Speculations Rocks is going to try to kill Baby Shanks

[ImmaIvanoM]

The big lingering mystery with God valley is “What made Rocks and Garp team up to defeat Rocks?”

The answer is easy, Rocks is going to do something that’s even worse than what Garp thinks of Roger and it’s going to be worse than what Roger thinks the Celestial Dragons are doing. (And as a bonus, what Rocks is going to do is going to be what leads to all the surviving Rocks pirates deciding never to talk about him again, something so bad that Whitebeard and Big mom denounce Rocks forever)

Rocks is going to start killing the children of the Celestial Dragons. God valley is a vacation for the celestial dragons, they bring their kids to watch them do genocide. Rocks is going to go on a Celestial Dragons killing spree that includes the children of the Celestial dragons. (This is going to include Shanks and Shamrock)

The reason for why Rocks goes on this murder spree doesn’t matter. By this I mean it doesn’t matter to Oda. Roger and Garp are the good guys so Oda is not going to present Rocks’ reasons for rampaging as good enough no matter what. (And as a bonus, child murder is probably the one thing that would make both Whitebeard and Big mom denounce Rocks given they’ve gone along with every other evil thing Rocks has done, these two specifically have affection for children)

Imagine whatever horrible thing is going to happen to lead to Rocks’ actions, Oda is going to have Roger and Garp hammer home one message, THE KIDS ARE INNOCENT, NO MATTER WHAT

And yes I know the celestial dragons are also going around killing slave children, they’ll all be disposed of too (including Garling) before Garp and Roger reach Rocks or Rocks will be unlucky and he’ll just be the one Roger and Garp find before they find Garling also killing kids for fun


(If you think this is too simplistic a reason for Garp and Roger then remember that this entire thing started because a woman was kidnapped and a 6 year old slave somehow managed to leak all this info, Oda is not above making the biggest event in the story so simple, Oda loves kids, he made Luffy’s birthday Japan’s Children’s day)

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

The Celestial Dragons enslave and murder children all the time

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

The Celestial Dragons enslave and murder children all the time

Indeed, and when rocks starts murdering celestial dragon children too, Oda will have Roger and Garp stop him since celestial dragons doing it doesn’t make rocks doing it okay

 

[Bad English]

Kill them young 😂

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Indeed, and when rocks starts murdering celestial dragon children too, Oda will have Roger and Garp stop him since celestial dragons doing it doesn’t make rocks doing it okay

Rocks brought a nation to ruins how many children do you think suffered for it?

Suddenly when the future slavers and murders are in danger Roger and Garp give a damn?

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Rocks brought a nation to ruins how many children do you think suffered for it?

Suddenly when the future slavers and murders are in danger Roger and Garp give a damn?

Oda was intentionally vague with rocks’ misdeeds. Who knows what “brought to ruin” means.

Future slavers or not, Oda’s message is going to be very clear and he’ll sacrifice rocks to do it. Remember that Shanks is one of those celestial dragon children and That’s Oda’s self-insert golden boy

 

[Jinjoo]

So garp and roger join hands together to stop rocks from killing children as revenge but whistle away when the celestial dragons kill enslaved babies and slave children ? Lol

Imu will be present in God valley too and rocks and imu will definitely have their final confrontation so I don't think he'll die by garp and rogers hands.

Whitebeard has seen rocks attack loki a kid twice. And he still sticks with rocks for over a decade. Big mom tried to kill otama a kid because she wanted to go with nami and usopp.

None of the rocks pirates even liked rocks from the get go. They don't care if he lived or died. So their dislike didn't really start from God valley anyway.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Imagine whatever horrible thing is going to happen to lead to Rocks’ actions, Oda is going to have Roger and Garp hammer home one message, THE KIDS ARE INNOCENT, NO MATTER WHAT

Which just completely evaporates when you consider the fact that Garp, stood by and did literally nothing when 100s of babies many of them still in wombs, were slaughtered as part of the marines' hunt for Roger's baby.

If fucking garp and roger take Rocks targeting kid shank as the excuse to jump Rocks, they have no honor or worth anymore.

They just use lives of babies as excuse when it fits their agendas. And entirely ignore kids dying when its convenient for them.

 

[Punishhh]

So garp and roger join hands together to stop rocks from killing children as revenge but whistle away when the celestial dragons kill enslaved babies and slave children ? Lol

Well, you see Rocks is a terrorist while the WG is a government.
Garp is one of the worst characters in the story morally speaking, he deserves to be tortured by the BB pirates.

 

[MonsterKaido]

Tl ; dr?

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Tl ; dr?

The title, Roger and Garp fight Rocks because Rocks tries to kill Baby Shanks

 

[TheD.]

Didn’t sengoku and Garp slaughter hundreds of baby’s

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Which just completely evaporates when you consider the fact that Garp, stood by and did literally nothing when 100s of babies many of them still in wombs, were slaughtered as part of the marines' hunt for Roger's baby.

If fucking garp and roger take Rocks targeting kid shank as the excuse to jump Rocks, they have no honor or worth anymore.

They just use lives of babies as excuse when it fits their agendas. And entirely ignore kids dying when it’s convenient for them.

That’s true. But see Rocks is gonna be doing the child murders right in front of Roger and Garp so Joe they have to get involved

Didn’t sengoku and Garp slaughter hundreds of baby’s

Garp didn’t. Sengoku did

 

[Monkey D Theories]

I would genuinely prefer it if Oda simply had the balls to show Garp and Roger as pawns of the CDs.

it would make for a much better story if Roger and Garp made mistakes in their youth than for Oda to turn Rocks into a villain just to show that killing children is bad or whatever.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

I would genuinely prefer it if Oda simply had the balls to show Garp and Roger as pawns of the CDs.

it would make for a much better story if Roger and Garp made mistakes in their youth than for Oda to turn Rocks into a villain just to show that killing children is bad or whatever.

sadly oda wont

 

[Monkey D Theories]

One thing I could also see working is if Rocks targeted Dragon and Garp was forced to defend him.

Say Teach’s mom attacked Dragon, assuming the marine was an enemy, and Dragon accidentally shot/killed her in self defense.

Rocks then went after Dragon. Garp stepped in to protect him. Roger stepped in because Garp was Roger’s friend.

 

[centurion]

Kill them young 😂

 

[soupongo]

I would genuinely prefer it if Oda simply had the balls to show Garp and Roger as pawns of the CDs.

it would make for a much better story if Roger and Garp made mistakes in their youth than for Oda to turn Rocks into a villain just to show that killing children is bad or whatever.

>Turn Rocks into a villain

I think the whole slaughtering towns and ruining countries might have done that...

 

[centurion]

Didn’t sengoku and Garp slaughter hundreds of baby’s

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

What I find funny about this is that despite how people use it to slander Garp it's because of Garp that they never found Ace and Ace was able to be raised in peace with nobody pressing him for being Roger's son.