[FNZ] Light game Scrimmage Mafia (Unofficial)

Is Drago the Best Host?

  • Total voters
    16
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

NeutralWatcher

#65
#65
RedGloverKing said:
The game is unique so far, I understand the mechanics and I'll ask if I have questions. I can't get reads, it's only been a day/4 pages.
Click to expand...
What's your thought about these 2 roles? Watcher with macho at the end with Watcher role with no macho at the end?
1. Watcher - Night 1 Only - Macho
2. Watcher - Night 2 Only

I also don't understand what does 1x Ninja means here
3. Alignment Cop - Night 2 Only - 1x Ninja
4. Alignment Cop - Night 3 Only - 1x Ninja

same here. 1x Strongman at the end here.
15. Role Cop - Nights 1, 2, & 3 - 1x Strongman
18. Voyeur - Nights 1, 2, 3, & 4 - 1x Strongman
 
Finalbeta

Finalbeta

Zoro Worshipper
‎
#66
#66
Good morning.

I firmly believe a massive claiming isn't a bad idea here, to make sure we can spot several liars at once.

This isn't a bastard game and so the roles the host introduced are supposedly all rightful.
 
Flower

Flower

‎
#67
#67
Finalbeta said:
Good morning.

I firmly believe a massive claiming isn't a bad idea here, to make sure we can spot several liars at once.

This isn't a bastard game and so the roles the host introduced are supposedly all rightful.
Click to expand...
It's a terrible idea because roles are randomized, so not AI in any way.
 
Finalbeta

Finalbeta

Zoro Worshipper
‎
#68
#68
Flower said:
It's a terrible idea because roles are randomized, so not AI in any way.
Click to expand...
:choppawhat:

Whether they are randomized or not, one can discern who is Mafia or not by counting eventual duplicates

I don't follow your logic here?

This is no bastard game so the host isn't lying on the set up
 
Flower

Flower

‎
#69
#69
Finalbeta said:
:choppawhat:

Whether they are randomized or not, one can discern who is Mafia or not by counting eventual duplicates

I don't follow your logic here?

This is no bastard game so the host isn't lying on the set up
Click to expand...
Read the setup...
Post automatically merged:

Scum can have whatever role. Roles don't say anything about alignments.
 
Marimo_420

Marimo_420

The Honoured One
‎
#70
#70
Sup. This setup feels better than previous rounds and at least there's claiming around. Let's all have some fun guys and kill all mafia members.

No concrete reads atm. Nw vs Fuji just seems like town vs town to be me at this current moment.



This will also be my first and last post for a bit. I'm not touching 1500 posts.
 
Finalbeta

Finalbeta

Zoro Worshipper
‎
#71
#71
Flower said:
Read the setup...
Post automatically merged:

Scum can have whatever role. Roles don't say anything about alignments.
Click to expand...
I see, so claiming is perfectly useless 🤔

Not sure why Drago didn't restrict it then

After all everyone can claim without being afraid to be judged as Mafia
 
N

NeutralWatcher

#72
#72
Looks like only Watcher role (number 1) has macho passive. (Can't be protected)

This role might be town (can be killed by faction kill) or mafia (can be killed by vigilante) and it can be used on N1 so someone might have Watcher role here.
 
Flower

Flower

‎
#73
#73
Finalbeta said:
I see, so claiming is perfectly useless 🤔

Not sure why Drago didn't restrict it then

After all everyone can claim without being afraid to be judged as Mafia
Click to expand...
Because this is a read based game, not a claim heavy game.
Post automatically merged:

Also, guys, please stop wasting time with setup stuff. Literally doesn't matter because it's RNG.
Post automatically merged:

NeutralWatcher said:
What's your thought about these 2 roles? Watcher with macho at the end with Watcher role with no macho at the end?
1. Watcher - Night 1 Only - Macho
2. Watcher - Night 2 Only

I also don't understand what does 1x Ninja means here
3. Alignment Cop - Night 2 Only - 1x Ninja
4. Alignment Cop - Night 3 Only - 1x Ninja

same here. 1x Strongman at the end here.
15. Role Cop - Nights 1, 2, & 3 - 1x Strongman
18. Voyeur - Nights 1, 2, 3, & 4 - 1x Strongman
Click to expand...
Strongman, Macho and Ninja are passives. Not that relevant for Townies, though.

Anyway, back to class.
Post automatically merged:

Why so quiet :pepecafe:?
 
Last edited:
Finalbeta

Finalbeta

Zoro Worshipper
‎
#76
#76
Too much inactivity around, figuring someone's alignment is too haphazard right now :/

However my current focus is on wondering whether or not the way TAC has approached this game is legitimate from a meta standpoint
 
K

krogothwolf

‎
#79
#79
Finalbeta said:
:choppawhat:

Whether they are randomized or not, one can discern who is Mafia or not by counting eventual duplicates

I don't follow your logic here?

This is no bastard game so the host isn't lying on the set up
Click to expand...
According to the setup there shouldn't be any duplicates, all we'd be doing with a massive claim is give mafia night targets so they can figure out the roles they want to eliminate first, this would give town a huge disadvantaged due to how the roles are setup.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top