General & Others Roger, Rocks and Garp are brothers

[S.W317]

In the same sense that Luffy, Ace and Sabo were but something went wrong between them so they started hating each other as their world views were different and became rivals.

In God Valley, the three fought each other but during the fight Imu emerged and the three fought him but lost and Rocks ended up killed this way.

 

[NikaInParis]

Would Garp remain serving Imu for decades afterwards if he killed his sake brother in front of his eyes?
I know most OP characters are spineless but this is too much

 

[S.W317]

Would Garp remain serving Imu for decades afterwards if he killed his sake brother in front of his eyes?
I know most OP characters are spineless but this is too much

What if he didn’t know who this was, what if they have just literally fought a giant demon

 

[Yoho]

🤔 some parts I agree with some parts I don't

Could they have been sworn brothers at one point? Yes especially Garp and Roger

🤔but I don't think they ever hated each other, Roger trusted Garp with Ace he wouldn't do that with someone he hated

🤔And Rocks doesnt come off as a bad guy tbh, he even tried to fight kaido for threatening Harald who he considers a good friend

They all just had different ideas and ideals and those ideals unfortunately clashed doesn't mean they hated each other tho

Just the results of circumstances

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Garp, Sengoku, and Kong being “brothers” makes more sense

 

[S.W317]

Garp, Sengoku, and Kong being “brothers” makes more sense

I think they’re more like really close friends that met each other as marine recruits but I don’t think they knew each other from before this period.

The only reason why I think they’re sworn brothers is because of their intense rivalry, Rocks invited every top tier of that era into his crew except for Roger why is that?

In Kuma’s flashback, Rocks told Roger to get out of his way and was casually talking to him indicating they were long term rivals even before Rocks started his pirating career.

They both have similar swordsmanship styles, it gives me the vibes they were under the tutelage of the same master.

 

[JDragon20]

Garp is a complete and utter bitch/government doggy if he's blood brothers with Rocks and Roger.

 

[Grotesque]

 

[Monkey D Theories]

I think they’re more like really close friends that met each other as marine recruits but I don’t think they knew each other from before this period.

I feel like they’ve probably been marines nearly their entire life. Joining young like Koby did.

 

[S.W317]

I feel like they’ve probably been marines nearly their entire life. Joining young like Koby did.

They join at age 22, we know this already