dressrosa-6.5
Zou-9
WCI-7
Reverie-10
Wano so far-7.5
East blue saga- 7.5
Twin capes/whiskey peak-7
Drum Island- 8.5
Alabasta-8
Jaya-9.5
Skypiea-9
Long ring long road-5 (saving grace was Kuzan's entrance)
Water 7- 9.5
Enies Lobby- 9
Thriller Bark- 7.5
Sabaody-10
Amazon Lily- 6.5
Impel Down-8.5
Marineford-10
Post war-8.5
Fishman Island-6
Punk Hazard-7
Dressrosa-6.5
Zou-9
WCI-7
Reverie-10
Wano so far-7.5
It was only recently that I heard the DBF was unpopular. No one remembers the popularity of Afro Luffy? I'd say this illustrates the difference between OP being a phenomenon in Japan and being second fiddle to the likes of Bleach and Naruto abroad. People don't seem to care for gags as much in these fandoms.
Romance Dawn: 7/10
Orange Town: 7.5/10
Syrup Village: 5/10
Baratie: 9/10
Arlong Park: 9/10
Loguetown: 7/10
Whiskey Peak: 7/10
Little Garden: 7/10
Drum Island: 8.5/10
Alabasta: 9/10
Jaya/Skypiea: 10/10
Foxy: 6/10
Water Seven/Enies Lobby: 10/10
Thriller Bark: 8/10
Sabaody: 10/10 (best arc in One Piece)
Amazon Lilly: 7/10
Impel Down: 8.5/10
Marineford: 10/10
Fishman Island: 7/10
Punk Hazard: 6/10
Dressrosa: 7.5/10
Zou: 9/10
Whole Cake: 5/10
Orange Town: 7.5/10
Syrup Village: 5/10
Baratie: 9/10
Arlong Park: 9/10
Loguetown: 7/10
Whiskey Peak: 7/10
Little Garden: 7/10
Drum Island: 8.5/10
Alabasta: 9/10
Jaya/Skypiea: 10/10
Foxy: 6/10
Water Seven/Enies Lobby: 10/10
Thriller Bark: 8/10
Sabaody: 10/10 (best arc in One Piece)
Amazon Lilly: 7/10
Impel Down: 8.5/10
Marineford: 10/10
Fishman Island: 7/10
Punk Hazard: 6/10
Dressrosa: 7.5/10
Zou: 9/10
Whole Cake: 5/10
Romance Dawn: 5/10
Orange Town: 5/10
Syrup Village: 3/10 (boring arc)
Baratie: 8/10 (Sanji's introduction was cool)
Arlong Park: 8/10 (Luffy vs arlong was fantastic)
Loguetown: 5/10 (I dont like Buggy)
Whiskey Peak: 6/10
Little Garden: 5/10
Drum Island: 7/10
Alabasta: 6/10 (way too long)
Skypiea: 3/10 (Enel was pretty cool but anything else was garbage).
Foxy: 5/10 (Funny arc)
Water Seven/Enies Lobby: 10/10 (Amazing)
Thriller Bark: 9/10 (Kuma and the hilarious comedy made it a great arc).
Sabaody: 10/10 (Perfection)
Amazon Lilly: 5/10
Impel Down: 8/10
Marineford: 20/10 (Love Whitebeard and admirals).
Fishman Island: 9/10 (Hody was garbage, but I like the world building).
Punk Hazard: 7/10
Dressrosa: 9/10 (Dont know why many of you hate this arc).
Zou: 10/10 (Minks are awesome, Jack was menacing back then).
Whole Cake: 8/10 (Didnt like Wedding cake bs but it is a good arc with interesting new characters like Cracker, Kata, Oven, Peros and Daifuku).
Reverie : 10/10 (Nothing to say about it).
Wano: 5/10 (Hate Udon plot line,hate Orochi's design, Big mom Amnesia and the lack of interesting samurais in the enemy's side).
Orange Town: 5/10
Syrup Village: 3/10 (boring arc)
Baratie: 8/10 (Sanji's introduction was cool)
Arlong Park: 8/10 (Luffy vs arlong was fantastic)
Loguetown: 5/10 (I dont like Buggy)
Whiskey Peak: 6/10
Little Garden: 5/10
Drum Island: 7/10
Alabasta: 6/10 (way too long)
Skypiea: 3/10 (Enel was pretty cool but anything else was garbage).
Foxy: 5/10 (Funny arc)
Water Seven/Enies Lobby: 10/10 (Amazing)
Thriller Bark: 9/10 (Kuma and the hilarious comedy made it a great arc).
Sabaody: 10/10 (Perfection)
Amazon Lilly: 5/10
Impel Down: 8/10
Marineford: 20/10 (Love Whitebeard and admirals).
Fishman Island: 9/10 (Hody was garbage, but I like the world building).
Punk Hazard: 7/10
Dressrosa: 9/10 (Dont know why many of you hate this arc).
Zou: 10/10 (Minks are awesome, Jack was menacing back then).
Whole Cake: 8/10 (Didnt like Wedding cake bs but it is a good arc with interesting new characters like Cracker, Kata, Oven, Peros and Daifuku).
Reverie : 10/10 (Nothing to say about it).
Wano: 5/10 (Hate Udon plot line,hate Orochi's design, Big mom Amnesia and the lack of interesting samurais in the enemy's side).
Romance Dawn: 7/10
Orange Town: 7/10
Syrup Village: 5/10
Baratie: 8/10
Arlong Park: 9/10
Loguetown: 6/10
Whiskey Peak: 5/10
Little Garden: 6/10
Drum Island: 7/10
Alabasta: 10/10
Jaya/Skypiea: 9/10
Foxy: 7/10
Water Seven/Enies Lobby: 10/10
Thriller Bark: 7/10
Sabaody: 9/10
Amazon Lilly: 7/10
Impel Down: 9/10
Marineford: 8/10
Fishman Island: 7/10
Punk Hazard: 5/10
Dressrosa: 8/10
Zou: 9/10
Whole Cake: 8/10
Not bothering to rate Wano until the arc is over. As of now, it feels slightly above average and not event close to 10/10.
Orange Town: 7/10
Syrup Village: 5/10
Baratie: 8/10
Arlong Park: 9/10
Loguetown: 6/10
Whiskey Peak: 5/10
Little Garden: 6/10
Drum Island: 7/10
Alabasta: 10/10
Jaya/Skypiea: 9/10
Foxy: 7/10
Water Seven/Enies Lobby: 10/10
Thriller Bark: 7/10
Sabaody: 9/10
Amazon Lilly: 7/10
Impel Down: 9/10
Marineford: 8/10
Fishman Island: 7/10
Punk Hazard: 5/10
Dressrosa: 8/10
Zou: 9/10
Whole Cake: 8/10
Not bothering to rate Wano until the arc is over. As of now, it feels slightly above average and not event close to 10/10.
