General & Others Remember when people thought Yamato was going to join

Do you want Yamato to join?


  • Total voters
    1
#43
10 crew members is a lot in a series like this where Oda can barely give the characters a meaningful role, so I'd rather she didn't enter.
The last female Straw Hat to officially join the crew was Nico Robin, all the way back in Chapter 114 - which released on November 22, 1999!

That was 23 years ago! The main reason why I want another one to join is so this long record can be stopped. It sounds kinda silly to wish for, but 2 out of the 9 being female isn’t very balanced. One more wouldn’t change that margin by a lot, but it‘d be an improvement.

Oda does this weird gag with the female Straw Hats whenever a robot is shown where they’ll just stare at it with disinterest while the rest get all starry eyed about it. I don’t know why he does this a lot, because it’s not that funny. Is it sexist? Can’t girls like robots? :choppawhat:
 
#50
The last female Straw Hat to officially join the crew was Nico Robin, all the way back in Chapter 114 - which released on November 22, 1999!

That was 23 years ago! The main reason why I want another one to join is so this long record can be stopped. It sounds kinda silly to wish for, but 2 out of the 9 being female isn’t very balanced. One more wouldn’t change that margin by a lot, but it‘d be an improvement.

Oda does this weird gag with the female Straw Hats whenever a robot is shown where they’ll just stare at it with disinterest while the rest get all starry eyed about it. I don’t know why he does this a lot, because it’s not that funny. Is it sexist? Can’t girls like robots? :choppawhat:
Sorry but Oda can't write females well and the best written one is Vivi if that is any consolation.
[automerge]1675920023[/automerge]
femboy representation is needed for the strawhats

no one cares about yamato or carrot
Mink, Lunarian representation first
 
#59
This
Mythical Zoan
advCOC
fought with Kaido in 1 vs 1 for a while
WSC's daughter
a character like this just won't work
it would also torpedo the monster trio dynamics
Do Straw Hats look like underdogs to you in the current arc? The next big opponents will be Blackbeard, the Admirals and maybe the 5 Elders. Ultimately, one way or another, Luffy will get support again in the form of super strong characters like Sabo, Dragon, Shanks or Law, so why not let Yamato join right away? So that's not an argument. Your last point is the only one I agree with. The classic monster trio would no longer exist. However, Luffy has such a huge lead with G5 anyway that it would be more like a trio of Yamato, Zoro and Sanji, comparable to the typical top three Commanders that many antagonists had (Donquixote Elite Officers, Sweet Commanders, All Stars).
 
#60
Sure not everyone needs to be a fighter but there isn't any role for her in the crew - question is what she brings to the table as crew member? And, to me nothing.

Also, I won't expect Alabasta to get nuked from an author who has hard time killing even one side character these days lol
more named characters died in wano than any other arc.
[automerge]1676032393[/automerge]
The last female Straw Hat to officially join the crew was Nico Robin, all the way back in Chapter 114 - which released on November 22, 1999!

That was 23 years ago! The main reason why I want another one to join is so this long record can be stopped. It sounds kinda silly to wish for, but 2 out of the 9 being female isn’t very balanced. One more wouldn’t change that margin by a lot, but it‘d be an improvement.

Oda does this weird gag with the female Straw Hats whenever a robot is shown where they’ll just stare at it with disinterest while the rest get all starry eyed about it. I don’t know why he does this a lot, because it’s not that funny. Is it sexist? Can’t girls like robots? :choppawhat:
It's extremely funny and no they can't
 
Top