Chapter Discussion Since SH's didnt know shit about G5

#26
I actually talked about this particularly with @Panacea a while ago. Strawhat bonds and everyone's Loyalty to Luffy requires a huge amount of suspension of disbelief that falls apart easily the moment you think about it
it would be fine if we knew a bit of time had passed and these people actually talked to one another off screen.

As far as we know that isn't the case. There's no official timeline for the grandline events, only a couple of months have passed post ts and they don't talk to one another offscreen
 
#27
it would be fine if we knew a bit of time had passed and these people actually talked to one another off screen.

As far as we know that isn't the case. There's no official timeline for the grandline events, only a couple of months have passed post ts and they don't talk to one another offscreen
They basically don't even have small talks, just hang around in their own comfort zone on the ship, and only been with each other for a few months both Pre and Post Timeskip combined yet they would all die for each other and abandon their goals for Luffy
 

CoC: Color of Clowns

warmth of the sun and the cool of the shade
#29
The crew seems ridiculously hyper respectful of each other's privacy.

You'd expect them to talk about this stuff a little, but, instead, we get gags. It's weird, because it does make the crew feel somewhat disconnected from each other.
 
#31
Do they know zoro has fucking CoC?
Or do they know sanji genes awakend and there is always possibility of him losing his mind lol
Why they dont talk to eachother? Tf they do on ship, i hate this.
I doubt they know about each other’s new power ups. They’ll comment on it when and if they see it in action. Maybe Zoro did ask Luffy about CoC offscreen but I doubt it
 
#32
Do they know zoro has fucking CoC?
Or do they know sanji genes awakend and there is always possibility of him losing his mind lol
Why they dont talk to eachother? Tf they do on ship, i hate this.
I mean none of them were surprised when they saw Gear 5. They obviously knew about it. It’s just that they didn’t know what the fuck it was since Luffy didn’t know either

Honestly it comes off like people are intentionally misreading that line
 
#33
I mean not knowing ashura is okay since this something somewhat weird and zoro never shows or talks about, but rest of them.... bruh they should know these kinda thing.
it would be weirder for zoro to go up to any of them to tell them he has coc
things like missing an eye tho should be brought up .powerups tho should be seen in action.
 
#35
They dont.
Only Brook knows about Robin's Demonio.
Only Zoro knows about Sanji possibly losing his mind since he called him to tell him. Maybe Chopper knows about the Exoskeleton but no one knows about Ifrit.
Nobody knows Zoro has CoC now.

No different from how Chopper & Brook were surprised at Sabaody to see Zoro make 6 arms/3 heads as he used Ashura.
luffy prob knows zoro has coc after kaido called out zoro's coc after being scarred
 
#36
Do they know zoro has fucking CoC?
Or do they know sanji genes awakend and there is always possibility of him losing his mind lol
Why they dont talk to eachother? Tf they do on ship, i hate this.
I swear the shit makes no sense. I understand oda sees this as a gag manga most times but holy shit why dont we compare notes? What kind of team work can there be if they have no clue what one another can do?

They dont strategize, they dont teach each other, they dont do shit but goof off.
 
#37
They seem to know less and less of each other as time goes by.
Odd cuz the opposite should happen ... Oda do be lacking when it comes to human interaction.
 
#39
It seems like the Straw Hats don’t talk to each other about anything unless Oda shows that they’re talking, which is annoying. Why wouldn’t Luffy talk about his new form or Sanji his new abilities? :choppawhat:

Reminder that Robin is still keeping Poseidon a secret from Luffy, for whatever reason.
 
Top