Questions & Mysteries Size of ....

Which is bigger

  • Egghead

    Votes: 15 62.5%
  • Onighishima

    Votes: 9 37.5%

  • Total voters
    24
#22
Sunny was confirmed to be around sixty meters tall in a Vivre Card iirc

I agree that the size is inconsistent, but it always is when it comes to One Piece, for me though, that page is where Oda specifically details it's scale so it's the most reliable example, of course some will agree or disagree with that because it always depends on what side of the agenda they fall on.
We don't need an agenda to agree both that this pic is shitty scaled and that Oda in general is a very inconsistent writer, especially regarding graphic indicators.
:pepelit:
 
#23
We don't need an agenda to agree both that this pic is shitty scaled and that Oda in general is a very inconsistent writer, especially regarding graphic indicators.
:pepelit:
I didn't agree that the image is "shitty scaled" at all, but Oda definitely doesn't give a fuck about being consistent with sizes.
 

ConquistadoR

The Rogue Prince
#27
You can scale Onigashima a bit differently instead of the Sunny scaling.

A Number (roughly the size of Oars) looks comparable to this Mountain/Rock/Door on the Roof.




Onigashima is surrounded by even larger mountains than the tiny ones on top of the skull.




It's a pretty large Island, where failed Ancient Giants like the Numbers can roam around freely.
 
#29
I mean , It was even called Little Island.
Bro, Marco is clearly comparing Onigashima to the land mass of Wano as a whole... hence why he says "separate little island".

But even if you want to ignore that, I have to ask, which island is Marco calling it small in relation to? One Piece islands range in size from Alabasta, practically a continent, to Marineford, practically mountain sized, is it little compared to Alabasta or is it little compared to Marineford?
 

ConquistadoR

The Rogue Prince
#30
Personally, I dont think we have an actual answer or scaling on how large Egghead is compared to Onigashima.

But i'm sure that Onigashima is definitely much, much larger than the Labophase, though likely smaller than the whole of Egghead.
 
#31
Bro, Marco is clearly comparing Onigashima to the land mass of Wano as a whole... hence why he says "separate little island".

But even if you want to ignore that, I have to ask, which island is Marco calling it small in relation to? One Piece islands range in size from Alabasta, practically a continent, to Marineford, practically mountain sized, is it little compared to Alabasta or is it little compared to Marineford?
Well, If It Is an island of Wano, It Is by definition smaller than Wano itself. If not, that (Onigashima) would have been the landmass. So, Marco could have just said "that island" .

But to be honest, what makes the deal for me Is this (and some other pics similar to this one):



We saw that Onigahsima was not even big as the flower Capital, that as big as It might be surely puts Onigahsima in the small Island spectrum.
 
#32
Well, If It Is an island of Wano, It Is by definition smaller than Wano itself. If not, that (Onigashima) would have been the landmass. So, Marco could have just said "that island" .

But to be honest, what makes the deal for me Is this (and some other pics similar to this one):



We saw that Onigahsima was not even big as the flower Capital, that as big as It might be surely puts Onigahsima in the small Island spectrum.
So some tiny panel with no detail in it is more important than a huge double page spread where Oda explicitly has characters comment on it's scale

Alright bro, you do you.
 
#33
So some tiny panel with no detail in it is more important than a huge double page spread where Oda explicitly has characters comment on it's scale

Alright bro, you do you.
As I said, we saw multiple panels with Onigashima near the flower Capital, this one Is just clearer. In all of them you can see Onigashima Is flower Capital size at best.

That + Marco explicit statement makes the deal for me. But that Is for me.
 
#34
That ain't perspective you clown, the Sunny is closer to the point of view than the skull and objects are:milaugh:

This is an example of perspective, it makes Luffy look like twenty feet tall because he's standing closest to the point of view with other character behind him
Your retarded ass is scaling a 56m tall ship to a 2m fence 😂😂😂
 
#36
We were having a serious debate, why start trolling:seriously:
:kobeha:
That’s what you’re doing with that dumbass pic tho, scaling a 56m ship to a 2m fence
I posted like 10 pics showing how that pavilion is nothing but a small port for boats and ships, and how Oda simply drew the Sunny that way to make room for Onigashima on the panel
:hapnoel:
 
#38
First, Oda is a mess with sizes. Characters go from 4m to 30m from one pannel to the next (see Kuma or dragon Kaido), so comparing not characters but island sizes is stupid. Nonetheless, I think EH is way smaller than Onigashima. Onigashima skull was big enough to have thousands of warriors of all sizes AND giants INSIDE. Add to that the mountains surrounding it.
On the other hand EH had huge palm trees but you can clearly count them from a far and buildings are pretty close to the water. People may get the wrong impression with all the runpiece but keep in mind that CP0 made more than the size of the island by skywalking in no time (going to PR).









Punk Records is roughly half the size of EH:



As you can see its pretty small for an island:


 
Top