General & Others Rate The One Piece Live Action

[pg13]

 

[shastar-sei]

Overall, I rate it an 8, with episodes 7 and 3 doing the heavy lifting.

 

[MUUGEN]

still not a fan of luffys actor

 

[ZippySpace]

I'd say it's 8/10 television which by the standards of live-action manga/anime adaptations is pretty good.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

Honestly not more than 7. Its not bad at all,and has some great stuff,but also some bad stuff,so 7 is the right rate in my opinion

 

[milluki]

it is only enjoyable when you are not completely there. i watched the first two episodes at night, when i was very tired. it was great fun. then i went to sleep and resumed watching it later, in a more sober state, and it wasn't good anymore. so when your senses are dulled, be it from a lack of sleep or intoxication, it can easily be a 9 or a 10. otherwise a 3 at best.

 

[Djordje]

Shit show with terrible actors chosen for certain characters.

And yeah too small boobs compared to original manga.

 

[Yere93]

A 9. I love how camp and endearing it is.

 

[LolonoisZolo]

Very cringe due to average acting but overall ''respects'' the source material.
6/10
Watched S1 and 2 episodes of S2 only though so scoring may change.

 

[Longleg Larry]

8. I knew full well it wasn't going to outdo any other medium as a whole & glad I didn't go into it with that expectation.

That being said, live action Igaram, Mr. 9 & Mr. 3 did outdo their counterparts

episodes 7 and 3 doing the heavy lifting.

This

 

[ZoroFan23]

8/10 overall.


7/10 for faithfulness in adapting the source material.
9/10 for pacing.
9/10 for Zoro greatness.
8/10 for the actors they chose.
8/10 for the cgi effects and creatures.

 

[NikaInParis]

7 seems fair. It has sone good stuff, some great stuff, some bad stuff and some awful stuff. But the good outweighs the bad imo.
A lot of room for improvement.

 

[D. Plant]

I just watched first episode, honestly just whatever for me.

 

[Zenos7]

Very cringe due to average acting but overall ''respects'' the source material.
6/10
Watched S1 and 2 episodes of S2 only though so scoring may change.

Do you watch it in the original language? i prefer watching it with japanese dub.

Im definitely positively surprised by the live action (though granted i didnt have any expectations beforehand). some changes i dont mind, but others annoy me a little.

Like that crocus introduction scene within laboon was just so hilarious in the source material =/

 

[AverageBuggyEnjoyer]

9/10 by anime live action adaptation standard

5/10 by regular TV standards

 

[kekaro]

Quoting myself:

5-6
The first 2 episodes are dog shit, 3 is great, the other are meh, the stuff with Hirulukk is also great the actor carried.


Only episode 3 is an improvement, imo, an objectively better version of the manga. The Hiruluk stuff is great, but that's also kino in the manga. So you get an adaptation that butchered some manga moments with some good moments, but overall, imo, neither a faithful adaptation nor enough original stuff for the run time.

A lot of improvement if season 3 is also like that, meh, cant imagine watching it, no more value was produced imo, sloppa

9/10 by anime live action adaptation standard

5/10 by regular TV standards

my man