Powers & Abilities So what exactly is the difference between Roger’s, Xebec’s, Shanks’s, and Rayleigh’s fighting styles?

[soupongo]

It hurts you that you have to acknowledge them all an swordsmen doesn't it? Nowhere left to move the goalpost lol

Why would I care? Leechawk got his title after all the great swordsman died and he got to fight none of them. Him and Zoro are like guys trying to become the greatest swordsman in the 20th century when everyone has guns.

The same reason Mihawk is the strongest until Zoro surpasses him. Rhymes with khaki

Mihawk presumably trains a lot and had rivals etc, we were literally just introduced to Rocks as a top tier, with zero mentions of him training ever or fighting anyone. So why would he be able to fight Roger/Garp at the same time, who also have kings haki? It doesn´t even make sense.

Also, Haki is a dogshit power system that Oda added a decade into the manga anyway.

 

[Shiroyru]

So the last straw Shanks fans got is height scaling.

Height scaling is infallible

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

What’s funny is that Oda is gonna have Shanks > Mihawk anyways. Height scaling confirms Oda has Shanks above Mihawk (admittedly the reason will probably be dumb af, but this is Oda we’re talking about, logic doesn’t matter in modern OP)

So height scaling is valid but not Oda telling you Mihawk is stronger than Shanks?

 

[сука]

Height scaling is infallible

Funny how this cope initially came from reddit, who always claim Zoro = Sanji, and at times even Sanji > Zoro "because of their styles", despite Zoro being the 1cm taller one. Schrodinger's height scaling.

 

[Midnight Delight]

I see you all are still making these weird ass Thesis about Swordsmanship in One Piece again

 

[Shiroyru]

So height scaling is valid but not Oda telling you Mihawk is stronger than Shanks?

Height scaling has a 100% win rate so far. Title scaling has a 0% win rate so far

 

[Shiroyru]

I see you all are still making these weird ass Thesis about Swordsmanship in One Piece again

?

My post was literally just “?” lol

 

[Midnight Delight]

I really hope you all realise that Oda doesn't care about any of this at the end of the day

 

[сука]

Height scaling has a 100% win rate so far. Title scaling has a 0% win rate so far

Law cucks after googling Buggy's height

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Height scaling has a 100% win rate so far. Title scaling has a 0% win rate so far

It's not about what you think, Oda said he's stronger so he is.

 

[shadowdancer]

All of them use kenjutsu but different styles

 

[soupongo]

Law cucks after googling Buggy's height

Has there ever been an argument against height scaling that wasn´t just being disingenuous about the claim?
(that it´s about rivals)

 

[сука]

Has there ever been an argument against height scaling that wasn´t just being disingenuous about the claim?
(that it´s about rivals)

What's disingenuous is trying to argue Zoro/Sanji or King/Queen as rivals when these dudes are literally crewmates and they never had a serious fight against each other. The only "1cm difference rivals" are Shanks and Mihawk and the portrayal favors Mihawk.

 

[Shiroyru]

It's not about what you think, Oda said he's stronger so he is.

By your logic, Oda also said Sickbeard > Mihawk

 

[Shiroyru]

What's disingenuous is trying to argue Zoro/Sanji or King/Queen as rivals when these dudes are literally crewmates and they never had a serious fight against each other. The only "1cm difference rivals" are Shanks and Mihawk and the portrayal favors Mihawk.

Your idol literally dreams about beating Sanji, but sure, keep spouting this disingenuous BS bud

 

[soupongo]

What's disingenuous is trying to argue Zoro/Sanji or King/Queen as rivals when these dudes are literally crewmates and they never had a serious fight against each other. The only "1cm difference rivals" are Shanks and Mihawk and the portrayal favors Mihawk.

Mfw autism about what ¨rival¨ means in this context

 

[сука]

Your idol literally dreams about beating Sanji, but sure, keep spouting this disingenuous BS bud

In fan-requested cover pages he dreams of beating Sanji, in Oda's canon he dreams of beating Shanks' superior

 

[HA001]

Your idol literally dreams about beating Sanji, but sure, keep spouting this disingenuous BS bud

That's a fan request

 

[Shiroyru]

That's a fan request

A fan request that Oda willingly chose to draw

 

[сука]

A fan request that Oda willingly chose to draw

WHAO! What's next? He'll be willing to answer questions on sbs?