Speculations Shanks probably killed Roger

[JoNdule]

Shanks is a good guy. He didn't kill his mentor lol, he's such a saint his only "allies" are weaklings who would have died years ago

Everytime I think of this I cringe
Oda really can't write Shanks as a great character
He has to force narratives on him : allies are so weak, they rely on Shanks the perfect good leader

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Everytime I think of this I cringe
Oda really can't write Shanks as a great character
He has to force narratives on him : allies are so weak, they rely on Shanks the perfect good leader

that part was so bad
i was hoping we'd see hints of an "evil Shanks" against Kidd.

i really did like the theory of him being the underworld boss..

 

[Kumathegoat]

yes.

shanks poisoned Roger.

Roger discovered and told him here.

 

[Cruxroux]

yes.

shanks poisoned Roger.

Roger discovered and told him here.

Red Taro

Imagine your rival is called World strongest and you're called red taro.

I'm officially calling shanks fans as Retardo from now onwards.

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

Saint Shanks is a Holy Knight

Poisoning Roger would be something within the realm of his cowardice to pull off.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Saint Shanks is a Holy Knight

Poisoning Roger would be something within the realm of his cowardice to pull off.

Pranks is the one who talked to the gorosei.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

He probably did, but not because he’s evil

imo Garling manipulated him into doing it
[automerge]1725912053[/automerge]

yes.

shanks poisoned Roger.

Roger discovered and told him here.

Told him rat hair would never be pirate king