Should we keep D1 start in the game?


  • Total voters
    12
Status
Not open for further replies.

Fujishiro

Love is a painful illusion
only?
like 4 mafia and 2 hostiles?

i guess that might be true if the hostiles have their own kills too
definitely an arsonist then, and maybe PB
Pestilence has to be in this game, it wasnt in the last. If Zem wants to tests the role then she has to have put something new imo.

And so we gotta keep in mind Lo claims the most. And also PBs will try to get rid of confirmed townies through thread play since they cant kill, because once they become Pesilence the more confirmed people the more likely for them to be caught through process of elimination.
 
My apprentice @Wris claims tracker who tracked you, she got the result that she visited her and she claims to have been poisoned.
I'm the sheriff and I investigated her last night. Her play on day 1 didn't make sense to me. She suspected you for being exe and she votes Flower anyways meaning in her point of view Flower should have been town for her. I also saw it weird when she voted Xlaw because from what I remember he was getting scum read asking for a claim and same thing can be said about odd who was also asking for a claim and Wris said along the lines of, "Why are we voting odd? He barely said anything except asking for claims." Wris admitted her vote on Xlaw was omgus.
 

AL sama

Red Haired
I'm the sheriff and I investigated her last night. Her play on day 1 didn't make sense to me. She suspected you for being exe and she votes Flower anyways meaning in her point of view Flower should have been town for her. I also saw it weird when she voted Xlaw because from what I remember he was getting scum read asking for a claim and same thing can be said about odd who was also asking for a claim and Wris said along the lines of, "Why are we voting odd? He barely said anything except asking for claims." Wris admitted her vote on Xlaw was omgus.
perfect march lol

5.) Sheriff, Executioner, Werewolf, or Poisoner
 
S

Sallucion

Sallucion can't read me confirmed! I'm not even in this list.

You could be necro.
I may have missed your claim if you say you're confirmed.
If you say this only because you whispered someone with info, then no. You 're not confirmed to me in that case. Like I said, I will have to reread some posts about the people I haven't mentioned in my post, so I'm not saying you're not town, nor scum.
 

EkkoLoJinx

No dude... that's a bike...!!
I don't know. I trust you because you already hinted your role in D1 and it's something you do. What I dislike is the way you casually claimed your role when no one asked for it. You knew it was a coven game and with a coven game there is a chance to have an Coven Leader in the game. Depening on the 3rd it's smart to use you and lead you to coven themself, but I doubt they will do it. With a poisoner alive it's more likely to lead you somewhere else to give poisoner free space.

Lucky for you Poisoner is already caught.



What? Odd, the vig, getting lynched may have been a punch to the face for us.
Reading this Lynch was the worst lynch I've ever read and I still don't understand how this happened. You make it sound like it was no big deal.
A no lynch is also an option, it doesn't change anything from the normal ToS format to go the first night without a lynch. You dislike this D1 format, because there is no info at all, yet you vote Guilty on a Vig claim, which is the best info you got out of D1.

You could have caught some scum if you just trusted his claim. And If you know the mechanics, you know what I mean.



I'm tired. :catsweat:

------

Alright the people I trust so far:
And I will tell you now that I only 100% trust people with claim that make sense etc.

100% Town:
AL (Obvious)
Wris. (Obvious)

Most likely town:
Ratchet - I have my eyes on you :shocking:, but you look very town to me. I liked your D1 play, very town friendly.
Van - I wont put you on my 100% town list, because you havent been confirmed, but I do trust you on your claim
Flower - I trust AL and he trusts you. You know it's not smart to say that you will claim next DP, or the DP after next DP. Should just have kept it to yourself ;-;.

I have everyone else, except from scum read, Neutral for now. I must say I have to reread some stuff, but it's late and I don't want to analyze for hours right now.

Scum read:
XLaw - I already mentioned above here how easy he was on the vig lynch.
Altough people already mentioned it to you and, I didnt read your post before I replied to Ekko, there is no need to answer a question which is meant for me to answer. This way you only make me look like scum. You have played ToS on OJ before, so you know this was a bad post. I haven't played ToS for almost 2 years and mechanics and things like this is not something you forget.

I also dislike Krogo had to claim so early on. I'm not saying he had to because you asked him to, but you played a big part in it. I have seen the talk between Krogo and the jailer, and I know for sure the Jailer is no noobie in ToS. If the Jailer doesn't trust me after this DP he could have jailed me once again, this without me having to claim Trapper.
Besides this I couldn't get much from your post. It looks like you're pointing from one person to another without good reasoning and thinking.

I wouldn't mind a claim from you to be honest, but let's see what the others say.

-------

Now we know we are dealing with Coven, but we don't know which 3rd party we have to deal with.

For Coven:
Coven Leader: No witched claim yet, or I missed it? The only possibility are:
The Coven Leader abstained for the night. Dunno why.
I am the Coven Leader and I got jailed, which is not possible because I know my role. Also, CL and Trapper have different Invest results, so go ahead if you want to check me.
Someone is not telling us he/she got Witched. The only person not posting so far is @T-Pein™ . So last chance to see if we have a Coven Leader. If Zem really wants to troll us she puts a witch in the game instead of Coven Leader ;-;

Poisoner: Confirmed. I doubt there is a mafia group in this 18-player game. And thus there is no Hypno who could fake sent the message.

Medusa: With a Trapper and Tracker in the game I doubt there is a Medusa. Especially after 0 Medusa deads and CL. (I know CL is not confirmed), but no CL and no Medusa is a weird setup in my eyes (Still possible ofcourse)

Hex Master, Necromancer, Potion Master: All of them are still an option.

For Thirds:
If the setup is how I think it is, we have no SK and Vampires.
I'm not sure which one to expect, but I wouldn't be surprised with a PB in the game.

-----
Im heading to bed now.
interesting what about juliet? drago?
 

EkkoLoJinx

No dude... that's a bike...!!
I'm the sheriff and I investigated her last night. Her play on day 1 didn't make sense to me. She suspected you for being exe and she votes Flower anyways meaning in her point of view Flower should have been town for her. I also saw it weird when she voted Xlaw because from what I remember he was getting scum read asking for a claim and same thing can be said about odd who was also asking for a claim and Wris said along the lines of, "Why are we voting odd? He barely said anything except asking for claims." Wris admitted her vote on Xlaw was omgus.
aww yea so the outed consiligere is really helping town, how cute of him
the consigliere slipped rolecopping u as sheriff, so u r confirmed town which is nice
































:sadgrin:
 
already up to a blimey start eh
I'm the sheriff and I investigated her last night. Her play on day 1 didn't make sense to me. She suspected you for being exe and she votes Flower anyways meaning in her point of view Flower should have been town for her. I also saw it weird when she voted Xlaw because from what I remember he was getting scum read asking for a claim and same thing can be said about odd who was also asking for a claim and Wris said along the lines of, "Why are we voting odd? He barely said anything except asking for claims." Wris admitted her vote on Xlaw was omgus.
so what results did you get on tris
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top