Theory Roger is still alive

[Kuni samurai]

My theory is that the person hiriluk is talking about is Roger. When we saw Roger talking to Whitebeard we see him next to mountains and cherry blossom trees.
Roger probably faked his death in order to create a new Era so people like Luffy are born. Roger is maybe waiting for Luffy in LaughTale. When Roger said he wont die and when Whitebeard said that Blackbeard is not the person Roger is waiting, what if this was supposed to be meant literally.

 

[Extravlad]

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Interesting theory, but man, I would be SO pissed off if it came true...can’t think of a worse way for Oda’s revival fetish to manifest than yanking the former Pirate King back from oblivion before the next one is officially crowned.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

I mean people were thought that Oden was coming back......

Not really a fan of Roger coming back considering he doesn't have the will of P like Pell, Pagaya, Pound and maybe Pedro.

 

[Flappy]

Roger came from eastblue, so not west as mentioned bij Hililuk. It would totally suck if he is still alive. Losing his son and all

 

[Herrera95]

Roger is more dead than Ace.

 

[Finalbeta]

Around as dead as Ace

 

[Gutts]

I think you should read again Drum arc.

When does a person die?

Hiluluk's answer explains the meaning of Roger's things not to die.

İnhereted Will...

 

[Herrera95]

I think you should read again Drum arc.

When does a person die?

Hiluluk's answer explains the meaning of Roger's things not to die.

İnhereted Will...

He said that, and then he died. So...
Pound is a better man to talk about death. Pell too. And I bet Pedro is alive.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

He said that, and then he died. So...
Pound is a better man to talk about death. Pell too. And I bet Pedro is alive.

The will of P.

And don't forget about Pagaya lol.